Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 44 · 30 October 1903
14printed page
scan 14 of 20

Page 14 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 44

(continued from page 13)

...and superficial little book to a close. It is truly high time that there were created a comprehensive, modern theory of Jewish history and of the origin of Judaism, based on the economic conception of history, yet also appreciating the psychical factors in their full significance. It is all the more high time, since in the most modern Judaism the struggle between tradition and free thought threatens to begin anew . . .

And if Lublinski's attempt founders on the striving after too great a simplification, Dr. N. Syrkin takes the most zealous pains to express his thoughts as confusedly and indigestibly as possible. Doctor Syrkin has a passion of his own. Some people love to write books. He prefers to write periodicals. I recall a story in which the hero made a newspaper for himself. He wrote the correspondence and the leading articles himself, telegraphed from every country under the sun — from his garret, of course — and even brought actions for lèse-majesté against himself. Dr. Syrkin proceeds in much the same fashion. First he brought out one number of a Jargon periodical, "Der Hamon" (The Proletariat), published by the organisation "Cheirus" — the same organisation of which a wit lately wrote that its three members had now split into four factions. Now he has issued a second periodical, in Hebrew, "Haschachar" (The Dawn). But the number contains exclusively articles by Doctor Syrkin. He writes everything: philosophy and sociology, and even satires. And as he is the only contributor to the periodical, so, I believe, this number will also remain the only one, since he will also be its only reader. To the merits of the "system" of Dr. Syrkin, who would revalue all the values of Jewish life, for whom Achad-Haam is the philosopher of the decadent and despairing Jewish bourgeoisie, and so forth, I shall perhaps return on another occasion.

A. Coralnik.

*

A new book by Dr. Franz Oppenheimer has just appeared. It bears the title "Das Gesetz der Marx'schen Gesellschaftslehre". By way of a preliminary survey we give the table of contents, and shall follow it with a detailed review from an expert hand: Theses. The chief pillar of the Marxian theory of society. The law of accumulation and its consequences; the law of accumulation and the theory of surplus value. The Marxian proof. The origin of the capital relation. (Primitive accumulation); The reproduction of the capital relation. (The law of capitalist accumulation); The Marxian sorites; A. Exposition; B. Criticism. The Marxian assertion in the light of the facts. The facts of industrial development. (The "setting free" of the labourer and the compensation theory); The facts of agricultural development. (Centralisation, expropriation and setting free in agriculture); Competition in agriculture; The accumulation and centralisation of agricultural capital; Large and small holdings in agriculture; The setting free of the rural proletariat; The facts of the capitalist process as a whole. (The urbanisation of the population). The cause of capitalist exploitation. The distribution of landed property and rural migration; Anti-critical interlude; Outline of a theory of wages; The tendency of capitalist development. Concluding word. The theory of classes.

Feuilleton.

Great Assembly Hall.

The distance from Minsk to London is very great. — Distances mean ethnographical differences.

There are Zionists in Minsk and Zionists in London. The Zionists in these two places, so far removed from one another, are for the most part born in Russia, and those who came into the world in London are descended from Russian-Jewish parents. And yet what a difference between a Zionist meeting in Minsk and a Zionist meeting in London! These differences ought to find expression in the "Welt." One should not merely print the speeches and name the generals; one should also describe the common soldiers and depict the battles.

For my part, I wish to present the combatants of Great-Assembly-Hall in London, Mile-End, to the "Welt" and its readers.

On the third Sabbath in the month of Ab there were many excited spirits in the East-End. That one could perceive if one stood before a placard announcing the great meeting in Great-Assembly-Hall. There were numerous such placards in Hebrew letters, and countless inflammatory articles.

A Jewish paper had criticised the touchingly pretty procession for the National Fund (see No. 14 of the "Welt"). That, after all, is the right and duty of every respectable paper, especially of one that writes in Jargon.

After all, all the great English daily papers had honoured this demonstration with a notice. Our friend of the Jargon paper, however, is said to have criticised the procession very unfavourably. And that they will not stand for in the East-End. Zionism is holy, the National Fund sacrosanct, and its procession without blemish. The imprudent critic was suddenly stamped a Social Democrat and finally degraded to an Anarchist. I ask you — a man to whom not even the procession of the National Fund is sacred, must he not be an Anarchist? And an Anarchist may no longer go up on the platform, the place of honour near the tribune; he must rather go down below the speaker's pulpit, where all the worldly newspaper reporters sit.

Great-Assembly-Hall has the form of an elongated triangle. At one of the narrow ends there rise, one above another from below, the reporters' benches, the speaker's pulpit, the platform, and the amphitheatre of the guests of honour. Round the hall runs a gallery, and a second rises at the other narrow end. Here sit the singers, to join in the singing.

The auditorium is densely packed. Men who plainly have their Sabbath clothes on, many too who are used to the frock-coat, celebrate in fashionable finery, and mothers with babies; one sees coarse, bearded faces, from among which the carefully groomed English ones shine out. They all like to speak English, which not many command well, and all love the land of their refuge, just as each likes to pass for one who knows the country.

When I asked a man, who spoke a few English words only with difficulty, whether he had been long in London, he replied: I have been here a very long time — six years already. — But now back to the singers, men and women.

They begin a Zionist song in clear voices, and before they have sung a verse their singing is swallowed up by a torrent of voices that sounds like the surf of the sea. There may be some 6000 people in the hall, and if only half of them raise their voices to join in, it produces an effect one can scarcely resist. Even when there is a pause in the singing, it rumbles in there as on a rocky coast in a stiff sea.

And the sea is stormy. A mighty wave comes roaring on, slowly at first, then swelling ever stronger, and now it seizes the critic, "the Social Democrat," "the Anarchist," the reviler of the procession. In vain some of the stewards plead, in vain the calmer Zionists set themselves against the superior force. The sea rages and will have its victim. Again and again