No. 44. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…rial and spiritual prosperity, they have co-operated. I believe in the future! Well do I know that suffering, hatred and prejudice divide us from this future. But I know too that flight would not overcome this suffering, these dissensions and prejudices." gt.
*
Continuing his article, which we published in our last number, N. Sokolow writes further in the "Hazefirah" on the East Africa project:
Whether East Africa is or is not suitable for colonisation will be decided by the expedition of experts. I have already said that it ought to be the business of the "Ica." If the conditions for settlement are favourable in every respect, let it colonise there; its work will find recognition. Only let the Zionists shake off this plan as early as possible, for it does not concern us at all.
The autonomy for whose sake we took up the East Africa plan exists in Argentina as well. The colonists there may elect their own head and their own judge in each colony; each of them has its police, which is indeed appointed by the Government but, as in France, is subordinate to the local authority. Moreover, several colonies may choose a common administration and form a self-contained commonwealth.
In Brazil the Germans have their own commonwealth in St. Paolo; were the majority of such a commonwealth Jewish, it would certainly be a Jewish one, without any favour or special concession. Were the Jews to settle on unpeopled spots of America and attain a considerable strength of population, they would possess a territory, and in consequence also a commonwealth, which they could administer autonomously.
If there prevailed among us at all an "autonomous tendency," the will and the wish and the endeavour to be masters in our own house and not schnorrers in strange lands, we should long since have had more than one autonomy. But this desire does not exist among us, since our national consciousness is dulled and the content of our national life has sunk to a minimum — especially where foreign countries are concerned! And to what end, after all? ask the Jews, the pious as well as the free-thinking. In New Jersey there is a considerable Jewish population. Were they our Jews, Jewish-national Jews, they could, without hindrance from the Government, stamp a Jewish-national form upon their administration. But unfortunately we have no Jews who consider this necessary.
And therefore I repeat it most emphatically: what Zangwill said, that agriculture and not culture is the most important thing, is a mere pun. In reality it is culture that matters.
I do not wish to enter into discussions which would be out of place here. I point only to one fact. The possibility of autonomy exists for the Jews in Argentina too. What was held out in prospect in East Africa already exists in Argentina. Why, then, this joy over something remote, because it is new?
In Canada too it is possible, under the prevailing laws, to obtain free autonomous administration. Much more easily still in Australia.
The attractive tone of the letter of offer from the English Government has evaporated and faded away into nothing as a result of the commentaries which the "Times" has added. It hastened to declare that the autonomy would be merely an internal one. It is true that Jews too, at least some Jews, contributed to this commentary. I mean, namely, the Jew Lucien Wolf, who pushed himself forward and protested: "We do not wish to found a State again, but to enjoy toleration." But with such Jews we must always reckon; there will always be such.
If, then, we leave autonomy out of the East African proposal, there remains a plan for a very distant, exotic colonisation. To such a plan one can answer neither "Yes" nor "No." It is an incident, an episode within the Zionist movement.
Not only is it not Zionism; it is not even a "Jewish State." At any rate no more a Jewish State than Argentina with its autonomy.
*
Honoured Editors!
For twenty years I have worked disinterestedly for our Zion, and I am one of the founders of Rishon le-Zion. I have crossed Palestine four times in every direction, and I spared neither loss of time nor of money when I investigated in person the colonisation in Argentina. Likewise I studied for myself the Jewish conditions in North America. I was in lively intercourse with Leo Pinsker. My friends, eminent Zionists, know that my last breath belongs to Zion.
The experiences I have gained in practical life move me to declare freely and openly: had we no Uganda, we ought, for Zion's sake, for the sake of the people's welfare, to seek ourselves a Uganda. I fear a direct passage from the Golus to Erez Israel. No outside power — we ourselves would bring ourselves into the most difficult situations if we entered with all the qualities acquired in the Golus.
Too deeply has the servile spirit penetrated our masses. Of liberty, equality and right we know only the name, not the substance. We talk much of them and tremble before everyone, from the lowest barefoot beggar up to the Minister. We have thereby so taken on the mentality of pariahs that even among ourselves we no longer know either discipline or love of our people. One Jew is the other's enemy — poor folk, indeed, always hate one another.
Is it not a proof of this that the only and the most ardent opponents of Zionism are Jews? For years we have staked our hearts and our nerves upon the sacred cause of the people, and still find far too little feeling and sympathy for it. We have leaders of unheard-of strength of will, patience and wisdom, and every shallow pate reviles and slanders them with impunity. Countless petty parties in Jewry are united on one point only: in stubborn combat against us, against Jewry.
After my experiences, our present generation appears to me only as the dust from which bricks have first to be pressed. We ought first, in a free land, to heal the wounds of soul from our Golus. How fine it will be when we have forgotten trade and possess agriculture in place of over-culture, discipline and love of our people! With these building materials we shall be able to raise up Zion as the proudest and most splendid edifice in the world.
In Uganda a generation can be reared in pride and freedom. In Uganda the peasant class can arise. When with this power we enter Zion's opened gates, our life will offer no moment in which the applause of the high-minded of all nations will be denied us.
What harm can there be in it if, on fertile territory, in freedom and by self-help, we heal the great disease: the Golus? If we go into the hospital in order to come home healthy and joyful?