No. 3, Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
Of shekels, it is true, we have collected only a little over Fr. 8000; but in view of our organisation, which has now become a regular one, the agitation will be able to develop a greater activity, and the receipts will be correspondingly larger.
At the last Delegates' Conference in Jassy we also made provision for the cultural question, and the commission is endeavouring systematically to introduce the teaching of the Hebrew language into the schools.
From the table communicated it may be seen that the Federation of Zionists in Roumania numbers 113 regularly functioning societies (among them 13 ladies' societies), and 44 societies have already been inscribed in the Golden Book of the National Fund.
As regards the situation of the Jews in Roumania in general, the emigration, as mentioned at the outset, continues without interruption, particularly that of the artisan class, which has no confidence in the new law, reformed though it be. Save in isolated cases, all of them find remunerative livelihood and employment everywhere, especially in the United States of North America, and take care to provide the members of their families who have remained behind with the means of following them to the new home.
Dr. Pasmanik (greeted with applause): I too must begin by establishing the difference between criticism and criticism. For when we are told that we must exercise criticism upon the activity of the Actions Committee, it would be a sorry thing for the Zionist movement if such criticism were not permitted. But what led to the unpleasant scene of yesterday was the circumstance that people who have come to be something only through the movement created by others now have the courage to say: Your leaders are bad. Put me in their place, and then I will do it better (Applause).
Mr. Nossig, as well as Mr. Trietsch, could have co-operated very usefully in the whole work without exercising such criticism. It seems to me, however, that one would not shrink even from a radical split in our movement — on condition that the persons concerned should then stand at the head of the seceding party. But the unity of our party must be our highest aim; those who act against it are our enemies (Applause).
I should like to pass on to a factual and objective criticism, and above all to call attention to 2 figures. First: under the travel and agitation account there stand Fr. 108,586. 74 Cts., under Palestine research Fr. 530. 38 Cts. That is sad; for Palestine research ought to cost not Fr. 530, but fifty, a hundred times as much. We in fact know nothing of Palestine (Interruptions); Dr. Kokesch tells me that nothing at all has been spent; so it is even worse.
I fear, too, that the new idea of East African colonisation will wholly absorb our attention, and that we shall forget Palestine on account of it. East Africa, even if we learn how to cure the yellow fever, will after all be only a "night-shelter," whereas Palestine is to be our home. I should like to invite the Congress to give the Actions Committee an imperative mandate that it shall now at last not merely record Palestine commissions in the minutes, but create a living commission which will really bring us a knowledge of Palestine.
Secondly: the Lesser A. C. seems in a number of matters not to have proceeded quite strictly in accordance with the statutes, inasmuch as it has not called in the Greater Actions Committee as adviser on important questions. Is it true that the members of the Greater Actions Committee were informed of the East Africa plans only very shortly before the Congress? This practice must cease once and for all.
A third point is the following: from Dr. Herzl's St. Petersburg speech the passage could be gathered: Now we surely need no parties. I should like our Actions Committee to hold to this standpoint, that we have only one aim, the elemental aim, for which no parties are necessary: the attainment of a secured home. For that we need a united, strong Jewish people (Great applause).
President Dr. Bodenheimer takes the chair.
Dr. Fränkel-Copenhagen waives his right to speak for political reasons.
Dr. Schlaposchnikow (in Russian) censures the passing from one colonisation project to another before one had been finished. It is proposed to form a commission for Africa. He, however, proposes that El-Arish should not be discussed until it is certain whether it is really impossible to do anything in Palestine.
Dr. Fink-Vienna (greeted with applause) wishes, in the name of the "Misrachi" group (Applause), to move a resolution on the East African matter, but at the request of the President, Dr. Bodenheimer, refrains from doing so for the present.
Schabotinsky speaks in Russian on the report.
Dr. Rabinowitsch likewise speaks in Russian on the report of the A. C.
E. M. Lilien. I must speak in an excited hour. All of us who are assembled here are neither friends nor enemies, but servants of a great idea and servants of our people. We are all elected by the people and have the duty of stating our opinion without varnish. I hold the view that one can be a very good man but a bad musician, or an excellent and loyal Zionist and a bad member of the A. C. I and my friends confess that we are not very satisfied with the A. C. I grant that our movement has made progress, but that is a proof of our great idea. The A. C. (I do not mean the whole of it, but I must hold the whole of it responsible) has repeatedly overstepped the mark. Let us take the holiest, greatest, most beautiful, most eternal thing that we created at the First Congress: the Programme. I and my friends demand an alteration of the Programme, and now it is said — I myself accept the Programme as it stands here and do not see the necessity of an alteration; but the Programme has been altered. Our Programme is clear and distinct. It runs: "Zionism strives to create for the Jewish people a home in Palestine secured by public law." Nevertheless there was for a long time in the world, and no one protested against it: Zionism strives to create a home in Palestine secured by public law, not for the Jewish people, but for those who do not wish to assimilate in their present place of residence. That too is a view, but it is not our Programme. In the "Welt" of 1898 one may read: "Zionism strives to create a home secured by public law for those Jews who cannot or will not assimilate in their present dwelling-places" — mark well, for those who cannot and will not — and Palestine has been left out. But that too is a position, and that could be our Programme, it could be accepted; and Dr. Nordau expressed himself to the Hungarian Jews in another sense, in which he patriotism