Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 43
(continued from page 1)
…of Herr Dr. Meyer, who unfortunately represents a type — and only for that reason do I occupy myself with him here — shall be set forth, so that his conclusions may not come as too great a surprise. That Herr Dr. M. condemns the aimless sending hither and thither of expatriated Jews is something that simply surprises one in his article, and becomes intelligible only in view of the "practical consideration." Nevertheless let it be noted with pleasure. What he says about the defection of the German Jews is also correct, just as the observation is not new to us that with the growth of the Jewish element the anti-Jewish feelings of the non-Jewish population are intensified. Since Herr Dr. Meyer has a diminished moral obligation towards the "co-religionists of the other rite," he is naturally not in favour of "strangers" (by which Dr. M. means those of the other rite) immigrating into Germany. Into Germany, then, they are not to immigrate; for the expatriation of the oppressed no money is to be given, out of practical consideration. What, then, is to be done? Herr Dr. Meyer has no exhaustive answer to that. Probably he hardly seeks one. He knows only that "under this exaggerated solicitude for the Eastern Jews those of our co-religionists must necessarily suffer who were born and grew up in Germany and stand in need of our help." Or rather — yes! He does give an answer after all, an old one, which is also uncommonly characteristic of the economic horizon of the advocate. It runs: "The shirt is nearer to me than the coat." The "surplus of time, strength and money" may be applied to the Eastern Jews, who — only think! — "pray according to a different rite from ours and will not even eat with us," only when Herr Dr. Meyer's "shirt" leaves nothing more to be desired. Thus does the German Jew Dr. Meyer, doubtless an otherwise very humane and self-sacrificing man, think about the relief action for the Polish-Russian Jews.
And now for his ideas on the Jewish national movement. Dr. Meyer records the decline of the anti-Semitic movement, at least in Hanover. Why should that not suffice him? The Guelph shirt is probably nearer to him still than the Old-German coat. At least that would be logical, after his fashion. "At present," he declares, "a certain sobering and disappointment has set in among the ranks of our opponents. The Jewish population, some 4000 souls strong, keeps itself in the background." His proof: "There is no Jew in the town council; among the officials of the province there is scarcely more than one co-religionist; at most one notices in the street the much-censured, unhappy gift of multiplication," etc. We did not know hitherto that the total absence of Jewish town councillors and government officials was to be ascribed to the reserve of the Jews. Herr Dr. Meyer must, to be sure, know better. Let us suppose he is right. What has he, and what have the Jews of Hanover, achieved by it? He tells us at once: "All in all, however, we believed that we could draw breath a little in peace from the hard, strenuous and exciting struggle with the adversary. To our surprise and to our painful astonishment there has now suddenly, as though overnight, arisen in our own camp the national-Jewish movement, which makes short work of all our previous labours and simply throws them on the scrap-heap. According to this account all our purposes and aims are wrong, our labours useless, we ourselves soft-treaders and cringers who have not the courage to avow their descent and their race. That is the thanks and the recognition for our having battled with our adversaries for a decade; this the reward for our having openly avowed our Judaism before every man and at every time, and for having discussed the Jewish question openly and honestly with the best and noblest of the nation, with the knights of the spirit and the most divinely gifted artists, and having commended to them a less prejudiced judgment of conditions and personalities.
"All that is now wrong and useless. Salvation is now to lie in national-Jewish feeling, thinking and sentiment. One does not know whether this is a matter for laughter or for tears." I confess that this appeal to the best and noblest of the nation, to the knights of the spirit and the most divinely gifted artists, to whom Dr. Meyer has "commended" a less prejudiced judgment of conditions and personalities, irritated me far more than even the "unhappy" gift of multiplication which the author quotes. It is the genuine, oppressive air of the ghetto that blows towards us from such phrases. I wish merely to place this on record. A rejoinder has already become unnecessary.
In another passage, after having emphasised that he has frequently found among former anti-Semites benevolent, sensible and justly-minded men, Herr Dr. M. goes on to say that he and those of like mind had hoped that steady, energetic labour would succeed in reconciling the antagonisms and in carrying equality of rights into actual effect:
"Now the young people would suddenly show us that all this was wrong, that we are a different race, and must seek our home in Palestine.
"On this question no discussion is possible.
"The antagonisms cannot be reconciled and the gulf cannot be bridged."
I will bring no further quotations. From what has been adduced it is sufficiently clear of what spirit the advocate is the child. Now let him and those who share his views be given an open and clear answer.
We understand the pain and the disappointment that speak from these words. We younger German Jews too, and surely the Jews of other lands as well, have not been spared this pain, the pain of seeing fall into ruins that which had been extolled to us as our stronghold sure.
We understand also how much more bitter must be the pain of those who have laboured a whole life long at this work of the complete assimilation of the Jews, and who now believe this work to be irretrievably lost. It is a sad thing that, in spite of the good will of those who share Herr Dr. Meyer's views, it has come to the shamefully petty and humiliating result that "the Jewish population keeps itself in the background." Nor is it verily any triumph for Jews of the advocate's stamp that the smallest pause in the war of annihilation against our people should be regarded as a success of these assimilationist endeavours. But all this, as we have said, we can understand, will not now make such people otherwise. It is a dying generation, which cannot see that the Jewish national movement represents just as organic a development of Jewry as did, in its day, assimilation, which has now fulfilled its task after a fashion. Still less will these people understand that without their labour we should never have become Jewish-national at all, that they are our forerunners, who forged for us the weapons with which we fight to-day. We have been Europeanised. For that we thank our fathers. We have taken a significant share in the culture of mankind; with admiration, with fervour, we have taken its treasures into ourselves. No German Jew will ever upon these