Page 12 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 27
(continued from page 11)
...moment increased importance, since its interest is no longer squandered on alms but employed for social-political purposes that benefit the community as a whole. In Bohemia there are no fewer than eight Jewish organisations spanning the whole country, of which the Representative Body of the Jewry of the Land and the Bohemian Communal League are to be named as the most important. To have given new life to the latter is the merit of our worthy, malcontent fellow Zionist Mr. Julius Bondy, President of the congregation of Hořowitz, namely through his project of a Provincial Chamber of Presidents of Israelite Congregations in Bohemia. At the last Communal Assembly of the Bohemian Communal League, at the end of January of this year, Dr. Schanzer of Pilsen delivered a meritorious report on the defects of the law of 1890 now in force, and likewise closed with the call for an Imperial constitution of Austrian Jewry. And he won the Communal Assembly over to his conviction. And now we Zionists too mean to raise our voice loudly and distinctly for the reform, in the proud consciousness that only our intervention will set the matter rolling. As self-respecting Jews we cannot suffer it that, while not only the Catholics and the Greeks, but also the so much less numerous Protestants have had, these latter since 1861, their Imperial organisation and deal with the State as power with power, every District Captain and district sergeant can meddle in the affairs of the 546 isolated religious congregations of Austria. The Government bears no blame; only we Jews ourselves. Regretfully the Minister of Public Worship, Dr. Gautsch, exclaimed in Parliament on February 7th, 1890: "It is a peculiar phenomenon; whereas otherwise every religious society, understandably, wishes to draw the circle of its internal affairs as wide as possible, and therefore claims for itself the greatest possible autonomy, here a panacea against all abuses is sought in the influence of the State. This standpoint was for the Government an absolutely unacceptable one." That is, the Government left the Jews, these quarrelsome servile souls, more freedom than they themselves desired. This must now be otherwise. I therefore propose my theses to the Party Conference for adoption:
-
(Provincial Consistories.) A. Here I add that these should by no means extend precisely to merely one province or to a whole province. On the contrary, it seems perhaps dangerous to awaken and strengthen provincial particularism. Practical need alone should decide the territorial delimitation. But let us leave these subsidiary questions!
-
(Supervision of the Congregations.) B. This is a highly important task. The welfare of a congregation must not remain delivered over to the conscientiousness and ability of its board for the time being; there must be a higher Jewish authority which urges on the dilatory and removes the bad. That such cases become necessary is shown us by the dissolution of Kahals, often practised by the Galician Lieutenancy, and the dispatch of a Government commissioner — and often a Christian one! — to administer the misguided congregation. For the cultivation of statistics and history, understanding and forces are not readily found in the individual congregation; this necessary work must be performed, or at least directed, by a central authority. The "adjustment of differences" is unfortunately necessary too. Too long have we Jews been estranged from one another for such differences not to have accumulated. But their settlement is an internal matter, and we would decline the spiteful laughter of non-Jewish arbitrators. The non-local foundations, such as already exist to-day, for example, as the Moravian-Jewish Provincial "Massa" Fund, the Galician Meat-Tax Fund, etc., will in future gain in importance with growing Jewish feeling. The Consistories are to employ these foundations for the good of the whole. With the positively rapid shifting of population precisely among the Jews, and especially their flight from the open country into the larger towns, many congregations, deprived of their taxpayers, fall into grievous straits; they can no longer maintain their institutions of worship and their other communal institutions, lead now only a sham existence, and thus repel their members afresh. Here a general organisation will have to step in, alleviating and helping, to preserve what exists as long as possible. And if a congregation has become impoverished, the general organisation will grant its subsidies on the spot, so that the schnorrers — without its being possible to test their worthiness — no longer go, as to-day, from place to place, from country to country, corrupting themselves and their benefactors. And if a congregation absolutely cannot maintain itself, then a Jewish tribunal shall decide upon its dissolution and union with a neighbouring congregation.
The theses state: Paragraph 3: C) The general organisation is to afford an authority against attacks from without. To-day any scoundrel can revile Jews and Judaism with impunity. Parliament, every public authority, every body of troops down to the company and the platoon can defend itself against collective insult. We cannot. It will be our task, in union with the other religious fellowships, to see to the filling of this gap in the law. The projected Imperial constitution would create a larger tribune for our party propaganda, inasmuch as the efforts which are made to-day in individual Zionist congregations, heeded by no one, would then lie open to the admiring gaze of the federated congregations, and the Zionist delegates could press directly for the generalisation of their creations. That the Imperial constitution would strengthen the Jews in their self-consciousness is beyond doubt. Such a Consistory would give its vote uniformly and without hesitation in all questions touching Jews and Judaism, where to-day a confused medley of voices prevails. How differently, for example, after Kishineff alone, would an immediate declaration of sympathy and solidarity by the whole of Austrian Jewry have told, compared with the feeble signs of life of the individual congregations, frittered away over months. Through the Imperial constitution we Zionists can thus educate the Jews to maturity as a people of the State. Their ambition will thus be wholesomely diverted from the petty Khille-spirit to the administration of a great whole.
Theses. D) The idea of an Imperial constitution is too fine and great to find immediate acceptance with the masses. Here a lively work of enlightenment must set in. Assuredly obscurantists will again arise from the midst of the Jews, who will rebel against the union in the name of freedom of conscience and divers other "freedoms". But their time is past. We can appear before Government and Parliament only when we are able to point to a united will and a precisely worked-out plan. The Jewish Congress is to serve to attain that.
Concluding Theses. E) I harbour no illusion. The other Jewish bodies will perhaps take up the cause of the idea of the Imperial constitution at the very moment when they see us Zionists warmed to it. But that matters nothing. The idea of the Imperial constitution is so compelling that those gentlemen will in the end not wish to look on quietly while we exploit it for ourselves by way of propaganda. And even if the pessimists should prove right, that not even such a Jewish Congress could be achieved, still the very working toward it must have as educative an effect as was the case in Germany. But haste is needed. Parliament, in which as early as 1890 the antisemites of various shades declared themselves against the legal recognition and regulation of Jewish bodies as strengthening the Jews, is even in its present composition little calculated to inspire confidence. Who knows what sort of popular representatives Jewish consistorial wishes will meet with in ten years?!
But once the form of a constitution of the Israelite religious fellowship has been created, then it shall be our care, the Zionists' care, to fill the confessional form with national spirit. As to the Armenians in Austria, the Serbs in Hungary, the Saxons in Transylvania from their national churches, so shall there then flow to us Jews from our Consistory a deep well of national strength and invigoration.
Perhaps, indeed probably, I shall meet with contradiction when I exclude the present holders of power from every combination. My co-reporter, Mr. Bondy, President of a congregation, seems, to judge by his theses, to have a better opinion of his colleagues. Well, I am under the depressing impression of the conditions in my native town of Olmütz and of those in beautiful Vienna. And then, surely, the maxim of experience should bear me out, that no one can wholly tear himself free from the impressions of his youth. And the present holders of power stuffed themselves so full in their youth with the ideals of a false liberty and brotherhood of nations that they still stumble, intoxicated, through the sorry present. We Zionists, we sober dreamers, call to them: Sleep off your intoxication, and meanwhile make room for us. The Jewish people has no time to wait. In conclusion I should like to say something to those fellow Zionists, especially from Galicia, who cannot wait for our intervention in politics: They wish to skip a necessary rung on the ladder to the final goal, and in doing so would needs come to a fall. With the Israelite religious congregations at our back, we shall gain nothing in the political struggle and at most shatter our Zionist organisation; but with the Jewish people's communities in our hands we shall
