No. 4 — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
(continued from page 8)
…ferent opinions as to the ways of carrying it out. Last year we had the activity of the Fraction; for a long time the Fraction could find no programme. The one thing that was established was the necessity of a division into fractions as a stage in the development of the idea, and that is correct. No idea can remain standing at its original level without generating opinions around itself. These are all human things. It was emphasised that an antagonism existed between East and West. Is it then possible that the most diverse views of life and of the world should not assert themselves? It is enough that we agree on the essential point. And the more we devote ourselves to practical work for our aspirations, the more will the dividing elements vanish. A difference between East and West exists; only one must not let oneself be carried away by it. The Landsmannschaften, without whose existence we should now be suspended in the air, ought, however, to bring out not what divides but what unites, what brings us closer together. And that is precisely the fundamental error of the Charkow Conference: that it did not point to what binds it to the Western Zionists, that they have one aim and are brothers, but that it strongly emphasised the difference. A certain secrecy hangs over the whole affair. The deliberations were held behind closed doors. One may justify the necessity of this by Russian conditions. But in that case one ought to have communicated the true intentions to one's friends, one's Zionist brothers; yet nothing further of these has reached us than the news of a passionate fronde against Dr. Herzl. It would be a glorious thing for the Jewish people if it had several Herzls, and it may count itself fortunate in the possession of the one. (Stormy, long-continued applause.) He, who of his fifteen daily working hours spends ten or eleven in the service of Zionism! (Applause.) But if our sinecures and large salaries are envied us, let it be known for certain: if others come forward who can do and carry out what ought to be done, we are gladly prepared to make way for them. — The speaker further comes to speak of the differences between large-scale and small-scale colonisation. It means nothing, set against the lives of millions, if at enormous sacrifice 40,000 Jews are settled in Palestine in 40 years, or 100,000 in 100 years. The only justification at present belongs to internal colonisation, which would make industrious Jewish farmers out of the begging proletariat of Palestine. That would be good not only for the sake of its economic aspect, but also because of the moral impression which the Jews in their ancient homeland ought to make upon the countless tourists of all lands. The speaker finally asks that we wait, without irritation, to see whether the bad news from Charkow may not after all turn out more harmless than it appears, which he ardently desires in the interest of our unity and discipline, and concludes amid great applause.
Phil. Frankl, chairman of the Union of Duelling Fraternities, calls upon the student body to its post as defender of discipline. He relates that Dr. Rosenbaum of Minsk, during his stay in Vienna, assured him with a handshake that he would not speak in public, but then did so after all. (Cries of indignation.)
The next speaker brings practical examples of a healthy opposition from the political life of England. Such an opposition, he says, is desirable. If one does not agree with the present majority, one seeks to instruct it and to defeat it openly. So did Chamberlain, who left the Ministry and agitated in the country in order to win a majority for his views. So too ought the Russians to have done, and to have created a majority in the Congress for themselves. Instead of this they seek to weaken the general confidence in the leadership, the confidence which is the most powerful impulse to work. The other Zionists must try to make good this loss with their vote. (Applause.)
Thereupon the president of the Vienna Rosenbaum meeting takes the floor and declares that Herr Rosenbaum did not break his word, since at the urging of the meeting he had delivered a short speech (it lasted only an hour. Ed. note) and not an address. This attempt at an excuse, for want of any logical foundation, meets with the unanimous dissent of the meeting.
Jur. Jos. Meisel delivered a speech in favour of the Charkow Conference, the substance of which was completely cancelled by corrections of fact.
In a spirited closing address Dr. J. W. Marmorek said: It has been said that Zionism must not rest upon two eyes alone. But successors to a political leader cannot be elected. Their worth must be so evident that everyone says: He and no other! But why a search at all, when Dr. Herzl gives so many
colossal proofs of his vigorous life? And yet stones are thrown at him on account of a project on which the opinion of the people had not yet even been sought. And the fact is more than interesting that of late three Bessarabian Jews turned up in Mombassa who made thorough enquiries into the suitability of East Africa for settlement. Moreover, the dispute over the project always stood under the sign of our leader's words that our gaze shall not turn from Zion. To be sure, we do not wish to work in a small-scale colonisation notorious for fiascos and secrecy, but in the modern manner of large-scale colonisation, opening up all the sources of the soil and of life for the welfare of the whole people, not of insignificant parts of it. The speaker once more stresses his suggestion that the Landsmannschaften be dissolved. (Applause.)
A resolution directed against the Charkow men is adopted almost unanimously and will appear in "Die Welt."
* * *
The Union of Duelling Fraternities of Vienna held an internal general meeting on Monday, at which, among much else, a protest against the Charkow Conference was also resolved upon. This will appear in the series of protests published in "Die Welt." y.
Letter from Homel.
Whoever has lived in Homel these last four months has surely, however giant-strong his nerves may be, had to give up a good part of his health; for naturally the days of terror in September, and the announcements of massacres of Jews which have never ceased since, have failed in no one, not even the strongest, to produce their effect upon the nervous system. One is entirely mistaken if one supposes, say, that the well-known Kishineff trials intimidated our population, and that the long-desired calm has at last been restored. On the contrary, we now live here as upon a volcano, whose subterranean thunder and rumbling ever give a foreboding of a speedy fresh outbreak of disturbances. The relations between Jews and Christians have become so hostile that people have even ceased to greet one another in the street, or to shake hands at such meetings as may be necessary. And by this the Russian gives expression to his deepest contempt. Every Monday, week after week, a new riot is announced, quite after the famous September pattern. At the same time, however, comes the very agreeable threat that the September programme was only child's play, "a little outpost skirmish" compared with what is now to come: "This time the masters of the situation would not leave a single Jew alive!"
Although the Jews here naturally do not take such threats too seriously, enough nevertheless takes place here to make their situation appear truly lamentable. Downright horrifying above all are the continual nocturnal house-searches for arms among the Jewish "intelligentsia." One must have lived through it to form even an approximate idea of it. At two o'clock at night a house is suddenly surrounded by a detachment of soldiers. The bell is pulled violently, and a dozen Gorodowois (policemen) with a Nadsiratel (police sub-lieutenant) confront the person who opens the door. The master of the house is summoned in a rough tone to remain strictly passive during the intended search. The women and girls are ordered to stay in their beds; while they are then guarded by two Gorodowois apiece, police-women without any ceremony carry out a search of their persons, so thorough that even the mattresses are inspected with the utmost care. Then, under the command of the Nadsiratel, the furniture is examined down to the tiniest drawers, and books and papers are packed into chests, so that they may be sifted at leisure by the police the next day. Finally the many cupboards and tables that have been torn open are examined for "false bottoms." When they have thus made havoc in the dwelling for three full hours, the Nadsiratel gives the signal to withdraw, formally begging the master of the house's pardon with a few meaningless words. But how do such house-searches affect the Jewish women and girls? Not infrequently, in consequence of the excitement and the indignities endured, they fall dangerously ill or suffer an incurable shock to the nervous system.
That under such conditions all trade and traffic comes to a standstill is easily explained; for naturally, from fear of the terrors painted on the wall in such glaring colours, no one from the surrounding district ventures to come into the town. Whoever can by any means manage it turns his back on Homel for ever. Every day dozens of Jews