Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 24
(continued from page 3)
…all the towns in which Jews live has passed this resolution is characteristic of Jewish psychology, and I will give the explanation for it at once.
In the last decades Odessa has several times been the scene of events similar to those which took place a short while ago at Kishineff. To be sure, what was achieved in the way of bestiality at Kishineff was something the Odessa plunderers of those days had not yet dreamt of. Even in Jewish massacres there is, it seems, such a thing as progress. For the rest, I do not wish to diminish the glory of the plunderers and robbers of Odessa. They too furnished a brilliant proof of their love for their Jewish fellow citizens, or rather for their fellow citizens' belongings. Whoever has once seen these hordes, drunk with fanaticism and alcohol, flinging pianos and other pieces of furniture from the topmost storeys into the street, whoever has lived through it as they turned the lanes with bed-feathers into a landscape of wintry aspect—to him, understandably, the news from Kishineff goes to the heart quite otherwise than to the rest of the Jews.
The prospect of getting bed-feathers in one's belly instead of entrails is not calculated to stimulate any particular desire for theatre-going. And when one's next neighbour's house is on fire, one has no longing for balls or other festivities. That is the psychological ground of the resolution of the Odessa Jewish community.
All the same, the resolution of the Odessa Jewish community remains a dignified manifestation, and it is much to be wished that the Jews of other communities, too, would give expression to their sympathy and their mourning in a similar way. That will be the most dignified protest against the infamies of Kishineff.
But there is one thing more we ought to learn from recent events. It is entirely useless for us to try to persuade other peoples that we are flesh of their flesh and blood of their blood. The Russian "little brother" was no more deterred by it from falling upon the Russians of the Mosaic confession than were, before him, the Czechs in Prague, the Germans in Xanten and Konitz, the Poles and Ruthenians in Neu-Sandez and elsewhere, the Germans and Czechs in Polna and its neighbourhood, the French in Paris and Rennes, etc., without grace, on into infinity. When many a Jew exerts himself to show demonstratively how little he is connected with the rest of Jewry, and thereby wishes, as it were, to make it understood that he is a good German or Frenchman, nobody believes him, and not without reason, for one cannot make a good German or Frenchman out of a bad Jew. However eminent the things we may produce in every field of human knowledge and ability, we are nevertheless everywhere hated and despised and, what is worse, powerless to defend ourselves against our enemies. Assimilation has gradually torn apart all the bonds of solidarity; it has understood only how to breed intellects, but not how to form characters.
Here lies the greatest task of Zionism: the Jews' feeling of solidarity must be strengthened; they must learn again to submit to a discipline. Without these two preconditions the success of our work is not to be thought of. And as regards the manifestation on the occasion of the Kishineff atrocities, we could at least protest in a dignified manner by avoiding the theatre and other amusements for some months. The effect would be not only of great ethical importance, but also a wholesome lesson for many an antisemite.
I therefore propose that we Zionists should lead the way with a good example and observe at least a three months' national mourning for the shameless crimes committed against our people. The sums saved might go in part to the National Fund and in part to the fund for the maintenance of the orphans of the Kishineff martyrs.
J. K.
An Exchange of Views between Zionists and Social Democrats.
The Vienna Social Democrats, following a hint from their Central Bureau in Brussels, had convened a meeting for 3 June on "Kishineff," and, since that alone would have looked too Jewish, at the same time on "Finland" as well. Nevertheless the Jews remained among themselves — the working class had, in solidarity, stayed away. The Deputy Dr. Ellenbogen, a notorious assimilationist, tried as far as possible to strip the massacre of its antisemitic character; the agitation, he said, had rather been arranged by Tsarism, hard pressed by the revolution, in order on the one hand to divert the passions of the people upon the despised Jews, and on the other to strike at the Jewish revolutionary working class itself. This working class, abandoned and denounced by the cowardly Jewish bourgeoisie, had after the massacre issued a manifesto laying the sharpest stress upon class antagonisms. "And truly, the bourgeois falsification of the facts is all the more to be condemned in that it diverts the direction of hatred from the real authors of the atrocities. It is the duty of the International decidedly to condemn those who still dare today to counsel cowardly retreat, or even mere submissiveness. Therefore down with Tsarism!" Even during this speech there were clashes, on account of the at times stormy contradiction of the numerous Zionists present. The Socialist but Aryan Deputy Pernerstorfer, after a brief discussion of the Finnish situation, where a small people was fighting the sacred fight for its culture, turned against his colleague Ellenbogen. All the Jews of the world, he said, had the right and the duty to mourn the national misfortune of Kishineff. The Jews in this country too had cause to defend themselves as Jews. He would not be ashamed of belonging to this people, which had preserved itself for two thousand years in spite of a sea of blood and tears. Zionism, leading to freedom and to the development of the people, could not be unsympathetic to him. Social Democracy must combat subjugation wherever it met it. The German Pernerstorfer, who thus prepared such a disappointment for his Jewish party comrades, was demonstratively acclaimed by the Zionists.
After an address by the Ruthenian student Losinski, the Zionist Nathan Gross, chairman of the Vienna General Jewish Workers' Association, in spite of the ever-swelling tumult, polemicized sharply against Ellenbogen and the revolutionary propaganda. He declared: In any case the hint from above found the people, as always, ready to murder us Jews, and that without distinction of class. The few Jewish revolutionary workers, since even the entire Jewish working class of Russia amounted to merely 3% of Jewry, must not entangle the whole of Jewry in their quarrels and sufferings; and it was downright unconscionable of the Social Democrats abroad to goad the Jewish workers, by their mere applause, into a hopeless struggle. And even if the Russian constitution were won, friend Krushevan would certainly parade as a leader of the people and a deputy, as Lueger, Ahlwardt and Drumont do elsewhere. Even in Austria, where only recently the Herzog motion for depriving the Jews of their rights could be rejected only with the help of the antisemitic Czechs and Poles, the Jews must seek protection from the Government against the popular parliament. And since the Social Democrats, too, do not wish to be a "Jewish protection force," the Jews must, instead of cravenly with all
