Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 9 · 26 February 1904
2printed page
scan 2 of 20
Facsimile · scan 2 of 20
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 9

Until then, somewhere, a great calamity came, whose effects were felt far beyond the frontiers of the country. Then pity was called forth, worked up in fine appeals, and in the end it sufficed once more for beggar's broth and, if all went well, for the — repatriation of those who had not yet perished.

Whoever knows the history of the Jews in recent decades will know that we do not exaggerate. But one need not even trouble to read up on this history. It suffices to study the measures of the great Jewish organizations, whose very existence in itself bears witness to the utter failure of Jewish policy hitherto; for had that policy succeeded — indeed, did anyone so much as believe in its practicability — all these institutions would be purposeless, if not directly harmful.

Let us give an example. The "Alliance israélite universelle" is one of the oldest Jewish institutions. Had it always been conducted in the spirit of its founders, it might have been a blessing to Jewry. But from the brotherly union which it was meant to represent, it has become a charitable society, on which the airs of a great political body sit comically enough. That it lives upon its old renown would not be the worst of it. One lives upon a thing only until one has used it up. With the Alliance that moment is no longer far off, if it has not already come. At least its steady decline and the founding of rival societies in other countries speak strongly for the latter supposition. One might now expect that the conspicuous loss of influence and prestige would needs give the directors of this body pause. Far from it. With its conceit of infallibility, which has often amused its friends and foes even more than it has annoyed them; with its obstinacy, which clings to what has long been recognized as bad, merely so as not to have to admit a mistake; with its hostility towards all who would bring fresh forces to Jewry, it is a veritable textbook example of a Jewish organization as it ought not to be. Whatever sensible thing it does must be wrung from it in hard struggle. Only one speciality, of which Crémieux and Netter surely never dreamed, does it cultivate with passion. It relieves the bodily want of the Jews by founding French schools.

Strangely enough, the starving in Stat or Marrakesch are no better off, even though such a school exists in Casablanca. The Alliance, of course, learns this only when the refugees from those parts besiege its school and the director of it telegraphs, among other things, that he is still most profoundly shaken by the memory of the terrible misery. The Alliance helps, too; for it always has a kind heart for the plundered, the outraged, and beggars fleeing their country. And since it naturally cannot preserve even a few hundred persons from starvation for any length of time, it also issues a touching appeal. Doubtless at the next plenary meeting the presidency will relate with satisfaction to the honoured members of the society how the Alliance intervened in this calamity too, according to its time-honoured custom, and how it has proved once more that it stands faithfully at its post. Then will follow a moved murmur from the few who have not fallen asleep during the proceedings, and in conclusion a vote of confidence in the management.

Had one come to the Alliance a week before such a foreseeable, or even announced, catastrophe and called upon it to intervene, it would certainly have declared that this was not its office. The interest and the activity of the Alliance are not directed towards the thorough, systematic improvement of an untenable state of affairs. Only when a calamity has occurred does it provide for the victims, according to its modest powers and with immodest demands upon the purses of others. That too is a policy, but a policy that may expect anything rather than recognition.

Naturally the Alliance has had to intervene once more in the calamity that recently occurred in Morocco. It still feels itself obliged not to leave such unfortunates in the lurch. That is certainly praiseworthy. But its policy is thereby characterized to perfection. Not a trace of foresight, no intention of real help. The worst, for which its inaction or its perverse measures share the blame, it then seeks to patch up after a fashion. Instead of lasting help — an alms. The true and proper politics of the beggar's broth! W.


The Non-Jewish Colonization of Palestine.

By Prof. Dr. O. Warburg.

What material for colonists is at our disposal for the settlement of Palestine, and what results have the colonization attempts hitherto made in Palestine to show?

We must distinguish between Mohammedan, Christian and Jewish colonization, since they are quite different both in kind and in their usefulness to the country. Such a denominational division cannot, indeed, be a sharp one, since within the several confessions the diversity of colonizing method is often greater than between the different confessions themselves. Thus, for example, the colonization of the Russian and Roumanian Jews stands far closer to that of the German Templers than the latter does to the colonization of the Christian Maronites; the colonization of the Maronites, again, differs less from the method of Arab Mohammedan nomads who have become settled than the latter does from the colonization of the Circassians, who are likewise Mohammedan.

In general, however, one may understand by Mohammedan colonization the method of the natives prevailing generally in the East; one would therefore also have to include the Druses, who represent a religious community of their own, as well as the Christian Maronites. It is the most primitive kind of colonization in the East, but it has the merit of being practicable with quite slender means. We know but little in detail of its extent; we are acquainted, it is true, with a whole series of newer village foundations, by Maronites and by nomads who have become settled as well as by Druses; we know, too, that Moroccans, Algerians and Egyptians likewise settled towards the end of the last century, though in limited numbers. As regards the extent, success and prospects of this colonization, however, we are still groping in the dark, and it would be a meritorious work to trace these migrations and settlements in detail.

The Circassians, who stand somewhat higher in culture, likewise came into the country only in the second half of the last century, and indeed with the support of the Turkish Government, which assigned them land there. How many Circassian villages exist in Palestine, and with what number of inhabitants, is unknown. As to their results, opinions differ; while it is reported from one side that the Circassian settlements are succeeding well, the view is maintained from another that the Syrian colonization of the Circassians, in contrast to that in Asia Minor, must be regarded as a failure.¹) Anyone who has experience in colonization knows that one


¹) Cf. the relevant data in A. Aaronsohn and Dr. S. Soskin, "Die Rosinenstadt Es-Salt," Altneuland, No. 1, p. 21.