Page 8. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 27.
(continued from page 7)
…first of all the ways and aims of social relief work, of popular education, of the furtherance of the earning life of Jewish women and girls, the raising of morality, the combating of the traffic in girls, etc.; b) in awakening interest in the general Jewish endeavours of the present day and by strengthening the Jewish consciousness of community."
In these words there is everything. In fact a great deal that is good and desirable. Unhappily this did not emerge in the same way from the verbal interpretations. From the address of the chairwoman, for example, it would follow that the only, or at least the only essential, tasks of the League would be the Galician question and the combating of the traffic in girls. We are, to be sure, in the charming position that wherever one touches us it pinches and hurts, and that of an endlessly long series of necessary works of relief each one is truly necessary and the most necessary of all. Now the Galician Jews are indeed one of the sore and sorest wounds of Jewry as a whole. When, then, the chairwoman so clearly sets forth the altruistic and egoistic reasons that speak for occupying oneself with this question — to support the poor and to spare oneself, to send them money at home and not to have to see them — the matter is perfectly plain to all the ladies. It is truly far from me to mock at the Jewish charitable disposition, and especially at the well-known good Jewish woman's heart. But are the rich Jewish women in Germany really so moved by the misery of the Galician Jews that they find no nearer and more essential task for themselves — and had the assembled ladies nothing to add, passing straightway to the more important questions of forming the committee? There was a lively discussion: one proposed 15 members, another 17, but a third only 12! In the midst of this fundamental debate there threatened, for one moment, to arise a debate on the programme after all, when one lady pointed to the necessity of spreading education in the smaller towns. She called forth no contradiction; further additions, too, proved entirely superfluous, all the more as the chairwoman promised to take all wishes into account. Pardon — one Frau Professor did speak on the statutes as such. For the programme, it is true, we heard nothing new, but the address was instructive none the less; we learned some important historical data about the activity of an international and interdenominational women's charitable society, in which, to be sure, the Frau Professor had already in the year 1887 (if only I have rightly remembered the date!) accomplished very beneficial things.
So all was on the best of paths, in most laudable concord, when almost at the close a little storm threatened to break, called forth, of course, by a peace-disturbing — Zionist lady. She held that the draft could not be adopted en bloc, since it did not contain essential points such as the Jewish education of the young and the cultivation of Jewish history and literature. A grim storm passed through the hall. The one Frau Professor and the other, and the Frau Direktor, well-bred, pious women all, who shortly before had used the most amiable and choicest parliamentary expressions — they all seemed right vexed, and very nearly, very nearly they would have had to permit themselves a sharper word. The little nose grew pointed, and in a vexed tone the identical rebuff was hastily blurted out: There are, after all, literary societies which carry on so beneficent an activity; one must not meddle in their trade. So she spoke, and quickly sat down again, and approving applause from the meeting was the well-earned reward for the courageous words. The chairwoman, however, declared profoundly that all social work means education. The incident was closed, and quiet and peace returned. Peace, too, was what the chairwoman laid chief weight upon, closing the meeting with the words "ישמם לך שלום".
But we shudder at this absolute quiet, at this deathly stillness in which nothing stirs, at this silent emptiness. We should gladly have completed the parting words: לחיים, "ולשלום!" more life! More youth!
Of this we were able to convince ourselves once again: that if we wish to accomplish real social work, the soft heart and the full purse of the Frau Kommerzienrat are in truth not enough, and that we have need of our youth.
j.
Paragraph 17 of the Alliance Statutes.
By Dr. Elias, Mülhausen i. Els.
Paragraph 17 of the Alliance statutes contains the following provision: The committees of the local groups and regional associations are to be elected anew every year. On the strength of this paragraph I called upon the committee of the Mülhausen local group of the Alliance in the autumn of 1903, the committee having been elected three years before, to hold new elections. That the committee had held office for 3 years without submitting yearly to re-election I could only ascribe to the circumstance that it did not know the statutes. I was therefore convinced that it would comply with my suggestion without reluctance. But I was mistaken. The Mülhausen committee would hear nothing of the statutes; it knew only the principle: J'y suis, j'y reste.
It first gave me the vague answer that it did not wish to remain in office for ever; when the suitable moment had come, a new election should be held. When I did not rest content with this answer, it sought to pacify me with the assurance that the elections would be held as soon as possible. Instead, however, of acting in accordance with this assurance, it asked for instructions from the General Secretariat of the Alliance in Paris, and received the astounding reply: The statutes, it was true, were still legally in force; but they were antiquated and were followed only in the rarest cases; new elections should be held only if a larger number of the society's members demanded them.
This reply was communicated to me after long delay. I declared that it was not binding upon me. It was improper to ask advice on self-evident matters. Neither the Central Committee nor the General Secretariat in Paris had the right, of their own sovereign authority, to abrogate or modify the society's statutes or to interpret them in a manner contrary to their sense. The statutory rights of the society's members might under no circumstances be infringed. If the Mülhausen committee would not hold the new elections itself, I should on my own initiative convene a general meeting of the Mülhausen members and carry through a new election. I had the right to such a course, since the committee de jure no longer existed.
My threat had the expected effect; it set the stone rolling. On Sunday, the 5th of June, the election took place. I did not succeed in bringing into the committee the elements I had wished for. On the other hand, the re-election of the previous chairman, who was responsible for the violation of the statutes, was prevented. The newly elected chairman gave me his promise to tolerate no further violations of the statutes and to submit again to re-election after the lapse of a year.