No. 1. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…wish to take part. These preliminary labours, however the political decision may turn out, will in no case be without value for a relief of distress on a large scale. The various funds of our Organisation may not be drawn upon for the costs of this expedition, since it does not concern a Palestinian territory. The Actions Committee has therefore the task of raising these costs in some other manner. Our El-Arish expedition cost about £4000; since we are here concerned with a territory yet more remote from civilisation, and since, in order to make use of both dry seasons, two expeditions will probably have to be sent out — first a chiefly scientific one, then a chiefly practical one — the costs are likely to run considerably higher.
To found a Société d'Etudes, as is the custom when business purposes are in view, I do not consider fitting in the state of affairs described above. On the other hand, there is also something awkward in accepting donations for an undertaking which, by reason of its magnitude, must later take on a business character. To the donors who came forward immediately after the Congress we shall, in due course, either return their contributions or devote them to the National Fund. The contribution of the Jewish-Colonization-Association, which I estimate provisionally at about £8000, I therefore conceive of as a payment on account to the separate account of the East African expedition at the Jewish Colonial Bank in London. Should steps later be taken towards the establishment of a Jewish East African Company — to whose foundation the Jewish Colonization Association will then also be invited, — the outlays for the expedition will be repaid by the Company. Should this establishment not come about, the Jewish Colonization Association will have to regard its contribution as lost, but will presumably find sufficient compensation in the results of the expedition, since through the assurance of the English Government a broad basis has in any case been created for a charitable colonisation. If the Jewish Colonization Association contributes to the costs of the expedition in the manner sketched above, you will receive a detailed statement of accounts and the reports of the expedition. I am sending this strictly confidential letter in identical copy to all members of the Council of Administration, in order to hasten its settlement.
With the most distinguished respect, Yours faithfully, Herzl.
II.
Reply of Mr. N. Leven, President of the I. C. A. (Translated from the French.)
Paris, 25th September 1903.
Sir,
After reading your confidential letter, several members of the Council of Administration of the Jewish Colonization Association, being assembled in Paris, have in the course of a conference deemed it useful to formulate the following observations, which are to serve as the basis for discussion at the next meeting on the 1st of November. It would be well if you would, before then, put yourself in communication with the Direction of the I. C. A. on this subject.
-
The I. C. A. considers it its duty to take part in the investigation of a generous offer made by the English Government; but it makes, even now, its most express reservations as to the possibility of bringing a work of colonisation in the region indicated to success;
-
We shall be able to grant our assistance towards the investigation of Uganda only if the project, of which this investigation is to be the forerunner, represents nothing but a work of colonisation in the proper sense, and no political undertaking. It is indispensable for us to be informed plainly and clearly on this point;
-
We require that the Commission of Investigation be formed of six members, of whom three shall be appointed by the Zionist Society and three by the I. C. A. Both the Zionist Society and the I. C. A. shall be entitled to reject the members proposed by the other side;
-
The I. C. A. will be able to contribute to the costs of the Commission of Investigation only to the extent of one half of the sum deemed necessary.
Accept, Sir, the expression of my most distinguished consideration,
N. Leven.
Dr. Theodor Herzl, IX., Türkenstrasse 9, Vienna.
III.
(Reply to Mr. Leven.)
Dear Sir,
Your answer of the 25th of September to my circular letter to the gentlemen of the Council of Administration of the I. C. A. I can, to my regret, regard only as a rejection of my proposal.
In Point 2 you make your co-operation conditional on the matter having no political character. It has been known for years that our movement has a political character. You are therefore setting an impossible condition.
The undertaking, if we finally carry it out — our next Congress will decide upon that — does indeed also comprise a great relief of distress, one many times greater than all previous ones put together. I opened to you the opportunity of taking part in it without imposing on you a condition that would have been in contradiction with your principles hitherto. You wish to impose such a condition upon us. That is to say: you decline.
Respectfully, yours faithfully, Th. Herzl.
Vienna, 27th October 1903.
This exchange of letters says more about the J.-C.-A. than an extensively laid-out book furnished with detailed data. It is beyond doubt, and is moreover admitted by the J.-C.-A. in its President's letter, that it would have been the duty of the J.-C.-A. to take part in so great a colonising undertaking destined for Jews. In order to cloak its ill-will, its resistance to everything that might be capable of preventing a dispersion of the Jews and a fragmentation that leads to impotence, the J.-C.-A. withdrew to a standpoint which, as it knew very well, could under no circumstances be acceptable to the leadership of the Zionist movement. This proceeding of the J.-C.-A., which is not devoid of the worst political hypocrisy, shall here simply