Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · 5 February 1904
8printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 6.

(continued from page 7)

…that the representatives of the various Jewish parties take an equally lively interest in statistics and come together on the ground of this Society for common work. In the course of the meeting many of those present enrolled as active or supporting members.

Report on the Meeting of the Association of Jewish Teachers of Religion at the Austrian Secondary Schools.

(Vienna, 28th and 29th December 1903.)

The meeting was well attended and ran a dignified course. It was opened on Monday, 28th December, at 10 o'clock in the forenoon, by the chairman, Dr. Adolf Weiss (Vienna), who in his address welcomed those assembled and the Board of the honourable Vienna Jewish Community.

The chairman devoted a warm and heartfelt tribute to the late Inspector of Religious Schools Dr. Jonathan Wolf, who was a shining example as a teacher of religion and whose noble character was known to all his colleagues. The chairman further asked the meeting for authority to convey in suitable form the sympathies of the Association to his colleague, Inspector of Religious Schools Dr. Leopold Langfelder, on the completion of his 70th year. (Applause.) Written declarations of support have been received by the meeting.

Passing to the first item of the agenda, "Report of the Chairman", the chairman welcomes with sincere satisfaction the fact that only in the last few weeks four of the colleagues, 2 of them in Vienna (Kollek and Goldhammer), were appointed permanent teachers of religion at secondary schools. — At the request of the Board of the Vienna Jewish Community the committee has drawn up the draft of a syllabus and of instructions for religious instruction at secondary schools. The syllabus was approved by the Vienna Jewish Community after unessential alterations, whereas the instructions, in keeping with the particular conditions in Vienna, received more far-reaching alterations on the basis of further oral deliberations. The chairman reports on the preparatory steps taken towards the publication of a quarterly journal and on the obstacles which have hitherto stood in the way of its appearance. — Thanking his colleagues on the committee for their zeal in the work, and the Association for the confidence shown him, the chairman lays down his mandate as chairman, with the request that his report be received. (Applause.)

After the treasurer, Dr. Goldhammer, has rendered his financial report, the committee is granted its discharge and thanks are expressed to the chairman.

Dr. Alfred Stern declares himself ready to place at the disposal of the Association the material which the Union of Austrian Jewish Communities, founded some years ago, had collected on the investigation of the conditions of religious instruction.

The former deputy chairman, Rabbi Dr. Feuchtwang, is elected chairman, and Prof. Dr. Heinrich Pollak secretary. Elected to the committee per acclamationem are Messrs. Dr. Goldhammer (Vienna), Prof. Kanitz (Vienna), Insp. Langfelder (Vienna), Dr. Grünfeld (Bruenn), Prof. Dr. Kisch (Prague), Dr. Biach (Brüx), Prof. Weiss (Vienna). — The former chairman, Dr. Weiss, was appointed an honorary member in recognition of the services he has rendered the Association. — As reporter on the item "Motions for the Amendment of the Statutes", Dr. Weiss moves several alterations of individual paragraphs of the statutes, with which the meeting declares its agreement. A motion of Rabbi Dr. Kaminka for the amendment of § 9 of the statutes is rejected.

In the second session, which began at 4 o'clock in the afternoon, Chairman Dr. Feuchtwang presided.

Item 3 of the agenda comes up for discussion: "The Legal Position of the Teachers of Religion". Dr. Weiss takes the floor as reporter and explains that the appointments of permanent teachers of religion hitherto made must not deceive us as to the fact that the Jews find themselves in an exceptional position, inasmuch as for Protestant teachers of religion in Vienna 3 established posts have been created, although at no Viennese secondary school does the number of Protestant pupils exceed 40, whereas the Jewish teachers of religion are appointed only ad personam. The reporter therefore moves that a petition be presented to the high Government, which should contain the following points:

  1. At those institutions at which the Jewish pupils predominate, the high Ministry will be pleased, on the basis of the provision of § 92 of the Organisation Draft, to establish permanent posts. 2. This should also be done in respect of those institutions where a sufficient number of hours is available for the teacher of religion, even if the condition of point 1 does not apply. 3. In such places where a teacher of religion teaches at several institutions and has the sufficient number of hours, a post should be established at one of these institutions (as has actually been done in the case of Protestant teachers of religion). 4. At all institutions at which it is not possible to create a complete post, the teachers of religion should be appointed as permanent teachers at a lower salary, on the basis of alinea 4 of the law of 19th Sept. 1898. 5. The high Ministry should secure to all teachers of religion, including those for whom posts cannot be established, on the completion of their term of service, a provision for old age corresponding to the extent of their teaching activity. 6. The Association should point to the often arbitrary and objectively unfounded combinations of classes, which stand in the way of the technical possibility of suitable instruction, and ask the Ministry to issue an appropriate rule. 7. The Association should combat the evil prevailing at individual institutions whereby only one lesson in religion is given weekly. 8. The Ministry should, on the basis of the ordinances issued hitherto (which are to be cited by name), remunerate the exhortations delivered at the divine service for young people, in case this divine service for young people has been made obligatory for secondary schools, or count them as two teaching hours.

In the debate following these explanations, Dr. Gustav Kohn, Vice-President of the Jewish Community and member of the Imperial-Royal Lower Austrian Provincial School Board, intervenes; he sets forth the efforts of the Vienna Jewish Community to increase the appointments of permanent teachers of religion, and advocates striving for the establishment of these posts, for which it would be necessary that the candidates should prove their qualifications by a certificate legally valid in the eyes of the State. Messrs. Rosenmann, Lazarus, Grünfeld, Kisch, Hausner, Bud also take part in the debate, and those assembled agree upon the compromise motion to address the following petition to the high Education Administration:

"The Association of Jewish Teachers of Religion at the Austrian Secondary Schools begs that only those be entrusted with Jewish religious instruction at secondary schools who have proved their general and religious-scholarly education in a manner beyond all doubt, and that the high Education Administration, whether by the institution of an examining commission or by the authorisation of a theological seminary, create the possibility of regulating and determining the extent of the knowledge to be required."

On the motion of Prof. Dr. Reich, the Vice-President of the Vienna Jewish Community, Dr. Gustav Kohn, is also appointed an honorary member of the Association.

The third session was opened on Tuesday, 29th December, at 10 o'clock in the forenoon. In the chair: Chairman Dr. Feuchtwang.

Rabbi Dr. Alex. Kisch delivers the report on the creation of a uniform syllabus, the possibility of which he acknowledges, provided it can be achieved that separate religious instruction is given for every class which has Jewish pupils. The subject-matter, he says, must be divided into 1. doctrine of religion and biblical history, 2. the Hebrew language, so far as it is necessary for public instruction and for the understanding of the original text, 3. formal matters of religion. — The reporter argues that a spatial and moral separation should be made between the duties which the State has in respect of religious instruction, and which the teachers of religion fulfil in its name, and the duties which the Jewish communities have in respect of the training of stalwart Israelites; in such wise that in the secondary schools only so much Jewish religious doctrine, history and learning should be taught as leads to the goal of the moral and religious education of secondary-school youth, while whatever goes beyond this interest of the State, such as the treatment of ritual questions, should be the subject-matter of separate religious schools to be founded by the individual Jewish communities and organised on the model of similar institutions in Germany. In the debate that follows, recognition is expressed to the reporter for this detailed and spirited report, but various speakers stress that the demands contained in it are utopias, further, that the reporter has failed to offer positive detailed proposals, and finally the handing over of a part of the