No. 43. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
On the Question of Organisation.
Zionism finds itself at the moment in a state of ferment. Above all, the loss of our leader of genius: it is not merely a question of a person, but of a system, for the person was so great that he embodied an entire system. With the disappearance of the former, the latter too must undergo some curtailments and alterations. And the more resolutely we adapt ourselves to the new conditions, the better for the further progress of Zionism.
A further cause of the ferment lies in the internal party divisions of the movement, which are likewise necessities of life. On the one side "Misrachi", on the other "Poale Zion", between them a whole scale of intermediate stages — all these groupings have, and must have, a right to exist within the Zionist Organisation.
Finally, the questions of the Land and of the lands have also not yet been entirely answered.
In a word, a whole series of circumstances creates a certain indefiniteness with regard to the future modalities of organisation of the Zionist movement. If, then, we were to wish to give definitive forms to our organisation even now, we run the risk of creating something unstable and provisional. Frequent alteration of the organisation, however, is very harmful and must be avoided as far as possible.
We are therefore in complete agreement with the declaration of Dr. Klee and Dr. Hantke, namely, "that the time is not now ripe to carry out a general and thorough-going alteration of the Organisation Statute".
We also agree with them in this, that for the present it can only be a question of amending § 23 of our Organisation Statute.
On this we should now like to make a few remarks.
Above all we must point out that we must strive to compose the Inner A.-C. of members who live, or can live, in the same city. If we rely upon the members being able to assemble every two or three months and deliberate together, we run the risk that in fact the two or three members who live in the same city or near one another will form the centre, and that this centre will in fact do everything by itself. On the other hand, Zionism is still too unified a phenomenon for us to be able to conceive of various departments acting independently. "Questions of uplift" are so bound up with "internal affairs" and "finances" that there can be no talk whatever of independent departments. Either a single person must administer all three departments, or else the three heads must always go hand in hand, that is, be able to consult one another at any moment. That, however, is possible only if they live in the same city.
Incidentally, we should like to know what is actually understood by questions of uplift, and how one person can master all these questions. For in the first place, so far as we know, by uplift is understood the work of the present, which must be at once of a spiritual and of a material nature.
Now a person may very well understand all the questions of Judaism, of national-spiritual uplift, and at the same time possess not the faintest idea of the complicated economic questions. And then comes physical uplift, for which a hygienist would be more fitted than an economist or a Judaist. And then, altogether, it would have to be a man of quite extraordinary — impossible — qualities who could judge the questions of uplift according to the different countries of the Diaspora. The questions of uplift do not, in our opinion, belong within the competence of the central leadership at all, but within that of the various national organisations.
The same appears to us to hold good of the department of "Questions of the Russian Organisation". When one speaks of party divisions within Zionism, one must think above all of Russia. We should thus have to have in the Smaller A.-C. as many representatives of the Russian national organisation as there are factions within it. By this, however, the unity of the leadership would suffer disturbance. And this unity must be our highest aim.
Had the proposal of the German Zionists been adopted, we should in fact have the same thing as before: unity would be guaranteed only by the chairman of the A.-C., but with the tremendous difference that the new chairman would be no Herzl.
We therefore think that one had better keep to the old system: an Inner A.-C. of only five members, who live in the same city and who together direct all affairs.
It is indeed possible that the Commission for Palestinian Affairs may be in another city, because this Commission must possess a certain independence and because its activity is of a quite particular nature. We also imagine that in the Inner A.-C. there will also be a Russian Zionist, not as "representative of the Russian national organisation", but simply as a collaborator.
Our proposal, however, is bound up with another condition: the payment of salaries to our members of the Actions Committee. Only in that case can we choose the suitable men, who will then be able to devote their whole strength to Zionist work. We by no means wish thereby to criticise the previous workers and leaders of our organisation; rather we wish to point out that under the present circumstances, and under the influence of the terrible example of our departed leader, we must absolutely insist that all our leaders be salaried, so that all of them without exception may devote themselves to the movement.
We should thus have a five-member Actions Committee, at whose head would stand the director of political affairs. In addition, the Inner A.-C. would have charge of the internal administration (finances, agitation and press) and of legal affairs, the several departments being distributed among the various members, of whom at least one must be a Russian Zionist. Independently of the Inner A.-C. we should also have the Palestine Commission, the directorate of the legally constituted National Fund, and the presidency of the Colonial Bank. The last three institutions need not necessarily reside where the Inner A.-C. functions. To speak openly, we imagine the matter thus: that the Inner A.-C. should have its seat in Vienna, the Palestine Commission in Berlin, and the directorate of the National Fund and of the Colonial Bank in London. At the same time, however, we must insist that no important decision may be taken without the Inner A.-C. consulting with the heads of the other permanent bodies, so that we should indeed have to require that such joint sessions take place about every two months.
Our proposal proceeds from the actual conditions, since it is a matter of impossibility nine members of the Inner A.-C. in one city to-
