Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 24 · 10 June 1904
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

"Die Welt"

From England.

Mr. Lucien Wolf keeps always on the surface of Jewish life. Every time, he rises up to combat this or that movement and current in Jewry. And the ideals of Wolf, for which he takes sides and in whose name he speaks, are the old-conservative, ostrich-policy ones, in the social as in the national regard. Mr. Wolf is one of those personalities who wholly lack the true sense for the living, pulsing endeavour, for the warm, many-coloured life of their time. But neither have they any true, clarified historical sense. They treat the present from the historical standpoint, and in history let themselves be guided by preconceived opinions and by influences of every sort. In the Jewish Question Mr. Wolf is the spokesman of the Tories, if I may so express myself. He is the ideologue of that old, rationalist-bourgeois Jewish view of the world which springs partly from religious-dreamy but rather more from comfortable middle-class motives: the view of Israel's destiny among the nations, of the Jewish mission. It is one of the most insipid of views. Now there is no nonsense to which clever theories cannot be attached, which cannot be defended. And that is the case of Wolf, as of many another believer in the Mission. Mr. Wolf is averse to Zionism. And his reasons, too, he has set forth time and again. He has always taken the rich Jews under his protection against the poor, the well-fed individuals and their assimilatory cravings against the Jewish people, which wishes to live. And he knows only one thing to repeat over and over anew, and knows but one magic remedy, and that is "Assimilation." He does not even take the trouble to consider whether and how this is possible, and how this theory can be reconciled with a dream of mission. And when he does once raise this question, he gives an answer that we should scarcely expect from a modern man, an "Englishman" of the XXth century who is not a modern clergyman. For Wolf it suffices that the Jews preserve what he takes for religion; nothing else concerns him. And for the nth time he recently set forth these views of his in a lecture on "The Zionist Peril." It will be superfluous to reproduce the substance of his speech; it will suffice if I point out that among the arguments there was not a single new one, to say nothing of a correct one — words, nothing but words. The speech seems to have been worked up from a "Vade-mecum of the Anti-Zionist." But the "Jewish Chronicle" rejoiced over the find, blew merrily upon Wolf's Shofar, and of course associated itself with the view that Zionism is a peril. That is nothing new with the "Chronicle"; but the Zionists in London have, in my opinion, paid Wolf's speech an undue degree of attention. It is the easiest thing in the world to negate something, to destroy something; but even that must be done with skill. A little hut, an Irish peasant's cottage, may be demolished with quite primitive instruments; to set the same to an American sky-scraper would be a ridiculous undertaking. Well, Mr. Wolf means to get at the proud edifice of Zionism, rising ever higher and striving heavenward, with old, worn-out arguments and catchwords that have long since lost their power. Poor man!

Mr. Greenberg recently, in a speech at a meeting of the Central Committee of the English Zionist Federation held on May 29th under the chairmanship of Sir Francis Montefiore, dealt thoroughly with Wolf's speech. He refuted all the objections raised on the part of the English assimilationist Jews, and protested against the Jewish Question being again and again connected with the religious question, as though these two questions were identical. He said, among other things: "The 'Jewish Chronicle,' as well as Mr. Wolf, have not even grasped the fundamental principle of Zionism, that the Jews are a distinct race and a distinct people. This was not meant to say that the Jews cannot take their place as citizens among other nations; it was meant only to say that anthropologically they form a distinct race, that their hopes and wishes were different from those of other nations." .... Mr. Greenberg coined a fine hit when, in the course of his speech, he came to speak of English assimilationist Jewry. There he said, among other things: "The Zionists are often asked when they are going to Palestine. That could probably not be their immediate task. Meanwhile they were organizing the Jewish people, and had done so with a success such as no one had ever achieved before; they had awakened in it the self-respect which it had no longer possessed in recent times; they drove out the old notion of the Jewish people that it must speak only softly, with muffled voice — a notion to which Mr. B. L. Cohen gave expression when he complained that the Jews push themselves forward too much. Not by assimilation, as Mr. Wolf asserted — who, by the way, meant not assimilation but 'Ass—simulation' (donkey-dissembling) — will the Jewish people be saved; it can be saved only in the most Jewish sense of the word. That would be their task as Zionists, and this they can carry out everywhere, in all parts of the country, and not merely by holding meetings, but by quiet teaching wherever the opportunity may offer. Above all, the Zionists must instil into the young the new ideas of the self-reliance and self-help of the Jews, and through them drive out the old, narrow Ghetto ideas, until they come to regard the Zionist teaching as the salvation of Judaism, as the salvation of their people."

And since the Aliens Bill has become, so to speak, our "daily bread," I cannot refrain from directing the reader's attention here, too, to the latest letter of Sir Kenelm Digby in the "Times" and to the leading article of the "Times" appended to it. Sir Digby discusses the question from the Jewish standpoint and shows the untenability and impracticability of the Bill. In particular he turns against the clause of the Bill whereby the officials would have the right to declare the immigrant at their pleasure "desirable" or "undesirable." That is nothing less than the introduction of a police régime! And that in England, where the "Bobby" is truly nothing more than a guardian of order, and where the Habens-Corpus statute forms the foundation of legislation! It seems that legislation, instead of advancing, goes backward. For once upon a time the law of aliens was at the same time the law of enemies (hostis = enemy and stranger). The "Times" follows Sir Digby's letter with a leading article that attempts to defend the Bill and to weaken the objections. But Sir Kenelm Digby will not let himself be deterred in his agitation, and he has promised to follow with a new letter in which he will analyse the several points of the Bill still more closely.

Mr. Winston Churchill, M. P., too, declared himself against the Bill in a letter to the chairman of the Old Hebrew Congregation in Manchester, as did likewise the labour press and the labour representatives. And also