No. 42 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…the reading-room, and say: the Fifth Congress has taken this into its programme. But we do not notice, or will not notice, that hundreds and thousands who go away from here are lost to Judaism. And now that for the first time we have the possibility of accomplishing something great — not to nationalise the "model cheder," but Jewish emigration, to concentrate a great mass of Jews in one place — people write: "The fatherland is in danger; a mortal blow has been dealt to the Basle Programme."
The Basle Programme runs: "Zionism strives to create for the Jewish people a home in Palestine secured by public law, and therefore only in Palestine. That stands fast. But did the Basle Programme perhaps also prescribe the road? When one cannot take the shortest road, one chooses a roundabout way.
I am profoundly convinced that the creation of an autonomous Jewish State will help the Basle Programme to its realisation. The free Jews, brought up in the national spirit, will not rest so long as the Jewish people still has an "unwept tear," so long as its ancient homeland, its sanctuary, is withheld from it. Not we, the scattered and divided, but they, the whole men, will lift from the twelve millions of the Jewish people the disgrace which these brought upon themselves when, in the year 1898, they did not furnish the means to become masters of their own land."
"But, Doctor," I objected, "do you not fear that the East Africa project will draw off too much of our strength?"
A.: "That is surely no objection! I do not speak of Herzl and Nordau. Their strength will suffice not only for Palestine and East Africa, but a very considerable store will still remain over for Judaism. As regards our forces, that is to say the Russian ones, I can tell you that it could do no harm at all if many a mouldering force were sent to East Africa to be aired out there. Even if many go away, new forces will come in, and this change of material can only serve our advantage.
Whatever the gentlemen may say who survey a little corner of life from their books or their small studies, however zealously they may busy themselves with the most various Zionist "measurements" in breadth, depth, and so forth, Herzl, who embraces the whole of Jewish life, perceives that the people, which has long possessed Zion in its religion as a symbol, as mysticism, that this people wants a living, real, tangible Zion. England's proposal, provided only that the land should prove suitable, is no road through the air, but a real road to the living, tangible Zion. Herzl gave expression to this thought somewhat as follows:
I have often been compared with Moses, but I am no Moses, if only because Moses was able to lead the Jewish people through the wilderness for fully forty years, whereas I should not be capable of leading them for even a far shorter time. There too, it is true, murmuring was heard, there too revolts took place, but the people stood firm. Now, however, in order to hold the people together and bring them safely to Zion, it is necessary to make arable the wilderness that lies upon the way, and that far sooner than in forty years."
"Has not Dr. Herzl lost something of his standing?"
A.: "For people to whom wide horizons are foreign, Herzl has betrayed the "Programme." But men who have understanding for the new page with which our history has been enriched, for the new conditions which give the Jewish genius the possibility of soaring to a marvellous height, who comprehend that an autonomous Jewish possession is the key to Zion — for them Herzl has grown into a national hero, and if the poet says: "How small is Sinai when Moses stands upon it," we may say: "How small is the Congress tribune when Herzl stands upon it."
"Why did the Russian delegates vote against East Africa, and the foreign ones for the project?"
A: "At the Congress the "Nay-sayers" settled this question very simply. We are the true "patriots" of Zion, and they are merely "Jewish-State men." But that is far from correct. Apart from the fact that many Russian delegates whom one certainly cannot deny Zionist patriotism — as for example Mandelstamm, the historian Jawetz, Dr. Chasanowitz, Barbasch, and the participants in the historic Kattowitz Conference, Jassinowsky and Pines — were for East Africa, it would be the height of injustice to suspect our foreign fellow Zionists, all the more since there were among them many Zionists of great merit. It might rather be explained as follows: the politically trained foreigners held England's proposal to be good as a means of coming later to Zion; the Russians regarded it as an obstacle.
The necessity of the commission for the exploration of East Africa was recognised even by those who are opposed to East Africa on principle. Even the commission which the Russian delegates had elected in order to acquaint themselves more closely with England's proposal, and of which I too was a member, declared unanimously, after careful work, for the dispatch of an expedition to East Africa."
Herzl, who is otherwise wont to carry through his plans with an iron fist, not only took no part in the debates, but did not even let the question be put to the vote immediately after Nordau's speech; instead he called an hour's recess. Naturally it was not softness on Herzl's part, but his deep conviction that the majority of the Congress would be for the appointment of a commission. We had either to confess that we are not the representatives of the whole Jewish people, but merely a party, and that the gift had not been directed to the right address, or to prove that we are the sole official representative of Jewry, that England has to negotiate with us alone. We should also have taken too great a responsibility upon ourselves had we, in the name of the people, taken a negative attitude towards something that was offered not to us but to the whole people. By accepting the expedition the Congress relieved itself of all responsibility. At the Congress I met "anti-Africans" who, in the interest of the Jewish people, did indeed wish that England's proposal might be realised at once, but since they regard this not as the affair of the Congress but as that of all Jews, they voted "No." I believe that many Nay-sayers are to-day thankful to Heaven that England's proposal was not rejected.
The labours of the expedition will now be followed with strained attention, and if only the result prove favourable — no Zionist Congress will reject England's proposal, because the Congress is the very child of its people and will never cast away what coincides with the interests of the people, and secondly because it will find itself under the pressure of the public opinion of the whole world. On the initiative of the Zionists, then, let a general
