Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 27
(continued from page 3)
…to found this settlement in this part of East Africa, or in another, was a different question. And he imagined that to an administrator the proposal to introduce a community speaking a foreign tongue would appear to involve so many difficulties that he would not wish to be responsible for the good government of the country. After Mr. Grey had set forth at some length his demand that the reasons which, as Earl Percy admitted, Sir Ch. Eliot had raised against the Jewish immigration should be made known, Mr. Lloyd George rose to speak. He said that he was not opposed to the founding of a Jewish colony, but he would like to learn the objections of Sir Ch. Eliot, and also whether this had been one of the reasons for his resignation at all.
The Prime Minister, Mr. Balfour: No.
Earl Percy: It would be more exact to say that Sir Charles Eliot had expressed his opinion in two different ways. His later opinion was unfavourable to the project. But it had nothing whatever to do with his resignation.
Mr. Lloyd George then observed that if the matter stood thus, he had nothing against the Jewish settlement. There were enough Jews whom we could spare. (Laughter) But he did not agree with the antisemitic sentiments displayed by an Irish Member. It was, after all, merely a question of safeguarding the rights of the natives and preserving peace in East Africa.
The motion was rejected.
By the Wayside.*)
II.
A little off the road. We turn in. A well-trodden, familiar road, a highway. Scarcely anything new to discover. But did not Dickens once say that it is precisely in familiar phenomena that interesting observations may be made? And the road on which we now set foot leads to the cemetery. In the distance graves are visible, fresh ones and crumbling ones, and towards the cemetery move ever new funeral processions, dark, draped in black crape. Dreams and hopes are here carried to the grave; here an end is made of a long and glorious history. An end — is it at least a fine one? Great as the life was?
I speak of assimilationist Judaism and of its convulsive attempts at least to "save" religion. A hackneyed theme — that is true. To speak of assimilationist Judaism is indeed to force an open door. Is it not a chose jugée? But nevertheless the question often presses upon us, and we cannot ward it off. Here and there it breaks forth, the beatified Reform and assimilationist Judaism, and announces to an astonished world that it still lives. Whether it really lives is a question. It may perhaps be the subject of our further reflections to discuss assimilation in all its manifestations; for the present we wish only to make an excursion, and be it only a hasty one, through the most important province of those Jews mad for assimilation who yet did not wish to turn their backs on Judaism altogether, of the de-Judaized who are nevertheless still stuck fast in Judaism — through that of religious reform . .
It always grieves me to read how the Western "assimilants" strive to maintain themselves somehow. You perhaps hate the assimilants; I pity them, because they are so weak, so small. Tout comprendre, c'est tout pardonner. And when one understands
*) Vide "Die Welt" No. 26.
whence the weakness springs, and that it is a weakness, one forgives it readily enough. One forgives him who is unfit for life, who is a candidate for death, for committing follies too in order somehow to save himself. The poor "modern" rabbis! How they wear themselves out to preserve their congregations from decay in this way or that!
And they are falling to pieces, the Jewish communities of the West In France, in Italy it is an everyday occurrence. And the greater the dispersion of the Jewish people, the more threatening is complete decay, utter dissolution. And what do the shepherds of souls, the modern rabbis, do against it? If the sermons are of no avail, which alas are so often tedious and often again enough to split one's sides, then it is supposed that the Jewish ritual is too narrow, too burdensome for the citizen of the Mosaic persuasion who deals in stocks and votes Conservative. And the poor rabbis begin to reform the Jewish synagogue. Thereupon the Geigerians remodelled the old Schul, and shaped it and painted it and fitted it with organs and Christianized it. But it was of no avail. The citizen was not attracted even by this bait. The effect failed to come. And we believed — we impartial observers of theological disputes — that the reformers had after all perceived the absurdity of their undertaking and were convinced of the fruitlessness of their efforts. Is this, then, the time for religious reforms? Reform means remodelling; it means a patching and an accommodating of the old to the new. Our age does not strive after such petty-bourgeois, second-hand-dealer's remodellings and revisions we want new formations, creations . . . That the reformers have not learned and will hardly learn. What little Hans does not learn, etc. Or perhaps he will after all; in the end even little Hans learns, when life handles him roughly enough. And what these reform endeavours look like! A downright misery. One involuntarily recalls the religious reform movements of earlier centuries in the synagogue. A Luria, an Akosta, a Bescht. What greatness, what moral earnestness!
Those men believed and carried others with them. But he who himself wavers in his faith cannot possibly convert others. And whereas the religious reformers of past times were real revolutionaries, even if unconscious ones, the Jewish reformers of to-day are petty cobbler-souls, who seek to prop up the tottering edifice of the Jewish community by a few unessential modifications of the Jewish ritual, by the introduction of irreligious, because purely secular, requisites of entertainment, à la organ, theatrical trappings, etc. I happen to read in the "Frankfurter isr. Familienblatt" a notice about a "reform" of this kind in the congregation in the West End of Frankfort-on-Main. The reform is to consist in the prayers being rattled off in the German language, in a form "abridged" and "revised" by a rabbi, to "choral singing and organ accompaniment". Dangerous, revolutionary! The poor, timid "Frankfurter isr. Familienblatt" raises a fearful hue and cry and protests against these innovations. It holds that the salvation of Judaism lies in the conservatism it represents. Possibly, — but possibly not. I should indeed be heartily glad to go along with the "Radicals" in religious questions too. Yet I must confess my sympathy for the Conservatives. And that for another reason. I believe that the road taken by the "Radicals" is an uncommonly ridiculous one — and ridicule is the most terrible thing in the world. Religion is scarcely capable of any serious remodelling. One must grow beyond a religion, or grow into it. There is no middle road here. Half-heartedness
