No. 45 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…through the creation of the Congress, through the winning of public opinion. Is the intention of Russia to support Zionism diplomatically, is the generous offer of England, the proof of a miscarried Charter policy, or on the contrary a splendid, real success? The Congress, before which lay the question of how it wished to answer England's offer, could find no other answer than to send out an expedition to explore the territory. Only when the results of this work of exploration are at hand will the Congress be able to declare whether it is for or against East Africa. But however the decision may fall out, Zion remains our ideal, and we may cherish the firmest hope that our leader, precisely after his success in Russia, will very soon carry us a right good stretch further on the road to our goal. (Loud applause.) The mood of the meeting, which was not closed until towards midnight, was visibly in favour of the East Africa project.
—y.
*
The "Jüdische Rundschau" publishes an address which Herr Elias Auerbach delivered before the "Berlin Zionist Association." We take the following from these interesting remarks:
The tremendous excitement which governed the Sixth Congress has passed with the delegates into the Zionist masses. The East Africa project has created two camps within Zionism, and the gulf seems deep.
An understanding we must seek, and we must find it, for division is death.
The East Africa project lies before us as a fact. The question is put to us, what attitude we are to take towards it. Or rather, the question should run: How does the East Africa project stand towards Zionism? — The judge is Zionism, not the project, were it the most brilliant of all. By our principles hitherto, which were surely meant to hold good for every case, we mean to examine this new particular case.
It is well first to make clear to ourselves how England understood the offer which proceeded from her.
For us there can be no doubt that Herzl's efforts regarding El Arish and Sinai were no emergency measure.
England saw — perhaps with regret — that the negotiations ran their course without result, because technical obstacles made a colonisation impossible. Her African proposal can therefore only be understood as a substitute offer. Our negotiators will have made sufficiently clear to the English and Egyptian Governments what kind of project was in question for us. And since England could not give this part of her territory, she offered, no matter for what reasons, another part. We cannot, in truth, demand that England should have a clear notion of what Palestine means to us, or that a question of territory exists for us in this sense. She knows only that we are homeless, and she believed she was giving us a home. And England meant, be it said to her honour, to give us a national home; that is evident from every word of the official document. Why else should the document speak of the observance of Jewish national customs and of the complete freedom of movement of the colony in all Jewish questions? Not England alone, but the whole of non-Zionist Jewry regards East Africa as a substitute for Zion, and many a one praises us for preparing, in place of the "utopian ideal State," to found a "colony" of a real kind.
For us, however, it is not a matter of indifference whether Palestine becomes our home or some other land upon the wide earth.
What is Palestine to us? I will but indicate it in a few words. Not merely the land of the past. For those of us who have been bound from childhood to the ancient tradition of our people — and even here in Germany they are still the majority — it has never ceased to be our home; all that we thought and hoped for the future of Israel, before we awoke to political national consciousness, leaned upon Palestine. We have read Jewish history, not as one studies a yellowed parchment, but as one takes out old, dear letters that one has written oneself. And there on every page stood Palestine, written in our blood, for we are the blood of our fathers. The people is sick because it has been torn from its land. We do not, indeed, believe that the character, history and culture of a people can be mathematically calculated from the nature of its land; but we do believe that for every people there is one soil to which it is most intimately and most naturally adapted, especially when it has grown together with it for centuries, and above all when its great and rich history has been played out upon it. And that is its home. A people has but one home, like the child that is torn early from its parents' house. If it grew up in a hut, then the hut remains for it all its life the very essence of all that is dear and homelike, though it should dwell in palaces.
That is what Palestine is to us, and therefore it is irreplaceable. As a substitute for our home, as England perhaps well-meaningly intended it, East Africa therefore does not for one moment come into consideration for all those who held to Palestine before. Here, precisely, those part company who merely make a Zionist virtue of Jewish necessity from those who, with all their life and being, are rooted in Jewish history and in Palestine. The former were never Zionists; the latter can never become Africans. And were the territory offered us five times as large, Herzl would have to repeat his word: "The signal for departure we may not give to our masses on that account."
The British proposal is not contrary to the Basle Programme; rather it lies wholly outside the Programme and does not touch it at a single point. Was Herzl, then, entitled to lay it before the Congress? What concern was it of ours?
Well, I hold that in this there is nothing we could regret; rather we ought to feel a high and pure joy. From its first appearance Zionism has laid claim to be the negotiorum gestor, the manager of the affairs of the Jewish people. With word and wish alone the thing was not done. But faster than the boldest and most confident among us had hoped, historical development has brought us to this point. We are out of the stage of the separate endeavours of a party; we are the public, general representative of the Jewish people in its entirety. In this capacity Herzl stood before the Immigration Commission in London, in this capacity he travelled to St. Petersburg, in this capacity he negotiated with England too. Many a one before us would have rejected the proposal as addressed to the wrong quarter, and would thereby have shown himself a faithful Zionist, but a poor advocate. But Herzl, with his far-seeing gaze, which is just what raises him tower-high above us all, has won for Zionism its predominant position within Jewry as the chargé d'affaires of the Jewish people, and he would have done unspeakable harm to the standing of our movement had he acted otherwise. — Zionism may declare itself incompetent in no Jewish question when it is approached as mediator.
But with this the limit is at the same time sharply drawn up to which Zionism may concern itself with East Africa. Only as chargé d'affaires has it to act. To do more is forbidden us by our Programme. Yes, what is our Programme?
