Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 36 · 4 September 1903
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 36. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…tors the request that they consider under what conditions a branch could be established in Johannesburg. I stated two years ago: in South Africa conditions are very favourable, and I am convinced that a large part of the capital would be raised in South Africa itself.

President Wolffsohn: Next in turn is the Chairman of the Council of Supervision, Mr.

Dr. Herzl: On the question of the branch I will inform you that I have endeavoured to meet the wishes of our organisations, so far as they have come to my knowledge. Of course the business arrangements and the business administration of the matter are no concern of mine; for that you have your Board of Directors. During my stay in St. Petersburg, where I had the pleasure of having at my side the expert counsel and support of our esteemed friend, Director Katzenelsohn, I obtained, in conjunction with him, a prospect of the re-admission of the sale of the shares in Russia and of the establishment of a branch in Russia. The matter has not yet been concluded, but it is in a fair way and will perhaps in a short time become a reality, if all that has been held out to me by a competent quarter comes true. A second wish has for several years been voiced in one of our organisations which, I believe, has a great future if we cultivate it, namely in America, and this wish came forward particularly at the last Convention in Pittsburg. There the American Federation took into consideration the wish expressed by individual groups of societies that a branch be established in the East End of New York, where 600 000 Jews live, and I believe that the fulfilment of this wish promises to strengthen the Bank. The Council of Supervision yesterday also resolved to establish this branch as far as possible. (Applause.) I think you will not be displeased to hear these communications.

Mr. Dr. Farbstein: The last General Meeting elected two auditors for the report of the Auditors; one of them, Mr. Jakob Herz, declined the office. I have examined the matter and communicate my findings to you. Apart from this report I have also given the Council of Supervision a special report. My proposals, summarised, are:

  1. In view of the microscopically small number of those shareholders of whom § 99 speaks, it would be altogether unnecessary for § 99 of the Articles to remain in force; for if we wish to found branches in America, Russia, Palestine, I believe the question cannot be whether those who stand at their head hold 500 shares or not, but whether they are fit for their office.

  2. I would recommend the Board of Directors to consider appointing a committee which should be in London for some weeks. Those who are elected ought to be sent more often to London, for from the reports one receives at the green table one cannot see enough. Perhaps the item "Travelling Expenses" might be put somewhat higher. In my opinion the item "Salaries" is somewhat too high. It must be taken into account that the Bank is closed on Saturday and Sunday, and thus a fifth of the working time is lost. The question might possibly be considered whether the Bank should not work on Sunday; then a fifth of the staff could be dismissed. The Board of Directors recommends a profit of 5 pence per share; in my view it is no misfortune if in the first business year the payment of a dividend is dispensed with.

  3. The members of the Board of Directors should be in London at least once a year, at a time to be fixed; then they will gain an insight into the course of business; and finally, that the Board of Directors be paid for the year 1902 a compensation for loss of time in the total amount of 600 pounds sterling.

As a last motion: that you grant the Board of Directors its discharge, with the fullest acknowledgment of the services rendered. I have concluded. (Applause.)

President Wolffsohn: Several motions have now come in: for closing the list of speakers, for closing the debate, etc. I call your attention to the fact that 30 speakers are still down to speak, and I should like to let the General Meeting itself decide whether we are to close the list of speakers, or rather the debate. (A voice from the meeting: After Dr. Farbstein's report a new question has arisen which must be discussed. I move that general speakers be chosen.)

The motion to close the debate is rejected.

President Wolffsohn: Mr. Roscházky has made a motion; it must be put to the vote. Then I will have the motion to close the list of speakers voted upon. Those in favour of closing the list of speakers will raise their hands. (Done.) The motion is carried. Mr. Dr. Wahrhaftig has the floor.

Mr. Dr. Wahrhaftig: Resolutions were passed by the last Congress which were in part left to the Council of Supervision to deal with, and on which we have received no information either from the Board of Directors or otherwise. That will not do. There is, for example, an important motion of Mozkin's, who said at the time: "Irrespective of the number of shares he holds, every shareholder shall be able to have only one vote at the General Meeting." It appears that this is not the case, and yet it is a motion that was much discussed. Now we have not heard whether this motion was dealt with by the Council of Supervision. After a long debate it was also said at that time: "It is the resolution of the Congress that it be noted in the minutes of the latter that life shares shall never be issued"; the Articles should be altered accordingly. This, however, has not been done; only the life shares were abolished from then on. Often, however, only such are asked for, and upon our informing people that they no longer exist, we are simply referred to the Articles. Therefore we must insist that the Articles may and shall be altered. There is a point that is still more important. You know that it was resolved at the 5th Congress: the A.C. is to come to an understanding with the Board of Directors of the Jewish Colonial Bank that a portion of the forfeited deposit moneys be held at the disposal of the A.C. It took a long time before this decision was arrived at, and now we have not been told how much money has fallen in this way, nor how much is to be placed at the disposal of the A.C.; for it goes on to say: "Subject to the approval of the General Meeting." Now we wish to take steps, the moneys are needed, and we move that they be placed at the disposal of the A.C. I miss the answer of the Board of Directors on this point and ask for an explanation.