No. 24 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…had presided and at which Dr. Heinrich Loewe delivered the address, which closed in an enthusiastically received Hedâd for Dr. Theodor Herzl. Before the assembly of more than fifteen hundred persons Dr. Alfred Klee spoke with his accustomed mastery and to applause renewed again and again, kindling the indifferent and disarming the hostile. After him Dr. Paul Rieger spoke, with the honest fire of loyal conviction, as an opponent of Zionism, and made all the greater impression because his honest opposition is respected and because he showed himself a rhetorically most effective speaker. At the close he turned to the audience with the apostrophe: "And now — I know it — you will tear me to pieces and rend me asunder." Immediately after him Dr. Heinrich Loewe of Berlin spoke, and began, amid the general merriment of the assembly, thus: "And behold, a lion came up and tore him to pieces!" He then, to the thundering applause of the assembly, refuted and rent asunder Dr. Rieger's objections, and set against his orthodox-reformed Mosaic confession the national Judaism of a Moscheh-Rabbenu. A great part of his great success, to be sure, he owed to the eloquent but materially untenable arguments of Dr. Rieger, whose sympathetic personality defended a weak cause. Immediately after Loewe's rejoinder the numerous applications for membership in the local group began. In a brilliant closing speech Dr. Klee refuted the other opponents.
Thus the Hamburg meeting was, from beginning to end, a fine success, in which scarcely a blemish was to be noticed. Our confidence in our national leadership is firmer than before. For we now know that it neither wishes to replace or dilute national Judaism, nor thinks of a substitute Zion outside Zion. Thus the Hamburg meeting, not by bridging irreconcilable antagonisms but by making clear the opinions and views that really exist, has demonstrated before all the world, and strengthened anew, the unity of German Zionism. May the one shadow, too, soon vanish, which would not let our bright joy arise wholly undivided! So we close our report with the heartfelt wish that was voiced again and again at the Delegates' Conference, that our Theodor Herzl may soon be once more in full possession of the health so precious to us! Zionism to the fore in Judaism! Herzl to the fore in Zionism! Saxôni haz-Zaphôni.
The Political Situation.
Report delivered by Dr. Klee at the German Delegates' Conference.
Ladies and Gentlemen!
The Greater Actions Committee met in Vienna this spring. The resolutions of that session are known to you in their particulars. Nevertheless we have held it our duty to give the German Delegates' Conference a brief general survey of the development of the political situation of our movement since the Congress, that is, of the work which the Basle Programme demands in its last sentence, where it speaks of obtaining such governmental consents as are necessary for the attainment of the Zionist aim.
The foreign policy of Zionism, like all foreign policy, can be conducted only by a very small circle of persons: by the President of the Inner Actions Committee and by those to whom, in the several countries, he gives special commissions from case to case. In keeping with the discreet character of the work, criticism must be cautious. This has always been understood in German Zionism. We have always taken to heart the saying of that famous leader of German Liberalism, that one may make opposition, where occasion requires, only in questions of home policy, where one proceeds from definite principles whose realization one strives for; but that one must beware of meddling in questions of foreign policy, which are primarily questions of expediency and can be rightly judged only by him who holds all the threads in his hand, knows all the details, and indeed also bears the responsibility. It was another German politician who coined the phrase about the jack-boots with which the irresponsible critic often treads into finely-meshed nets.
We left Basle under the impression of two events: the East Africa project, and the declaration of the Russian Government in the letter of Herr v. Plehwe to Dr. Herzl.
Almost all the German delegates voted for the despatch of an expedition to East Africa. They understood England's offer as a political success. Great England had recognized the Jewish people as a national community and had declared itself ready to give this national community a political constitution. That was a significant advance. After Basle, however, a discussion of the East Africa question set in which frequently took a wrong direction, anxiously concerned friends making a stand against the possibility of substituting East Africa for Palestine. That, of course, had never been thought of by anyone. The question of a possible settlement of East Africa was, properly speaking, not yet open to discussion at all. Should the expedition decided upon bring unfavourable reports, the project fell; should it bring favourable ones, there was still time to broach the question of principle as well. In any case, after the unambiguous declarations of the party leadership, the question could never be put as "Palestine or East Africa?" but only ever as "East Africa and Palestine?", or at most the watchword might have been given out, "through East Africa to Palestine." The premature discussion, and the at the least superfluous campaign against the possibility of a way of putting the question which was not only wholly remote from the intentions of the party leadership but diametrically opposed to them, called forth much needless disquiet.
To this was added the illegal form of the Conference at Charkow. We had the great satisfaction that the most authoritative Russian leaders admitted the illegality of the Conference. We believe that these matters, which are now happily settled, have strengthened the sense of legality and the understanding of the absolute necessity of submitting to the resolutions of our organization. The Vienna protocol of settlement, which you know, contains, when closely examined, nothing but what is self-evident. It expresses satisfaction that the Inner Actions Committee has worked without interruption for Palestine, that the expedition decided upon by the Congress will and must set out, and that everyone remains free to discuss the East Africa question. Whether this last is really advisable, however, seems to me highly doubtful, and I should like to give expression to this doubt with regard to our own deliberations as well. After the return of the expedition the Greater Actions Committee will meet again to receive its report. Only when the Greater Actions Committee should then resolve to lay the East Africa project before the next Congress as a settlement project does discussion in the groups and at national conferences seem to me timely. To-day it means a waste of time and strength.*)
*) The Hamburg Delegates' Conference, following this suggestion, passed no resolutions on the East Africa question.
