No. 28 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…mon work. The rich Zionist journalism assures every new idea the widest diffusion; let the delegates be informed by this means, each of them will form an uninfluenced opinion, and the Congress would be spared many unfruitful debates that disturb unity. The triumphal progress of every good idea in Zionism is assured if the mandates are in the possession of tried Zionists. Let them be elected, let them be informed, and then let heed be paid, strictly and calmly, to the judgment of proven conscientiousness. The speaker finally recommends the following resolution for adoption: All foundations in Zionism which appeal to the Zionist body as a whole must, if they wish to be accounted Zionist, be sanctioned by the Congress and be subject to its control. (Applause.)
In the debate Sitzmann (Vienna) expresses the opinion that it seems to him that free expression of opinion is to be suppressed by the theses proposed by the reporter, and moves their rejection.
Dr. Zweig is of this same opinion, although he is an opponent of the Fraction, because compulsory measures play into its hands.
Hausmann (Lemberg) finds that groups with divided labour, with different ways to the same goal, are positively necessary.
Dr. Menczel discusses the question from the standpoint of a practical Zionist. He sets up the parable of the building of a house, to which one party of workmen first brings the building-stones, the other first the interior furnishings. It is a very useful work, one that will some day be very welcome, but at present untimely, which is being performed by the Fraction. Whoever lives in the East will let every opinion of his own and all secondary matters give way before the ardent wish to see the house of rescue from misery built as quickly as possible. If every Jew wished to champion his opinion as the sole possibility, we should have to fall apart into a thousand fractions. The centre of gravity of our movement lies naturally in the East. It is an error to suppose that education can make these masses there the directors of their own destiny. For a long time yet they will be object instead of subject in our movement. A home of their own and bread of their own will raise them higher in a moment than decades of work now.
Markus (Kuttenberg) is willing at any time to grant the Fraction funds, provided only it does not disturb the labours of the Zionist gatherings.
Buber takes his start from Dr. Menczel's parable in order to remark that the question is how the house is to be built. One cannot make the experiment of bringing people to Palestine without the slightest conviction of their mental and physical fitness for a new community. He holds regeneration to be the chief end, the taking of the land to be its means, not the reverse. The gaining of material means is striven after more strongly than the gaining of convinced adherents. That is what has made possible the rise of a watered-down, humanitarian Zionism. The Fraction does not let its courage be dimmed by the misfortune of the Jews. It wishes to bring us thinking masses; to make the object into the subject. It emphasises nothing that departs from the Zionist programme, but only the third point of the Basle Programme: the strengthening of national consciousness.
Schmidt (Vienna) has misgivings about wishing to educate the Jews into thinkers rather than into peasants. He desires such opposition as may be necessary from time to time within the framework of a calm parliamentarism.
Dr. Bernhardt, on the general subject, commends to the Congress the resolution that the Colonial Bank begin its proper activity at the earliest possible moment. For discussion he puts the motion that the thesis defended by Dr. Marmorek be dropped, and that there be adopted instead: The III. Austrian Zionist Conference condemns every alteration of a fundamental principle of the Basle Programme.
Dr. Zweig moves as a resolution to the A.-C., consolidated statements of the statements hitherto issued for the N.-F. (Rejected.)
Kreppl moves in place of Thesis 1: Every separative division along party lines within Zionism is to be rejected.
Dr. Fink (Vienna): To serve up cultural questions to the Eastern Jews now is to give them stones instead of bread. To everything its time, but now unity for all.
In the reporter's closing speech he expresses the opinion that Zionism, with its concise guiding principles, is the educator in life for millions, a better one than all the clever theorists in weeklies, who after all cannot possibly be understood in the Ghetto. No value can possibly be attached to this theoretical education.
The speaker protests against the reproach of illiberality. The law he has proposed offers only the resolve to a voluntary restraint. There is nothing here against freedom, but something good for discipline.
On the vote, the motion of Kreppl (see above) is adopted.
Additional motion of Dr. Fink: All endeavours in Zionism directed towards separate formations are to be condemned as injurious to it.
The remaining theses of the reporter are adopted.
The resolution of Feldblum (Cracow): a call upon the Bank Committee to carry out the resolutions of the V. Congress, — is adopted.
IV. (Afternoon) Session.
There follows the debate on the chapter of the Religious Communities.
Del. Markus (Vienna, III.) has misgivings concerning the project of assessing the communal tax according to the income tax. For the commissions for assessing the latter, mostly antisemitic, have assessed the tax on Jews far too high, and in this robbery the Religious Communities must not take part. The agitation projects of Bondy, based on the good disposition of the communal presidents, are illusory for Vienna, where the Religious Community provides excellently for the antisemites in material respects.
The poor-relief system stands at the lowest point of humanity. The religious instruction is a scandal. After twenty years' work for the improvement of conditions, the speaker is compelled to stand for the sharpest tone.
L. Taubes speaks of the abuses in the keeping of the registers in Galicia.
Rep. Bondy emphasises once more that his remarks apply only to Bohemia, where the good tone is the better one. But where fighting must be done, let it be done in the sharpest fashion.
Dr. Menczel proposes that, on the occasion of the VI. Congress, a call be addressed to all Religious Communities to greet the greatest assembly of the people. Of the greatest conceivable importance in the communal question is to gain influence over religious instruction in a national spirit.
Braff proposes never to put up a candidate of the opposing party. The electoral figures change thereby in our favour. The Zion Societies on the emigrants' route must refer their petitioners, hitherto always supported and forwarded by them, strictly to the Religious Community. That will open many eyes.
Dr. Bernhardt depicts the Vienna Community as the stronghold of an everywhere outlived, disreputable Liberalism. He describes its hair-raising sins of omission (see "Welt", November 1902) and its heartless conduct towards the emigrants. He desires from the Party Conference a prohibition of every compromise with official circles and a command to fight.
Inslicht (Vienna) wishes to see the establishment of technical and school courses for the Jewish working youth taken into the programme for the Religious Communities.