Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 43.
(continued from page 5)
. . . have been written had another shade of party threatened to endanger the organisation as a whole. On the contrary, it is acknowledged that Orthodoxy has hitherto preserved Judaism, and nothing is more ardently desired than that all the Orthodox should join Zionism — as Zionists. In life outside the framework of the movement they may pursue Orthodoxy as much as they will . . ."
What the article aimed at was, on the one hand, to bring about a clarification of the situation through the discussion which could be expected to follow it; and, on the other, should there be a tendency within the Misrachi prepared to propagate Orthodoxy even at the expense of Zionism, or indeed to its peril, to warn it against this and hold it back.
It was therefore by no means a polemic, but was written precisely in the interest of preserving peace in the party, by drawing attention to the dangers which seemed to threaten that peace and which ought to be met in good time. It would be reckless simply to wait for the dangers and to concern oneself with them only when they can no longer be averted. In a well-conducted movement threatening dangers must be foreseen and opposed while they are still arising.
From the programmatic resolutions of the Misrachi at Pressburg, which were quoted word for word, it had logically to be concluded that the Misrachi wished to propagate Orthodoxy within the general movement of Zionism as well. This was described as dangerous and warned against. The possibility of an error arising from incomplete reporting was, however, not excluded, and a correction on this point was declared to be desirable.
A clarification of the situation, if only in part, has in fact now been brought about by the discussion. The relevant statements of Dr. Adler and of the official circular of the Misrachi culminate in this: that the Misrachi never intended to carry on Orthodox propaganda within the Zionist movement at that movement's expense; and in the circular the Pressburg programme too is interpreted in this sense. There is now no reason to interpret this programme otherwise than the leadership of the Misrachi itself does, and this interpretation is gladly taken note of as the desired correction, and the wish and hope expressed that this standpoint will always be maintained in future too, and will accord with the actions of the Misrachi.
One point, however, has not yet been cleared up — indeed, it has not been touched upon by so much as a word. The article "Achtung" also pointed to the danger which the creation of an organisation within the organisation carries with it, and set forth its illegality under the statute of the organisation. On this point our fellow Zionists of the Misrachi keep entirely silent. It is, however, anything but a matter of indifference, and an explanation on this head too will therefore be gladly awaited. עוזר.
Paris Letter.
On the evening of Saturday, the 8th of October, Dr. Alexander Marmorek opened the Zionist "season" with a great programmatic address in the society "Mebassereth Zion."
Dr. Marmorek first described the general situation of our movement after the passing of Dr. Herzl. He then spoke at particular length of the various currents which, since the death of our never-to-be-forgotten leader, have been seeking with greater confidence to assert themselves.
First of all, he said, one must remember the old "Chowewe Zion," who believe that their time has come once more. These are the people who have learned nothing and forgotten nothing. As promoters of the first colonisation efforts the "Chowewe Zion" are forerunners of our political endeavours, and as such are assured of our gratitude; but we have long since passed beyond these beginnings. It would mean a return to primitive stages in the development of our idea were we, after seven years of political Zionism, to go back to the work of the "Chowewe Zion." There may well be naïvely honest people who are of the opinion that the Jewish people can really be helped by the support of a school, the building of a house, or even the founding of a colony in Palestine; but we do not see our task in undertakings of that kind. They may satisfy people who cannot even grasp what a political movement means, and who would bring to nothing Dr. Herzl's great work, the political and national rebirth of our people, in favour of petty undertakings. Such tendencies — and we know who propagates them and would gladly make them dominant in our movement again just now — are calculated to rob our movement of its popular character and to strip it of its national character. We Zionist workers of the West do not wish to further such endeavours, which proceed from the politically unfree cities of the East. For us Zionism is an ideal to which we adhere only as a political and national movement; only in political Zionism can we strive for the solution of the whole Jewish question.
A second current which now believes its time has come is that of the "Misrachi." The union of the Misrachists believed it necessary at Pressburg to "enlarge" our programme. The matter at issue was the alleged religious elaboration of the programme. When some time ago people came forward who propagated a free-thinking Fraction in our movement, they were decisively rebuffed. The Fraction, too, dissolved again after a very short existence. Now our Orthodox wish to try in black the same experiment which the adherents of the Fraction undertook without success in red. We can well understand, in the light of its development, the Orthodox standpoint which a number of Zionists take up in their religious position; we certainly respect their religious feeling too; for every Jew, even the most convinced free-thinker, has a spark of religious feeling within him, since our religion is indeed a national one. We also know very well that it was the often exaggerated fencing-about of the Law by the rabbis of the Ghetto which rendered Judaism great services in perilous times. But all this cannot induce us to declare religious views of any kind binding upon the adherents of our movement. It is a great danger for the future of our people should such endeavours regain influence among us. This everlasting dragging of religious views into matters which on quite another
