Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 41
It has been said that if autonomy were granted to a Jewish settlement in East Africa, the Russian and Polish Jews of whom such a settlement would consist would bring their disagreeable national peculiarities with them and form an alien Ghetto. But then the same may always be asserted of the Eastern Jews, wherever they may settle. They form Ghettos in America, England, the Argentine, Canada and South Africa. Granted that it would come to the formation of a new Ghetto there, this circumstance might nevertheless help to ease the existing conditions. In any case they will not be foreign intruders, since the settlement will belong to them and they will be in the majority. Their position will be roughly similar to that of the French of Canada, whom surely no one regards as foreigners. As for their allegedly disagreeable habits, that is a matter of taste. After all, they might improve under freer institutions. It was then asserted that the Jews are unable to govern themselves. That must first be proved; it will not do to pass a hasty judgment in so serious a matter. A priori there is no reason whatever to suppose that they must be inferior to other peoples in administrative capacity. Besides, they would not be wholly independent. They will have merely a municipal Home-rule; in all respects they will be subject to British control. They will be British citizens with the privilege of being able to preserve their religious and national customs, and this likewise disposes of Sir Harry Johnston's objections that East Africa is too valuable to be given to foreigners. The Jews of Russia and Roumania will no longer be foreigners once they have settled in the British Protectorate. Lord Delamere speaks of public opinion being hostile to the project. But in East Africa, which has scarcely 1000 European inhabitants, scattered over the whole territory, there is no public opinion at all.
And even if there were one, it would be interesting to learn how Lord Delamere managed to hold a plebiscite within so short a space of time as elapsed between his leaving the local club and his entering the nearest telegraph office. No doubt there are a number of concession-hunters in Nairobi to whom the Government's proposal is not at all to their liking. One might rather sympathise with Sir Harry Johnston's view that the colony belongs first and foremost to British subjects. But up to this hour British subjects have not shown the slightest inclination to settle these distant lands. It is a splendid country; only European inhabitants are lacking there. Now that the Government has once offered a part of the country — there would still remain room enough for many millions of other immigrants — to the Russian Jews, an outcry has been raised in the name of those who do not care a straw for East Africa. Far weightier is the objection that we shall see a flood of "undesirables" pouring out along the Uganda Railway; but here too the argument falls short: why should East Africa not likewise attract capable colonists, as the Argentine and Canada do? It possesses an attraction such as no other country in the world offers to Jewish settlers: an autonomy of its own. Why should we not suppose that Jews will say to themselves: If we are once to become colonists, let us colonise a country that stands under Jewish administration? And at this call thousands of young, sturdy Jews, fit for work, will come. Others again have stressed the religious difficulties. How will it be possible, they asked, to found a modern State upon the Talmudic and Biblical basis?
But no one dreams of doing any such thing. Apart from the State's recognition of the Sabbath and the Jewish holidays, other religious considerations will hardly come into account in ordering the public institutions of the new community. The leading men entrusted with founding the State will be practical men, who will not hesitate a minute to make an end of certain old usages, such as, for instance, the Sabbatical year, which are impracticable in the East African settlement.
The Situation of the Country.
Where is the offered settlement situated? Nothing has yet been definitely fixed, and Mr. Chamberlain indicated a tract of land roughly 200 miles long between Nairobi and the Mau Escarpment, bordering on the Uganda Railway and taking in the depression known under the name of the Rift Valley. In the Rift Valley lie the lakes Naivasha and Nakuro, as well as other smaller lakes. It is about 40 miles broad and lies some 2000 feet lower than the surrounding highlands, which are about 8000 feet high. The Mau Escarpment itself is nearly 9000 feet high. The offered settlement would thus be situated in the highlands of East Africa, which stretch for 300 miles along the Uganda Railway, beginning at Kiu and reaching as far as the plateau of Nandi. This explains the curious fact that, despite the country's position under the Equator or a few degrees from it, the climate is nevertheless a temperate one, so that Europeans can live there quite well. The nights are cool, often cold. Europeans can work seven hours of the day at every season of the year; in some seasons the whole day is fit for work. People who know both India and East Africa prefer the climate of the latter country; some even give it the preference over that of South Africa.
On this point the High-Commissioner of Mombas, Sir Charles Eliot, writes as follows in his latest report: "It will certainly sound improbable when I say that the African regions lying a few miles from the Equator have a moderate climate, tolerable for Europeans and European plants, and this seeming improbability is doubtless the reason why the value of East Africa is so underestimated. But there is no doubt about it. Ten years' experience has proved that the climate is healthy and bracing, and that European children born in the country can live and thrive there." East Africa is in this respect different from West Africa. Nairobi lies at the foot of the Kikuju Hills, which stretch north-eastward towards Kenya. The climate is cool, and the Kikuju Hills are one of the richest districts of the Protectorate, rich in water and timber, all manner of grain crops, and bamboo forests. But since this district is already thickly occupied by the native tribes, as well as by the European immigrants who are bustling about there in considerable numbers, it will hardly be suitable for a large Jewish settlement. We may, however, assume that the Kikuju Hills will form the eastern boundary, so that the colony would occupy the depression between Kikuju and the Mau Escarpment, which is usually called the Rift Valley. The land is not properly a valley in the ordinary sense of the word, and is so called only because it lies a couple of thousand feet lower than the surrounding country. It has its mountains and its lakes. One first sees the depression when looking down from the height of the highlands, which rise 8000 or 9000 feet above sea-level. It is itself 6000 feet high and thus reaches the height of the Engadine in Switzerland.
The first large station in this region is Naivasha, picturesquely situated on a hill by a lake of the same name. Naivasha might easily become a new Tiberias. The neighbouring streams — the Morendat and the Gilgil — which the railway crosses on coming from Naivasha, offer the finest landscape views in the whole Protectorate. Forests and waterfalls abound. The country lying beyond Naivasha, east of the Rift Valley, is also one of the finest provinces of the Protectorate. It consists of a series of high plateaux alternating with zones of forest. The climate is moderate and water plentiful. In the High-Commissioner's opinion it contains some of the best grazing grounds in the world.
This country, which is almost unknown to Europeans, might very well form part of the settlement. But let us betake ourselves to the north-west and on along the railway line, beyond Naivasha and Nakuro.
Ten miles beyond Nakuro lies a station called Njow, where the first low slopes of the Mau Escarpment (the western boundary of the Jewish settlement according to Mr. Chamberlain's conjecture) become visible on the plain. Here are the High-Commissioner's words on it: This district is one of the most favoured in East Africa. In its rough outlines it might be compared with the country around Nairobi and the eastern slopes of the Kikuju Hills, but it surpasses them in every respect.
The climate is more charming, the water more plentiful, the soil more fertile. The landscape, as in many other parts of the Protectorate, is surprisingly English. The green hills and woods would be an ornament to a park in the