Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 37 · 11 September 1903
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 37. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

…hood of Israel will receive its binding together! Blood is thicker than a novelist's ink. The worst of Mr. Wolf's having called up this dead memory is that this naive old scheme already figures in the press as a Jewish colony, so that this failure has even been laid at our door! The work is not easy in any case. Even if the day on which we obtain British East Africa will not be so terrible as the day on which we shall get Palestine, it will be terrible enough. It is true that we shall be spared many religious difficulties with the Mohammedan and Christian sects, many political difficulties with the jealous nations, to say nothing of the comparative barrenness of Palestine; but all the same, even in fertile regions colonisation is no easy task. Mr. Arnold White prophesies failure. He reminds us that we shall have no market for our produce. I am glad that every difficulty is being pointed out to us. We must not repeat the mistakes of Baron Hirsch. But until the Commission has returned, brought a favourable report, and indicated all the means of overcoming the difficulties, no attempt will be made, nor will the matter so much as be laid before the Congress. Only the beginnings of colonisation are hard. The great Venetian empire began with a few refugees' huts in a morass. As Mr. Herbert Samuel has remarked, the question is first of all what manner of men the colonists are. If at the outset only the right class of men goes to Jewish East Africa, the rest will follow of themselves.

Not Money, but Men.

Colonies are not made; like trees they grow from a small seed. This simple truth the Ica has never grasped. But now the Ica is offered the opportunity of proving its worth. The Ica has always pleaded that, even if it has no thriving colonies to show, it has at any rate created schools and farms for the training of colonists. Its method was really a roundabout one, since most of its pupils never emigrated; but the Ica's position was simply this: that, should they emigrate, they could become good colonists. This position vividly recalls the famous Mrs. Brown, who once bought a copper door-plate engraved with the name of Simpson. Asked why she wasted money on useless things, she replied that Mr. Brown might die and she might marry a man named Simpson, and then the copper plate would be just the thing. Now the projected Jewish colony opens itself to these colonists, and we must demand of the Ica that it produce them and prove that they really exist. I would no longer ask the Ica for money, but for men. Let it keep its millions — let it give us its trained workers. It was also one of the weak points of the Ica that it is impossible to train colonists in general, since the conditions of each individual colony vary. But once it has been recognised what special kind of labour we need, the Ica's schools could prepare the Russian material for export for our purposes. Thus a connection between the schools and colonisation would have been established, my criticism would be at an end, and peace and bliss would reign everywhere. With the help of all Judaea, with an able Jewish governor at its head, such as, for instance, Sir Henry Matthew Nathan, who is rendering England such great service on the opposite coast of Africa, we could found a colony which would be a source of strength not only to Israel but to the British Empire as well; a colony which would be loyally devoted to the British flag as no other; a colony which would share in the spread of civilisation from Cairo to the Cape, and which, even in the event that Palestine shall be inhabited again by our people, will remain one of the brightest jewels of the British Crown. For since the British, as an Old Testament people, hold the same political and moral ideals as Moses, no conflict can arise between the institutions we wish to establish and those of the British Government.

Two Centres of Jewish Strength.

Nor would the creation of such a colony be so great a diversion of Zionist working strength as is supposed at first sight; for we should gain the co-operation of the millions of non-Zionist Jews, while the older Zionists will continue to work for Palestine. The older Zionists must, however, further bear in mind that Palestine cannot hold all the Jews, and that there is therefore room for two centres of Jewish strength, though more than two would dissipate our strength. When one thinks of the rapid growth of South Africa, one may reasonably expect that a generation will bring about a great transformation in East Africa, and that in a very short time Zionist energy, having once solved the problem of a refuge for the oppressed, will again concentrate itself freely upon Palestine. And not only will it be free, but strengthened as well by the colony it has created and the experience it has gained.

The Essence of the Basle Programme.

It has been said, however, and I come to the last objection, that the creation of a Jewish centre of strength in East Africa is contrary to the Basle Programme. But that is not the case. And even were it so, it could be of but slight concern to me personally. I am an adherent of the Basle Programme, not because it is the Basle Programme, but because it is the best programme. And what does the Programme say? Well, you may read its chief point every week on the title-page of the "Welt," the organ of Zionism. Does it say that Zionism is the creation of a publicly and legally secured home for the Jewish people in Palestine? No. It says that Zionism strives for the creation of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine. And will anyone still venture to tell me that our latest plan is not a striving towards that goal? Will anyone maintain that the creation of a publicly and legally secured home for the Jewish people somewhere is not already half-way to the fulfilment of the Basle Programme?

East Africa on the Road to Zion.

Indeed, the facts already show the contrary; for, to close as I began, nothing has brought Palestine so near to us as this plan. All the Balaams, such as Sir Harry Johnston and Mr. Arnold White, who meant to curse Jewish East Africa, have blessed Palestine, and have told the world that the only solution both of the Jewish question and of the thorny political problem concerning the future of Palestine is to give back to our people its ancient land. And the standing of the Zionists has been raised as well. Under the stimulus of the East African Commission the wish for a scientific exploration of the Holy Land was brought nearer to realisation at the Congress; for the first time an authority on questions of colonisation, Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, sketched a practical plan for the colonisation of Palestine; the Congress subsidised the Jerusalem Library and resolved that every Zionist society should contribute at least 3 R. yearly. And the last picture I have kept of the Congress was the descent of the Sabbath rest after the storms of the week, and two pretty little girls in red frocks singing Hebrew songs before an enchanted assembly.