No. 7. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
Two Views on the Russian Jews.
In the English periodical "Monthly Review" there was published last month an article by the well-known Russian political economist Prof. Tugan-Baranowski on the Jewish question in Russia. In a scientific and precise manner, with statistical and economic evidence in hand, he proves that the root evil of the Jewish question in Russia is by no means the antisemitism of the people, as interested persons in Russia would have had it believed. With a bold hand he points to the true origin of the hatred of the Jews . . . .
Now comes the refutation of these "false" and "malicious" assertions, namely on the part of the feuilletonist of the "Nowoje Wremja," H. Menschikow. He holds above all that the Russian policy towards the Jews is a retribution, an act of revenge of the Slavonic element against the foreign immigrants. Thus Russia had suffered very much from the Mongols, Poland from the Jews; the latter had brought Poland to ruin. He then sketches a history of the Jews in Russia, the purpose of which is to prove that the Russian policy towards the Jews has remained the same for centuries.
He said, among other things: "Our Government has not the least objection to a foreign people which brings into the country its talents, knowledge and means. But with the Jews nothing of the kind is the case, nor do they wish to assimilate with the native population. It is a fact that in the five hundred years which the Jews have spent in Poland and Lithuania, the Jews have not after all become Poles or White Russians. Moreover, the Jews, regarded as a whole, are an ignorant and anything but gifted mass. With two or three exceptions they have furnished Russia with no distinguished men. Hostile to Christianity and to Russian independence, they are a dissolving agent for the national culture and the organism of the people."
Menschikow then arrives at the following conclusion:
The Jews are the victims of their own history. They are the only race in Europe that has not been assimilated by Christianity. Either they must found a kingdom of their own — outside Europe! — as the Zionists propose, or give up their nationality. The real ghetto of the Jews is Judaism itself, an ancient faith which holds its adherents in a worse bondage than that of Egypt. It seems to me that the only Canaan for all, the Jews themselves included, is Christianity, as also the assimilation of the Jews with the peoples among whom they live. — So Menschikow! What is to be thought of this our readers will know, to whom the person of Menschikow is sufficiently familiar.
An English Socialist on Zionism.
Mr. Herbert Burrow, a well-known English Socialist, who is active chiefly among the Jews in the East End of London, delivered a few days ago before the South Place Ethical Society a very interesting lecture on Zionism. He opened his lecture with an account of his impressions of travel from the Prague ghetto. The ghetto had shown him the continuity of Jewish history; in the tones of the words of the Torah which he heard in the old Prague synagogue he had heard the song of the long, grand, martyr-laden history of Israel. He had convinced himself that the Jews are a people, although they are scattered over the whole earth. He then described the position of the Jews in all lands, the spectre of antisemitism which everywhere stalks about, arousing horror, bringing to light here a Kischenew, there a Dreyfus affair, and yonder a movement hostile to aliens. It would indeed be very good if the Jews could found a home of their own, although he himself (the speaker) scarcely believes in the possibility. The new home would in any case have to rest upon a Socialist basis. And now a wide prospect opened: to transform the capitalist order of society and to set the Socialist in its place. This was the true Zionism; for this the Jewish people ought to stand.
From the German Empire.
Since we last met together in Basle, where the German delegation already numbered 64 delegates, feverish work has been done in Germany. The East Africa project had won us the sympathies of wide circles hitherto indifferent, and we have endeavoured to strike while the iron was hot. Dr. Klee in Upper Silesia, Dr. Friedemann in Kassel and Hamburg, Herr Auerbach in Essen have achieved successes in numbers at which they themselves may at times have marvelled. Tumultuous jubilation in the meetings, many dozens of new members, rich contributions to the National Fund — what a contrast to former years! Hesitantly, as though conscious of guilt, a few people would edge up to the committee table and enter their names in the lists laid out. The old-established circles scarcely attended the Zionist evenings at all. Tempora mutantur. The surest strongholds of assimilationism are in a state of siege. Already today one may say that, apart from Russia and Roumania, probably no country possesses so great a number of native-born Zionists as the German Empire, and yet we stand only at the beginning of the upswing.
To the result achieved the Berlin Bureau has contributed considerably, which under the excellent direction of Dr. Hantke has distributed many thousands of pamphlets over the whole of Germany. The other district bureaus, too, have worked capably and on the whole proved their worth.
The best proof of this is furnished by the circumstance that the other Jewish organisations, the Lodges, the Central Union, the Relief Society of German Jews, the "Esra," feel moved to work in the same manner. Everywhere one suddenly hears of lectures, the founding of local branches, etc. That can only suit us. Above all it is a matter of rousing the Jews from their lethargy and awakening Jewish interests in them. The way to us they will find afterwards quite of themselves!
The awakening desire for organisation finds its best expression in the ever-recurring idea of convening a general German Jewish Congress. We have advocated this demand for years and hope that this time the goal will at last be reached. A forum must be created from which the wishes of the German Jews may be proclaimed loudly and clearly, and the feeling of solidarity declared. But this representative body ought to press its demands with calm and dignity, not begin its career as a petitioner. The practical result would certainly be insignificant, and its moral standing would certainly be shaken from the outset. Whoever goes "schnorring" for his good right forfeits the respect of the other side; that ought to be considered in good time! What we promise ourselves from the Jewish Congress is in any case not so much of a practical as of a moral nature. Without self-reliance, self-respect and a united will, successes are not won, and unhappily these preconditions are still in many quarters lacking.
A fine proof of this is afforded by the Ladenburg case. It had surely been unknown in the widest circles until the autumn of last year that a professor of that name was living out his days, after a fashion, at the University of Breslau. This sad circumstance Herr L. remedied by delivering at the Congress of Naturalists in Kassel a speech of scientifically questionable value, which culminated in the assertion that the natural sciences had clearly demonstrated the nullity of all religious convictions. This speech was psychologically interesting inasmuch as it proves anew how greatly the Jews, in the centuries-