Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 34
From England.
It is well known that the Alien Bill has failed in the House. Strictly speaking, it did not fail. The Government did not let matters go so far. When it saw that the Bill was meeting with so strong a resistance that the Government might in the end actually stumble over it, it resolved rather to withdraw the Bill. But it was not a withdrawal brought about by better judgment and by enlightenment as to the true state of affairs — it was no proof that the Government was seriously minded to deal with the pauper question in England in some other way than by prohibiting Jewish immigration — no, it was a simple move on the chessboard by the Ministry. What the Government aims at with its general policy cannot concern us here — we are asking here about the Jewish policy of the Ministry. It is of this that we speak.
I do not mean to say by this that the present English Government pursues a Jewish policy, that is, has specially taken the Jewish question into view. For that the Ministry is, after all, too conservative. Conservative in two directions. On the one hand, clinging too strongly to the traditions of the past century to pursue a policy of nationalities and confessions — on the other, too slow and conservative to be able to regard the Jewish question from the new, historical, wider point of view.
For the Jewish question has now, more than ever, ceased to be a local question — it has become a component part of world-politics, like the Eastern question. And just as the "Platform", the inaugural programme, of every Ministry was once its attitude towards the Eastern question, which after all touched England only indirectly, just as Cabinets fell on account of this question, so the Jewish question will become an integral component, a point of the programme. Be it well understood: not the Jewish question as it is conceived on the Continent — for that England is, after all, too mature — but in the sense of a great policy.
But it is not James Arthur Balfour, the deliberate, cautious, slow doubter, who is more a man of feeling than a Rhodesian politician, who is the man for it. He already regrets, indeed, that he withdrew the Aliens Bill. So he expresses himself in a letter to Hon. W. F. D. Smith, chairman of the London Unionist Members of Parliament. "He regrets the necessity of withdrawing the Bill in view of the opposition on the part of the Radical members of the Standing Committee". From every point of view, he holds, this is a question of high importance, and no time must be lost in mastering the difficulties. Whether the anti-alienists feel strengthened by the attitude of the Ministry, whether they still believe in the final victory of their cause — they are for the present continuing their agitation and are seeking to gain a footing once more. For foreign policy, with its immense perspectives — the Russo-Japanese war, the occupation of Lhassa, etc. — has put internal questions in the shade. But the gentlemen do not wish to be forgotten. And they have again issued a manifesto, signed by Sir Henry Seton-Karr, M.P., Mr. D. J. Morgan M.P. and Major Evans-Gordon M.P., in which the necessity of extending the work of the Immigration Reform Association is spoken of. That is all very fine, but is that all they mean? Does not the cloven hoof then follow?
I should like to touch upon one more question, which I should otherwise prefer to leave undiscussed. I mean the Shechita affair. Every year, almost periodically, discussions on ritual slaughter recur. Sometimes it is decided in favour of tradition, more often against it. But that such a question could arise in England too is curious indeed. England, it is true, is also the place where sentimentality has its hearth and its stronghold; it is true that there, for example, the fight against vivisection was waged most bitterly; but the question of Shechita! These everlasting opinions of the rabbis and of the "experts", of the physicians, etc.!
How did the Admiralty, which first raised the question, ever come to do so? A pity. — England does, after all, learn a good deal from the Continent. And what it learns is not exactly the best.
But all these are, in the end, matters of subordinate importance. A truly Jewish policy is in England only in statu nascendi, in the process of becoming. And we will hope that it will make a worthy appearance there. For among the English Jews who busy themselves in politicis, not all are like Messrs. Lucien Wolf or Louis Sinclair. There are also those who have not only a Jewish heart but also a "Jewishly" thinking head. And it will depend on them — the Hon. Members of Parliament and those who might be such — whether we really gain consideration in England and exercise upon the destiny of the entire Jewish nation the influence we might attain. For a piece of the Rule Britannia glory has passed over to us as well. It is simply so. The "Law of contingency", I might almost say. There sit in the House of Commons 11 Jewish members. The one most lately elected — last week at Reading — is Mr. Rufus Isaacs, K. C., one of the most celebrated English lawyers, a very interesting personality, a genuinely Jewish type, a self made man, something of a Chamberlain. He was first a merchant, and a successful one, then turned to the Bar, and is now one of the greatest English advocates. Thus a "Minjan" and a surplus besides of Jewish members at Westminster. At all events a great advance. In the year 1895 there were only 8 members. But what will the growing number of members avail? Did not the last division in the Alien Bill debate prove how disunited, how widely divergent are the views of the individual gentlemen in Jewish matters? Some, indeed, even voted against the Jews. And that is really not quite so monstrous. Each of the members is, after all, elected on a certain programme. Ministerial or anti-ministerial. He must then vote with his group if he wishes to have a firm footing. And that is the whole misfortune, that the Jewish members do not form a "Jewish" group. Not, indeed, in the sense in which the Irish party is one — the Jews cannot demand Home Rule in England — but "Jewish" in the sense that they safeguard the interests of the Jewish people wherever these come into question. And when the gentlemen do so — they will be no dangerous innovators, but will walk in the footsteps of the great old Dizzy, who wished it, who dreamed of it. Then the time was not yet ripe — now the Jewish people has struggled through and upward by its own strength — now it is for them, the Jewish representatives in the greatest Parliament of Europe, to carry out the work...
Spectator.
Dr. Gaster and the Zionist Movement.
A Letter from L. J. Greenberg.
Honoured Sir,
Permit me a few remarks on the occasion of Dr. Gaster's article in "Ost und West".
Dr. Gaster endeavours to create the impression that the differences of opinion between him and Dr. Herzl had their beginning with the East African question. That is far removed from the true facts. Years ago, before the East Africa project