Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 44 · 30 October 1903
13printed page
scan 13 of 20
Facsimile · scan 13 of 20
Scan of p. 13
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 44 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13

The World of Books.

Books Received.

Die Entstehung des Judentums. — Haschachar. Since Pasteur's great discovery, many other investigators have travelled the path he pointed out and have discovered bacilli of various kinds and of various diseases. Only recently an Italian professor has even discovered the bacillus of insanity. Such a bacillus whirls and floats about in the air, fastens upon this individual and that, and produces an epidemic.

If I am not wholly deceived, I believe that I too have discovered a new bacillus, namely that of the philosophy of history, or, to put it more precisely, the bacillus of the Jewish philosophy of history. Theories spring up like mushrooms after rain, each more imposing than the last, each more elegant than the last — a delight to behold.

Now such a bacillus lodged itself in an otherwise rather gifted and clever writer, S. Lublinski, and produced its devastating effect — to wit, a new Jewish philosophy of history.

Herr Lublinski has moulted several times; from the German-national, conservative standpoint he passed over to the Jewish-national, became a political Zionist, only then to turn frondeur once more and go over to Social Democracy.

There is, properly speaking, nothing remarkable in that. The evolution of thought, insight into the social question, may well lead to such frequent changes of front, and there are many among the Zionists who acknowledge the fundamental principles of Social Democracy, just as there are Social Democrats (or ought to be) who are able to think nationally as well, and, in our case, Zionistically. What is strange is only that the earlier stages of his intellectual evolution have left no influence, no trace whatever upon the later ones. A Jew who was once a Zionist, who was once convinced of his people's right to exist and capacity to exist, and who held its national, that is to say independent, life to be desirable and worth striving for, cannot without more ado throw his heartfelt convictions on the scrap-heap; at the least he does it with sorrow. It is otherwise if one was a Zionist of fashion and of hurrah, as unhappily there are some, in whom the ideal of Zionism never penetrated farther than the lips, to whom the essence of Judaism is foreign. Among such people I do not count Lublinski. And therefore his sudden change of front is to me a surprise, a "psychological riddle." See the case of Mehring. The author attempts in his little book ("Die Entstehung des Judentums." Eine Skizze. Jüdischer Verlag, Berlin. 1903) to give a "sketch" (and it does indeed appear more a belletristic sketch than a scientific work) of the genesis of Judaism, and that, as he already states in the preface, on the basis of the antimystical-economic view of history." It is, above all, rather obscure what the author actually aims to give: an explanation of the origin of Judaism as a complex of culture, of "Judaism," or of the Jewish people and its history — in short, of the outer or of the inner history of Judaism. For there is by no means a complete identity between these two sides of social life. Social development does not always coincide with the religious and ideological; sometimes the one outstrips the other, sometimes social life lies far behind the ideological, and then there arises in society a cleavage, a disharmony. Religion, to speak of one of the numerous manifestations of the ideological superstructure of human society, does not belong without more ado to economic sociology, is not subject to the same — I mean strictly the same — laws. It is a parallel phenomenon and belongs to another domain, that of higher sociology, of "cosmosociology," as Raoul de la Grasserie*) says. Lublinski speaks in the first pages of his pamphlet of the origin and development of the chief pillar of Judaism, namely monotheism. Although I agree with him in his judgment of the convulsive attempts of our bourgeois "liberal" and orthodox Jews to maintain the priority of the Jews in the idea of the unity of God — as though the Jews had no other merits and reasons for existence! — I hold his derivation to be wholly mistaken. He regards religion only in its social character; that might perhaps suffice to explain the religious struggles, which had a parallel economic-social basis, but by no means to explain the origin of religion. Why did monotheism have to arise? Why did Elohism have to be displaced by Jahvism? To this phenomenon, namely that the Jews were not Jahvists from the beginning, but Elohists, and that then, in the time of the Prophets, they returned once more to the higher religious Elohistic ideal, which had meanwhile acquired a strong democratic-socialistic strain, — to this our philosopher of history has paid no attention at all. And should we not perhaps, in order to find the cause of this phenomenon, which can furnish us with the real key to the history of "Judaism," have recourse to the theory which Renan already employed and perhaps also abused, which Gobineau and his epigones have certainly abused, but which nevertheless has a sound kernel — namely to the racial theory so hateful to Lublinski, this "blood-fable of the racial theory," as he expresses it?

In his exaggerated reduction of everything to a pattern the author does not see at all the difference between the prophet Elijah of Thisbe and Isaiah and Jeremiah, all of whom he regards as bearers of the protest of the poor pastoral and peasant people, which still preserved in memory the free forms of life, against the feudal-theocratic State. The author misjudges the tremendous difference between the prophet named, which consisted in this, that Elijah still belonged to the prophetic type whose representatives still passed for half magicians, when they were still interwoven with the old sun-myths and identified with them, and an Isaiah, who was a tribune, a reformer, who sought to introduce into society the new, purified Elohistic conception of God. The mythical-psychological side of prophecy, which has been so finely treated by many students of religion, and among others also by Kornill and by Lazarus in his "Jeremias," does not exist for the author. It is impossible within the compass of this review even to enumerate all the numerous defects of the author's historical construction. He holds, for example, that in Rome and in Greece there was no social question, since the city-states were slave-holding. A glance at the history of Rome and of Athens, as it after the latest researches, such as those of Prof. Schwarcz in Budapest, will prove the contrary to us. And then he leaps across centuries and declares in conclusion that the Jews entered antiquity as the only capitalists in the midst of a natural economy, that they carried this money economy with them into the feudal Middle Ages, whereby their changeful fortunes are explained, and that now they cannot free themselves from the spell of this old capitalism and form an antithesis to modern capitalism. Hence their suffering, hence antisemitism, inde irae... It is, in other words, the antithesis formulated by Sombart between "old capitalism" and "modern capitalism." But the question still remains open why the Jews could not adapt themselves to modern capitalism — they, who after all helped to create it. For it was Jews who called capitalism on the grand scale into being, until they were displaced by the Christian capitalists, such as the Gualerotti in Florence, the Fuggers and Welsers in Germany. And why were they displaced? If one once reduces everything, like Lublinski, to a single cause, one must surely be able to explain everything by it as well! And are the Jews in modern times, in the XIXth century, old capitalists? I believe the contrary is true. It is precisely they who have created modern capitalism in the economically backward countries of Eastern Europe, and they are even now its sole bearers there, as greater and lesser bourgeoisie. In recent decades an ever-growing Jewish proletariat has been forming. So why now the "irae"?

But at the close Herr Lublinski has spoken one true word, a word which I subscribe to without reserve: "Every movement in Judaism to-day, Zionism not excepted, serves consciously or unconsciously the removal of the natural and usurious economy, the modernisation of Judaism."

And lest I myself fall under suspicion of being likewise infected with the bacillus of philosophy, I shall bring my observations on this incomplete


*) R. de la Grasserie: "Les Religions comp. du point de vue Sociologique." 1899.