No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…nate their will to the will of the leadership, for they have understood that only at the price of many sacrifices can Zion be attained.
* * *
The Sixth Zionist Congress met in the year of the great national calamity.
All of us stood under the terrible impression of the days of Kischenew; stricken with grief and powerless before the hideous catastrophe which had already swallowed so many victims; shuddering before the fearful abyss that there opened.
The efforts to realise the ultimate aim of Zionism had not emerged from the stage of experiments.
The attempt to colonise Egyptian Palestine — El-Arish — had to be abandoned on account of the inadequacy of that country.
We found ourselves in a blind alley.
The storm-wind of Russian and European anti-Semitism was already bringing forth the most brutal deeds, and at the same time the gates of the ancient asylum of the persecuted — England and America — are closing.
The Imperial Ottoman Government, threatened in its existence by the Macedonian revolution, finds neither time nor sufficient quiet to understand and rightly appraise the advantages which might accrue to Turkey from the Zionist project.
In this difficult situation there comes the magnanimous offer of England, which offers the Jews no Zion, it is true, and no Palestine, and not the realisation of the historic ideal, but an entirely unknown tropical land in the Dark Continent, whose darkness is somewhat lightened by the uncertain light of a promised autonomy. To the persecuted and tormented people there is shown, within real reach — land; individual and national freedom are assured, tolerable conditions of existence are proposed.
Theodor Herzl, in view of the threatening calamity, was bound to bring the proposal to the knowledge of the Congress.
The Jews assembled at the Congress, this flower of the "materialistic" people — what did they do?
Did they seize with delight upon the African business, did they fling into the lumber-room Zion and Jerusalem, and the cradle of the nation and the ashes of the fathers; did they reckon up the railway and mining dividends, the export of ivory, perhaps also of black flesh?
The moment at which the African project was disclosed to the Jewish Congress will remain memorable for all time; for all time it will shine forth as one of the purest pages in the history of the Jewish people, a persecuted and outlawed people, which in the moment of real and brutal death did not for one moment deny its — sentiments, and did not for one moment renounce Zion.
And even had Africa flowed with honey and milk, and even were Zion a heap of stones and a desert, the choice was easy for us.
Unhappily there was no choice . . . .
With the English proposal in his pocket Herzl betakes himself to St. Petersburg and Constantinople, to negotiate further concerning Palestine — unhappily without success.
Herzl lays the English proposal before the Congress, gives an account of the attempts hitherto made, and moves the investigation of the magnanimous English proposal, because this is a dictate of international courtesy.
And that no doubt may arise as to the significance of this proposal, Herzl solemnly declares in ancient Hebrew words: "Let my right hand wither if I forget thee, O Jerusalem," and affirms his loyalty to Zion.
The Congress repeats this ancient oath, refuses every Heller from the Zionist funds for the African expedition, and at the same time resolves upon a series of undertakings for Palestine which are to be carried out forthwith.
The Congress resolves to investigate the African proposal and to send a scientific expedition to Uganda, and reserves to itself the final decision upon the English proposal.
This resolution is undoubtedly extremely significant, and extremely dangerous in its consequences. For years the Zionists have laboured at the abolition of the philanthropic conception of the Jewish Question. The foundation of their endeavours is the conviction that the Jewish Question can be solved only through the organisation of the Jews, in the sense of historic tradition, in a new society in Palestine. The soil, and indeed not just any soil, but only the soil of Palestine, and the Jewish nation — but also no welded-together group of wretches of various languages and cultures, but the nation grown into its soil, bound up with its culture, independently organised according to historic presuppositions — these are undoubtedly the premises of Zionism.
Berthold Feiwel is right: "Zionism is no movement of distress, even though it relieves distress. It is the crown of an historical development which begins not in the Ghetto but in Palestine. Character and spirit, custom, religion and language, a wealth of mysterious yet living forces, the people took with it from its land upon its wanderings; and by a wondrous destiny all the forces and peculiarities of the people, which so often in its history of the Golus pressed towards Messianic-Palestinian uprisings, are now awakening anew into a vigorous movement that strives towards Erez Israel."
Feiwel is right in this also, when he maintains that the deepest meaning of Zionism lies in its seeking to restore the never wholly interrupted connection between land and people, so that out of this natural union that social and cultural mission may be continued which ancient Israel took up.
And equally it is beyond all doubt, and no attempts at embellishment can alter it in any way: Africa is not contained in Zionism, does not lie upon its line of development, is no means to the end, but is rather an obstacle in the development of Zionism, a blind alley from which there is no way out to the Zionist Palestine.
I agree with Feiwel, Ussischkin and Kirschrot that this resolution of the Congress may be fraught with grave consequences, and that the leaders of Zionism have been burdened by this resolution with an enormous responsibility.
I can, however, never agree, and never shall agree, to attribute to this resolution a significance which does not belong to it, to see in this resolution an apostasy from the Zionist faith and high treason against the nation. I must repeat what has already been said.
If we have unanimously given our confidence to Herzl, if we have entrusted the destinies of our people to him, then we have the duty to obey him, then we have the duty to go whither he leads us, then we have the duty to believe that the road which Herzl has taken is the road to Zion.
The English Government is no Zionist institution; the English Government sees the hideous misery of the Jews, the misery which stretches out its hand before the gates and in the streets of London, wishes, as regards this misery, to re-
