No. 24 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…"Patriotisme et Sionisme" (Echo Sioniste", 15 February 1903), apart from incidental remarks in other speeches and articles, define my standpoint on the question of the conduct of Zionist Jews in their native countries so clearly and unambiguously that I really need add no further explanations to them. Whoever has not understood me has not wished to understand me, and with someone who does not wish to understand one cannot hope to make oneself understood. If it seems to you worth the trouble to publish this letter, I have no objection. To my feeling, however, this is superfluous.
With the highest esteem, most sincerely yours, Dr. M. Nordau.
The New Measures against the Russian Jews.
Our report, published in the "Welt" of 24 April of this year, on the measures drawn up by the commission appointed by the Tsar for restricting the rights of the Jews in Russia in the field of acquiring land and real property, now finds its full confirmation in the publication of the Russian "Government Messenger" of the 4th inst. The new Jewish law has, in the first place, taken from all the so-called privileged Jews in Russia—that is, those Jews who have acquired the right of residence throughout the whole Empire through an academic degree or through their membership of the first merchants' guild—a right conferred upon them under Alexander II and left untouched even by Alexander III: the right to acquire, lease or exploit land and real property . . .
The immediate cause of this prohibition is, as we reported at the time and as is now also made known by the "Government Messenger," to be traced to the report submitted to the Tsar by the governors of Novgorod, Pskov and Smolensk, in which the allegedly growing Jewish landed property in the three said governments was described as a danger to the economic welfare of the Christian population. The consequences of this new Jewish law for the Jews living in the interior governments are likely to be disastrous. The Russian authorities will always and ever find ways and means of giving even retroactive force to the purpose of the law, which is to keep Jews from the possession of land and real property . . . On the other hand, the new prohibition will only confirm the Russian people in its view of the rightlessness of the Jews in Russia.
But neither does the extension of the settlement area within the Jewish Pale, effected by the new law, offer our fellow Jews any advantages whatever. The 101 localities which were opened to Jewish settlement in the governments of Bessarabia, Vilna, Vitebsk, Volhynia, Grodno, Ekaterinoslav, Kieff, Kovno, Mohilev, Podolia, Poltava, Taurida, Kherson and Tchernigov belonged to the Jewish Pale of Settlement before 3 May 1882, before the creation of Count Ignatiev's well-known May Laws, so that the reopening of these localities to the settlement of Jews signifies no extension of their rights of residence. On the other hand, these localities offer the Jews no material advantage, because they remain forbidden to establish any industrial establishments whatever there. The true character of the new Jewish law is described by a St. Petersburg communication to the "Berliner Tageblatt" in the following words: "The Russian Jewish law just issued is regarded in Jewish circles as a wicked irony. Within the narrow residential district of the Jews in Russia, 101 villages have officially been raised to the status of small towns, in order that, together with the municipal regulations, they may also receive the more extensive police supervision. Since these new small towns lie within the residential district of the Jews, the prohibition against Jews spending the night in a village, which otherwise remains in force, no longer extends to them. Henceforth they may settle in these 101 localities. In spite of this apparent favour, however, the new 'law of grace' for Jews, as it is termed in certain quarters, nevertheless represents an extension of the cruel Jewish laws issued in 1882 by the then Minister of the Interior, Ignatiev. For the new law forbids also the privileged Jews, who possessed the right to live outside the Ghetto, and for whom, in the governments lying outside the Jewish district, no restriction existed with regard to the acquisition of land and real property or the usufruct thereof, the acquisition of real property outside the towns, just like the Jews of the Ghetto. Thus a bolt is also shot against the operation of any industrial undertakings whatever on the part of Jewish wholesale merchants, who, as taxpayers of the first guild, belonged to the privileged Jews. For the erection of factories in the towns is in any case extremely restricted by sanitary, economic and police considerations." — A still stronger proof of the severely restrictive character of the new Jewish law is furnished by the "Nowoje Wremja" in the article which this antisemitic paper devotes to the publication of the "Government Messenger" of 4 June. In words of great enthusiasm the paper speaks of the "redeeming deed" of the new law, heaps attack upon attack against the Jews in Russia, and at the close calls upon the Government to forbid the Jews altogether the acquisition of land and real property within the Pale of Settlement as well . . . And given the part which the views of the "Nowoje Wremja" play in government circles, it will not be at all surprising if one should soon observe the realization of the "Nowoje Wremja's" last wish as well. gt.
A Proposal.
The agitation over the events at Kishineff still trembles in the hearts of all feeling men. Is it conceivable that anything even approximately similar could be inflicted anywhere upon members of another people without the whole of civilized mankind breaking out in a single cry for retribution? A storm of indignation would break loose; the pressure of the outrage of all Europe would enforce the punishment of the guilty and would have carried through measures that would have made a repetition of such atrocities impossible.
And what is happening now on the occasion of the unheard-of events at Kishineff? In many places collections have been organized in order to bring help to the Jews who this time have still escaped death. Even these collections have perhaps already cost many Jews an effort of will, for those murdered and massacred are, after all, only — Jews!
The greater part of the Jews has taken very little notice of these bestialities, and that very unwillingly. It is true: the bloodbath of Kishineff is nothing new for the Jews. More still! This time it was even announced beforehand to the day, to the very hour! All of it, moreover, has happened once before, only with the difference that in earlier times such occurrences called forth the assistance of the Jewry of the whole world, and that the grief was felt equally deeply by the whole people. In former times prayers of mourning were instituted for such victims, and were inserted in our liturgy for ever. For they were brethren whom one mourned! And now? A single Jewish community — that of Odessa — has resolved, as a sign of mourning, to attend neither the theatre nor other amusements for three months. Why precisely my native city of Odessa alone of