Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · 15 January 1904
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 3 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…of the undersigned, and acclaimed and signed the enclosed motion. Mr. Horia Carp opened the meeting with an address. Messrs. Leon Brill, Isak Leon and Emil Golding spoke against the Charkow conspirators. The meeting was convened by the Zionist societies "Se Pezura", "Bne Zion Jehuda", "Dr. Rülf", "Bne Zion David", "Rabbi Akiba" and "Dr. Lippe". The enthusiasm for Dr. Herzl and the indignation against the men of Charkow were extraordinary. It was also resolved to inscribe Dr. Herzl in the Golden Book with 1000 Kronen. The subscription has already begun. The motion reads: The mass meeting of the Zionists of Bucharest, held on the 8th of January 1904 in the Great Synagogue under the chairmanship of Mr. Horia Carp, delegate to the Sixth Basle Congress, protests energetically against the treacherous presumption of the Russian Zionist leaders who conspired against the movement at Charkow, and hereby expresses its most deep and heartfelt devotion to our great leader, Dr. Th. Herzl, and says: "Kilchol wad enenutlujoth".

With Zion's greeting,

Horia Carp.

The Crisis of Zionism.

(From the "Jewish Express" in London.)

That which we have long feared has come to pass. The blow has fallen; destruction and dissolution have begun their work in our national movement, and our labour of the last seven years has melted away into nothing. The ultimatum which the Russian members of the Actions Committee meant to hand to Dr. Herzl is the heaviest blow that could have struck our organisation and our hopes. The bitterest enemy could not have wounded us so deeply as this ultimatum. It signifies the dissolution of our movement, the shaking of the very foundations of our house. Such an ultimatum is worse than ten ukases of Plehve or prohibitions of the Sultan. What is this ultimatum? It is the most insolent and grossest demand ever made of a party leader. An honourable leader cannot accept such a thing, and we cherish the deepest hope that Dr. Herzl will not accept it either. And that means one of two things: either Dr. Herzl must leave the movement, or all his helpers in Russia, his confidants, his fellow-workers of the last seven years must leave it, and with them, in all likelihood, their followers. Both are unthinkable. In either case the movement is threatened with dissolution. Herzl's withdrawal would mean the destruction of the whole organisation, since Herzl created it and there is no one worthy to take his place. Herzl's withdrawal means shattering the great organisation into a thousand pieces. But the withdrawal of the Russian members, on the other hand, is at the same time the secession of an important part of the Zionist party. In either case it is a terrible catastrophe. And if matters are pushed further in this way, there seems to be no way out any longer, since one of the two must come to pass. We once believed that the resolutions of the Congress must be carried out, and that it was the duty of leaders and led alike to abide by those resolutions. It is above all the members of the Actions Committee who must beware of introducing a kind of anarchy. The Congress resolved to send an expedition to East Africa. We do not wish to discuss here whether the resolution was good or bad. But once the Congress has resolved, the minority must submit to the majority. Otherwise all discipline falls away. Organisation becomes impossible. Those who were dissatisfied with the resolution ought to have waited until the next Congress and won themselves a majority, but not in the meantime to have destroyed the whole organisation.

If the leaders of Zionism mean to proceed with such tactics, it would surely be better simply to give everything up. If Zionism is ever realised, it will be realised only through a strong organisation, through common labour in which the individual must submit to the whole. By their last step the Russian members of the A.-C. have proved that they have never learned the A B C of organisation; they have set the worst example of a breach of discipline; they have themselves turned the Congress, with all its debates and resolutions, into a comedy; they have shown that no one need trouble himself about the resolutions of the Congress, that any Jew may destroy the Temple merely to gratify his whim. What right had the Russian members of the A.-C. to present such an ultimatum? Did they take counsel with the shekel-payers? We do not believe so; but did they reckon the responsibility they have taken upon themselves? Did they reckon the consequences of this murderous attack upon Zionism? We can only pity the crazed fanatic who fired at Nordau; but what are we to say of an assembly of Jews, leaders of Zionism, members of the A.-C., who plan an attack upon Zionism as senseless as it is dangerous? Did they reckon the consequences of their outrage, the rupture of Zionism, the catastrophe of Judaism? Did they reckon the reaction that would set in after the fall of Zionism, the despair and the apostasy from Judaism, the consequences of disillusion? As Zionists, nay more, as Russian Jews, we express our sharpest protest against this ultimatum. We hope by this protest to express the opinion of the mass of Russian Zionists. We call upon all the Zionist societies in England to hold meetings next Saturday and Sunday in order to organise demonstrations of protest, to be sent to Dr. Herzl, expressing to him our confidence in him and our protest against the destroyers. Matters have now reached such a crisis that the Zionists must show on whose side they stand, whether they are loyal to the great leader or side with the revolutionaries.

Already we see birds of prey scenting the body of Zionism, which they believe to be on its way to the grave. Already we see how all the anti-Zionist elements that have crept in are gathering together like microbes. Why deny it? We must openly confess that it is not the East Africa project that has caused the whole tumult. Already in the last three years we have noticed certain destructive elements in the movement. The fanatical clamour about culture, the wild plans of young people who did not themselves know what they wanted, were already a danger to the unity of Zionism before anything was known of East Africa. And even now we have in England an organised conspiracy against the central organisation. Can this not be prevented? The conspiracy must simply be exposed and rendered harmless. Let all Zionists know that Zionism is in a crisis, and that the utmost energy and activity are needed to save the organisation. If Zionism falls now, it will be generations before we can rise again. And that we must not permit.