No. 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
The "Committee for the Protection of the Organisation" furnishes these resolutions with the following remarks, of which we single out the most important: The word "Vienna" belongs to those abusive terms that have become popular and are readily employed whenever one wishes to attack our leadership. This turn of phrase, which arose in the circle of the "Fraction," has no sense whatever in the mouths of these gentlemen. The "declaration" of the district leaders that the "majority of the Congress" has violated the Basle Programme places them — the district leaders elected by the Congress by majority decision — upon the standpoint of the minority, which the Congress rejected. This contradicts the most primitive notions of any principle of majority or minority of votes. The reproach of autocracy which they make against Dr. Herzl strikes themselves, since they wish to overthrow by main force what a majority of the Congress has resolved. Moreover, it is they themselves who wish to thrust an autocratic authority upon Herzl; Herzl was to receive their secretly resolved delegation and promise it to do violence to the majority of the Congress! And he was to bind himself to this in writing. It would surely seem simpler either to trust Dr. Herzl or not to elect him next time. From the resolutions concerning the practical work of colonisation it emerges unambiguously that Uganda is merely a pretext for the fight, that what these gentlemen are simply after is the abandonment of political Zionism. And to this Herr Ussischkin wishes to compel us outside the Congress. Without here disputing the merits of the old Chowewe Zion, the question arises: in whose name, properly speaking, is Herzl being required to abandon political Zionism? Have the Zionists no say in the matter? Whose Congress, whose funds are these? May such changes of principle be brought about by way of "private correspondence"? As to the withholding of the Shekel moneys, those who were entrusted with the collecting by the Congress must send it whither their electors have determined. They have not the slightest right to act otherwise. The creation of a Country Committee is incomprehensible to us; for us such a committee does not exist. Vienna alone, and Vienna only, is entitled to call in the money from the country.
In conclusion the said "Committee for the Protection of the Organisation" is of opinion that one has to do here with the appetites of individuals who would turn everything upside down and destroy the whole organisation. Such attempts must be stifled in the germ.
The Committee hopes that the loyal and logically-minded Zionists will succeed in convincing public opinion of the harmfulness of such attempts. It believes it may see in this incident a momentary assault by individuals, with whom the Zionists as a whole cannot declare themselves in agreement. This body of Zionists as a whole remains unshaken and firm, indeed far stronger and healthier, once there has been eliminated from it — not criticism and opposition, which are otherwise healthy — but the morbid and senseless ferment and the secret autocratic electing. Only one thing remains for the authors of the "ultimatum": to awaken, sobered, from the dream that under the cloak of love for Zion — which they monopolise, though it is deeply rooted in all of us — they will be able to destroy the Zionist organisation.
Open Letter to the Editors!
In No. 52 of the "Welt" the majority of the Russian members of the A.-C. were attacked. As one of them I shall reply to this together with the participants of the Charkow Conference. But I am not only a member of the A.-C.; I am also a Zionist and belong to the general Zionist organisation. As such I turn to the central organ of our organisation with the request that it give space to the following remarks:
-
It is the custom that no sinner is condemned without the indictment having been laid before him and an opportunity afforded him to justify himself. "Audiatur et altera pars," as the saying goes. The central organ, which is subordinate to the A.-C., therefore had no right to publish any attack before the President of the Congress and of the A.-C. had summoned the accused before the whole collegium of the Greater A.-C.
-
Not a single one of the Charkow resolutions contradicts any resolution of the Congress. The Charkow resolutions were meant partly only to protect certain Congress resolutions; partly they related to matters that were never dealt with at the Congresses at all and belong to the activity of the period between Congresses. Some things were also resolved that concern the local organisational questions of Russia, which are not subject to the general Congress. Of this the Zionists will convince themselves once the noise of the street is over and the affair is settled before a juridical forum of the Zionist organisation.
-
In the whole of the Organisation Statute of the Fifth Congress there is no provision according to which a member elected by the Congress could be removed from his office in the course of the Congress year.
The summons which was addressed, on page 5 of the said number, to the former delegates of the Sixth Congress is therefore not juridical, but a means of agitation of the notorious kind. All the more so as the charge has not yet been confirmed by the competent forum of the organisation. Individual members have the right to resort to such means if in their view some danger is afoot. But the central organ, which is subordinate to the A.-C., has no right to lend itself to such juridically inadmissible excesses. Unless the A.-C. had resolved to rid itself in this manner of its disagreeable colleagues. That would be incredible.
I request the Editorial Committee to take note of these remarks and to honour me with a public answer in the "Welt."
With Zion's greeting,
Dr. M. Scheinkin,
Delegate to the Sixth Congress.
Declarations.
Highly esteemed Mr. Editor!
Having learned from the copy of the minutes of the Charkow Conference of the Russian members of the A.-C. of the resolutions which they have adopted against the organisation, against the resolutions of the Congress and against Dr. Herzl, we, the delegates of 36 societies of the city of Odessa, have resolved as follows:
-
To regard the resolutions of the Charkow Conference as a betrayal of the resolutions of the Congress.
-
To call upon the participants of the Conference to refrain from carrying out their resolutions. (Unanimous.)
-
Likewise to call upon them to refrain from sending a delegation to Dr. Herzl, since the latter has been authorised by no one and represents not the opinion of the organisation but that of private persons.
-
We protest against the resolution to transfer the financial centre to Vilna.
-
Maudel tamm is to be called upon not to hand over the financial centre at any price. Such resolutions can proceed only from the Conference of the Zionists in Russia.