Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 26 August 1903
8printed page
scan 8 of 16

Page 8 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 3

Of this item 80 000 Fr. were retained by Russia, so that only 28 000 Fr. fall to the other countries and the remaining expenditure, of which a further 25 % is retained in the individual countries. There remain Fr. 530; that is no expenditure at all, but a receipt, and indeed it stands on another side of the balance-sheet; it represents a donation from Dr. Tschlenow for the purpose of the journey to Palestine. Dr. Pasmanik inquires about the activity of the Greater A.-C. That is rather an intimate question. I should the less like to discuss it here, since I am not always content with how little we learn of the activity of the Greater A.-C.

To Mr. Lilien I reply that we have never made alterations in the Programme and do not intend any.

Scheinkin has inquired anxiously why the block of our Programme is missing from the "Welt." That happened for a purely typographical reason. Nor is it necessary, for we are assembled here, after all, around the Basle Programme. He has further said that the Orthodox are against East Africa. I have not, however, been able to arrive at this view. I should like to tell Mr. Scheinkin that he must make no distinction between conviction and work so far as Palestine is concerned. We are at a very difficult moment. We have taken great pains, in the speeches laid before the Congress, to take account of the present difficult political situation.

To Dr. Weizmann I reply that we did not lightly let El Arish fall. The negotiations over El Arish failed because too little water is available there. The standpoint of the Egyptian Government only shows us with what solicitous earnestness the question was treated there. It is clear that a settlement without sufficient agricultural prospects could only lead to bringing the settlers into distress. The Government had feared that, if a great colonisation should fail, these unsuccessful settlers would become a burden upon the Egyptian country. Nor did it wish that an undertaking of whose good intentions the Government was informed should end in a painful failure, and in this we were entirely at one. We dissolved the expedition not only because we had to comply with a demand of the Government concerned, but also because we could not direct an emigration and settlement to a place of whose capacity for settlement we were not entirely clear.

Dr. Nossig, with a certain outward thoroughness which I have already observed in several of his works, has given us practical advice. He is of opinion, among other things, that we could remedy the want of water in this tract of land by collecting rain-water. We too asked ourselves these questions at the very first. We attached to that commission excellent experts on the water question. Do not believe that we need such primitive advice. The annual quantity of water at El Arish is strikingly small; there is rain-water there for only a few hours in the year. Nevertheless it would have been possible, by damming and waterworks, to do something with the Wadi El Arish. But it was impossible to begin with that, since the works would have been far too complicated. The Pelusian Plain was therefore recognised as a basis for the settlement. The peculiar nature of this plain, however, would have required us to conduct Nile water beneath the Suez Canal, pump it up, and from there let it down again into the land, and so win the plain. According to the opinion of the Egyptian hydraulic engineers that would have been a practicable plan. But this water could not be given us by the Egyptian Government, because it could not spare so much water.

Interjection by Trietsch: "Dr. Nossig's question was not so primitive, for the point is with how many people the beginning is to be made."

If a smaller beginning were to be made, it is a question whether the dams in the Wadi El Arish would not have sufficed. Dr. Herzl spoke of costly dams; but these are not exactly dear.

Dr. Herzl: There are dearer ones and cheaper ones. Of course we too had a beginning on a small scale in view. Among our numerous reports there are also proposals for beginnings on a small scale. Dr. Nossig has found that I have here performed a theatrical scene. I must leave it to the assembly to decide which of us appears the more theatrical, Dr. Nossig or I. (Lively applause.) At all events this Congress has known me longer than Dr. Nossig, whom we see here to-day for the first time. I will not inquire how long he has belonged to our organisation. (Interruptions: For 3 months, for six weeks!) It is indeed my intention always to gain new Zionists. If anyone comes here with reservations from another point of view and brings them to bear in a loyal manner, I shall be grateful to him. But it is a different matter when one has belonged to an organisation for only a short time and comes here in the manner in which you, Dr. Nossig, have done. I must ask myself whether you have not come here in order to raise objections, (Commotion and cries of applause), more in order to raise objections than to join us, because the publicity of the organs at your disposal does not satisfy your need for publicity; but that you have come here without having joined us I will not construe as a form of malicious polemic. You have asked which is more important to us, settlement or charter. You say that settlement would have sufficed for you. I do not doubt it. It would have sufficed for you precisely because you are a political Zionist. (Applause and counter-cries.) I will grant you this as well. Now, through our long discussion of it, we have become quite clear that a settlement without security means only this: that one abandons people to an uncertain fate. We have seen the attempts. A settlement on a small scale has taken place. We are now of the opinion, after all that we have seen, that it can never lead further, and that we will therefore never lend ourselves to wasting the time of the people on such hopeless things. What you have said to me reminded me of a word which I permitted myself to use about Mr. Trietsch, and on this occasion I return to one of the little poisoned arrows that were in his speech of yesterday. He said, namely, that I had had dealings with him because I believed he had the "Ica" behind him. That was a little poisoned arrow: he has had dealings with me because I suspected money-bags behind him. That was an error; I knew that you have not the money-bags behind you. At the time I used a word about Mr. Trietsch which is not insulting; I said: Mr. Trietsch is a Baron Hirsch without money. Now I have made the acquaintance of a second Baron Hirsch. These gentlemen wish to do without money what Baron Hirsch could not do with money. But that cannot be done with money at all, but only with the national idea!! (Tumultuous applause.)

I will now also communicate to you something which I did not bring forward in the opening report. I have entered into touch with the "Ica" and have