Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 41 · 7 October 1904
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 41 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

We look forward with interest to the report of the executive on the first federation year now concluded. We must not set the Federation of the Jewish Gymnasts' Union tasks which do not correspond to the present state of the Jewish gymnastic movement; but we expect that, within the limits marked out, it will accomplish that which alone grants it the justification for its existence: practical national work!

Letter from Croatia.

There lies a peculiar, mysterious power in the Young Jewish movement, in Zionism. Precisely in a country which showed so little Jewish life, and where everything Jewish was in a state of torpor, if not indeed of dissolution, the working of Zionism can be clearly discerned. A few years ago not represented at all, then represented by two or three rabbis and a handful of students, Zionism, the Jewish national idea, is now advancing all along the line in Croatia.

When on the 6th of August the first Jewish Students' Congress from the South Slav lands met at Osijek, the eyes of a large part of the Croatian public, and doubtless of all Croatian Jews, were turned upon Zionism. Zionism passed this first test in Croatia brilliantly, and there has already been detailed mention in the "Welt" of how the whole Croatian press, and especially that of Osijek, treated Zionism sympathetically, and at the least not in a hostile spirit, and most warmly approved the demonstrations for the Croatian language and fatherland; and further, of how in the citizens' meeting and at the Congress recognition was unanimously paid to the Jewish national idea, to Zionism.

But on the same day Zionism also met with a harsh censure, for the "Agramer Zeitung" of the 6th of August contained, evidently from an "also-Israelite" pen, a fiery leading article against Zionism, in which the following passages occurred:

"But when a part of the Croatian youth of the Jewish confession, in an entirely superfluous manner, sets itself up as Zionists and raises a question which is no longer a question; when this part of the youth sets about erecting barriers against which, until no long time ago, judicious and reasonable men fought, until at last they succeeded in tearing them down and in softening and reconciling the antagonisms; and when the spread of Zionist doctrines, which for the rest we doubt, should gain ground — then it is time that the level-headed men who stand at the head of the Jewish communities should put a premature end to the dangerous doings of a few hotheads. It is likewise a duty of the Jewish spiritual pastors to confine themselves to the teaching of religion and to make no propaganda for an idea which proves to be a Utopia and which severs the life-artery of a whole generation. Besides the cultivation of religious instruction, regard should indeed be had to the history of Judaism as well; but, in view of the peculiar circumstances of the Jews, no nourishment may be given to such ideas as are calculated to estrange them from the nation in whose midst they live. One should rather have no other goal before one's eyes than to make one's own and to further the national spirit of the country, for every nation has the right to demand that all its citizens and inhabitants be merged in it in national respects.

"Thus, for example, the Jewish denominational school forms such an antagonism, as does the founding of the 'Zidovska omladina'. Both are based upon separatist tendencies and lay the germ of discord and estrangement in the minds of tender youth, which ought surely to be avoided under all circumstances."

Even if we do not long rack our brains over the question what "the inhabitants of a nation" may actually be, we can easily see what these observations mean to say. Everything that we have inherited from our fathers that is specifically Jewish must be destroyed, and our teachers of religion must themselves falsify and remodel Jewish history, lest pride and love for Judaism should spring up in the youth. All Jewish institutions must be dissolved: the schools, the societies for Jewish history and literature, the charitable institutions, and so forth. No words of refutation are surely needed against this programme, which was summed up at the Osijek Congress by the assimilationists in a few clear words: "We must have ourselves baptised, or else it will come to a Kischenew." The observations above decidedly drive towards baptism too, and doubtless all who are brought up in this spirit must arrive at baptism. But only if Jewish history is falsified can one hope that mass baptism will bring about assimilation. For centuries the Marranos were Roman Catholic Christians, and their belonging to the Jewish people brought them back again to the Jewish faith.

On the day of Schemini Azereth a level-headed man, who has stood for nearly forty years at the head of the largest Jewish community of Croatia, Zagreb's Chief Rabbi Dr. Hosea Jakobi, raised his voice. With youthful enthusiasm, with sonorous voice, he spoke to the assembled congregation of Dr. Theodor Herzl and his life's work. "Herzl devoted his life to the Jewish people, and he succeeded, in the East and in the West, wherever there are Jews, in gathering them as one united people of brothers. Though many may call his work a dream — the future will show whether it really was one. But immense is what has already been achieved: the awakening of Jewish self-consciousness in the Jewish youth. Where years ago there was only aversion and antipathy, there reigns to-day the greatest pride and zeal for the Jewish cause. Therefore we have no fear that shameful assimilation will prevail, since Judaism has proved anew its inexhaustible vital force through Herzl's work. We are loyal sons of our Croatian fatherland, but for that very reason we must also remain Jews and most faithfully further the brethren who are already in Zion or wish to go thither."

The address was no fighting or party speech, but only a festival sermon such as a Jewish rabbi delivers before his congregation. There are a great many of them, doubtless indeed the majority, who are not adherents of the organisation, but surely no one who is loyally minded towards Judaism stands without sympathy towards the Zionist idea, the reawakening of Jewish life. Hence Dr. Jakobi's address on Dr. Theodor Herzl met, doubtless with all, with warm understanding, for together with his earlier addresses on the cultural and humanitarian institutions of the community here it forms a firm programme.

Though not by name, I must nevertheless mention that in almost all communities the rabbis delivered detailed, deeply felt addresses on Dr. Theodor Herzl and his work. Even if not all are in the organisation of Zionism, yet all are sympathetically disposed towards it, and one of them gave the reason for this aptly: "I am very sympathetically disposed towards Zionism, for I have a heart for Judaism and therefore for the mighty