Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 32.
(continued from page 3)
…mann, Orgejew. Leime Warschowitz, Bialystok. Mos. Weizmann, Wloclawek. Dr. Weizmann, Stawropol. stud. P. Wilensky, Romni. I. Wulfohn, Riga. M. Silberfarb, Rowno. N. Sirkin, Rowno. Dr. Staropolski, Schitomir. H. Slotopolski, Tarastschy, Iljinzy and Stawistsche. C. Thalheimer (substitute), Cologne. Engineer W. I. Temkin, Tiraspol and Elisabethgrad. Dr. S. I. Temkin, Crementschuk. Dr. Torhowez, Czudnow. M. M. Ussischkin, Ekaterinoslaw. Mich. Uriaschsohn, Vilna. S. E. Weissenberg, St. Petersburg. I. B. Wolff, Slobodke. H. Ziemack (substitute), Göttingen and Hanover. M. Zobel, Proskurow. Miss S. I. Zwenigorodsky, Rostow. E. E. Zuckermann, Kieff.
"Misrachi".
At the Minsk party conference one of the most difficult questions of our organisation was satisfactorily solved. The culture question, which at every Zionist meeting, and still more at all the Congresses, seemed to form an almost unbridgeable cleavage in our camp, was solved by the appointment of two commissions for cultural work, each of which is to conduct the work of popular education according to its own religious tendency. That was the only right and indeed the only possible way to an understanding, and to the emphasising of the self-evident thought that the Zionist organisation must unite all Jews without distinction of their religious views, yet without favouring one tendency above another. In Zionism, which aims at nothing else than to remedy the distraction of our sorely-tried people, all shall and must be equal. In questions of education each tendency shall be left free to work according to its convictions, so far as this work does not offend against the general national idea which underlies Zionism. By this solution the pious have won a victory which, however, assuredly means no defeat for their former opponents. For their so-called culture struggle was not what it had long, through misunderstanding, been taken for; it was no struggle against culture, but a struggle for a tendency within culture, one that wished to see traditional life protected in the religious sense more fully than the non-pious seemed able to guarantee it. Moreover, our pious members had no easy game in the matter of agitation. The "לשכת השחור", the "black cabinet" of the Poltava Rabinowitz and his confederates, made all work impossible for them. The subversive work of the notorious "קולר" had a much easier time of it; it needed only to point to the alleged danger threatening religious life from the side of Zionism, and the law-abiding mass of the people, made wary by the harm that assimilation has wrought to this day, believed it must be on its guard against dangerous Zionism and its cultural aspirations. One need not be strictly orthodox to understand that a pious Jew, who suffers many a hard and bitter thing for his Judaism, who knows that his forefathers bled for the same faith — that this Jew does not so readily attach himself to modern ideas led by enlightened men.
The pious in our organisation had almost insuperable difficulties to overcome; they had to contend not only with ignorance and want of knowledge, but also with gross and base calumnies and distortions by which their ideal was to be brought into discredit among the masses. Their right to separate work in educational matters has done them good service; they were able to give the lie to the calumniators, they were in a position to enlighten their like-minded brethren as to the error into which these had been led by the opponents of Zionism. Since the Minsk assembly the orthodox Zionists have become stronger and are organised in exemplary discipline; their societies, which stand strictly on the ground of the Basle Programme, are multiplying in a most gratifying manner. "Misrachi," such is the name of the orthodox-Zionist party, already has its own organ, a Hebrew monthly named "המזרח" (The East), of which one number already published and the table of contents of the second, still in the press, lie before us.
The purpose of this periodical, according to the introductory remarks of an article by the leader of the Misrachi, Rabbi J. Reines in Lida, is "not to fight, but to enlighten as to the nature, the aims and the true aspirations of Zionism, and to refute the false accusations that are raised against it." "Our pious brethren," Herr Reines continues, "shall convince themselves what benefit Zionism can bring to our religion, to our people and land. They shall learn that Zionism alone is able to raise up our Law, to restore our youth to Judaism, that it alone is able to establish the unity of Israel and make of it a united people. Zionism alone can awaken the powers of the people to common work, for the benefit and welfare of our people and land; it alone can deliver us from our dreadful spiritual and economic distress . . ."
A goodly series of publicistic and scholarly articles, edited by the proven hand of so capable a writer as Herr W. Jawetz, shows us how earnestly "Misrachi" regards the mission it undertook at the Minsk Congress, and what a fine piece of cultural work it has since accomplished. If it continues in this manner to enlighten and instruct the orthodox masses about Zionism, it will achieve great and profitable things for our organisation as a whole. "Misrachi" will not, as people have hitherto mistakenly sought to make out, count as an enemy of culture, but will be a mighty factor of culture, which within a free popular movement is not only justified but also necessary for national development.
M. B.
Letters from England.
III.
And once more all is quiet in the community . . . .
No protest meeting will take place, and the "leaders" of English Jewry will set out with a sigh of relief upon their so honestly earned summer holiday.
Have they not, then, worked hard of late? Only consider! They have written to the "Times" a letter filling a whole column, published an appeal in the "Jewish Chronicle," and — wonder of wonders — talked week after week at the meetings! Is that not a gigantic labour? And what was the cause of this stormy excitement? A few Polish Jews to whom the Russians have taught a lesson, most probably because they did not keep their houses clean enough, or because they lived too closely together, or did not use the language of the country, or perhaps also because they would not acknowledge the blessings of Russian civilisation.
Does not our own Chief Rabbi warn them repeatedly that this might — God forbid — arouse the suspicion of our fellow-citizens even here in England, and was not that the sole cause of the movement against the immigration of aliens?
And so the matter appears to me to stand: I see in my mind's eye their pain-distorted countenances, and I guess their thoughts: "By what right do these Polish Jews exist at all, and cause us so much embarrassment that we must concern ourselves with them even during our holiday?" I think I also see a smile on the countenance of the chief leader in the noble struggle against the protest meeting, on the countenance of Sir Samuel Montagu. He thinks: This Zionist Bentwich has never been able to make his way. But how he always held out to the very last moment! Not even had I brought Lord Rothschild himself to the meeting would he have let go of his resolution. He knew that the chances of his resolution's adoption were 30 to 100, and nevertheless he refused to withdraw it. Of such timber are these Zionists carved. No wonder they win the confidence of the people; we cannot! . . . ."
Poor old Sir Samuel! I can assure him of my own sympathy and that of all Zionists. How he has laboured to justify his policy of "masterly inactivity," and into what disagreeable debates he was often drawn! There was, for instance, one man curious enough to ask him why he, Sir Samuel, had called protest meetings in London against the ill-treatment of the foreign Armenians, while the thought of protesting against the massacre of peaceable, order-loving Jews makes his hair stand on end. The curious one, of course, received no answer, and it served him right: next time he should not ask so awkwardly!
Be that as it may — now all is over! The community will congratulate itself on its splendid work, add it to the long series of its "wise and just" measures, and the incident will be closed. But nevertheless there are some points which have come to light that we Zionists may under no circumstances regard as closed. One of these points is the administration of public funds. I do not hesitate to say that no association in the world could rest content with the fact that with