Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 23 · 5 June 1903
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 23

(continued from page 5)

…soil, without an independent economic and social life, without a common national language and culture, is an absurdity; it is, no doubt, a theoretical compromise, but no practical possibility.

A far more modern and happier answer to the question that torments us is given by the book of Dr. J. B. Sapir: "Zionism: A Popular-Scientific Account of the Nature and Significance of the Zionist Movement," Vilna 1903 (in Russian). That the book answers to the needs of the Jewish public is proved to us by the friendly reception it has met with and by its rapid circulation (it is already appearing in a 2nd edition). In this work Dr. Sapir gives us a very warmly written, stylistically excellent history of the Zionist idea, and at the same time a catechism of Zionism. In point of information and of agitation it is one of the best works of Zionist literature, rich in data and in facts, overflowing with love for the Jewish people, and it bears the stamp of true conviction and of heartfelt confidence. And it will, we hope, not fail of its effect. "Words that come from the heart go to the heart," said our Sages. But if we choose to regard this work as that which it certainly does not intend to be — if, holding to the little word "scientific" in the title, we expect a truly scientific elucidation and explanation of Zionism — then our expectations will not be satisfied in full measure. The book suffers from the lack of a scientific method. It is a medley of views, of arguments of a social-economic and an ethical-religious nature, which, though quite good in and for themselves and suited to the purpose of the book, which is after all more expository, nevertheless do not penetrate to the depths, and either pass over the most important questions or merely touch upon them. Thus the book, which I should otherwise most warmly recommend, and which would also deserve to be rendered into German, leaves our theoretical wishes unsatisfied.

With greater pretension H. Felix L. Pinkus comes forward in his pamphlet, which bears the ambitious title: "The Modern Jewish Question. On the Foundations of Jewish Economic History and of Zionism" (Breslau, Köbner, publisher, 1903). This title alone tells us more than would be necessary of what this pamphlet aims at. Nothing more and nothing less than the foundations of Jewish economic history and of Zionism is what he would lay bare; and since he associates the two names so closely with one another, we must conclude, by the law of logic, that he holds the two things to be, if not wholly identical, at least almost equivalent. Whereas in Dr. Sapir's book we had to find fault with the deficiency of method alongside a good presentation, in this pamphlet we observe precisely the opposite. The method which the author employs is that of historical materialism, and thus a scientific one and, well applied, the right one too. This the great masters of the materialist school have shown us — among others, Engels and Loria. But how easily the same method, badly understood and applied, may lead to grotesque errors is shown us by the band of epigones who hang upon the coat-tails of the masters. Molinari, for example, arrived at the ludicrous assertion that monotheism developed out of polytheism for the reason that it was cheaper to serve one god than several. Well, the author of the present pamphlet goes so far, in his endeavour to trace Jewish history and Zionism back to economic history, that he almost ignores the actual conditions. I will not here enter with him upon any theoretical discussion of his economic views, for that would really mean debating with Werner Sombart, to whose views the writer has attached himself without criticism and which he seeks to force upon Jewish history. But I believe it is not altogether scientific when one who has set about the mighty task of constructing a Jewish economic history (one of the most complicated of tasks, nota bene) misjudges the whole literature bearing on the subject. Does the use of a few general works on political economy suffice for the carrying out of this task, even if only in its outlines? A Jewish economic history without the use of Jewish historical works!! Had the writer known, for example, the legislation of the Mishna and of the Talmudic and post-Talmudic epochs, he would not have arrived at the fundamentally false proposition that "the Jews early took over capitalism from the Phoenicians," or that "the abnormal position of the Jews results, as the abnormal condition, from the old capitalism which the Jews had carried over from antiquity, and then as the impossibility of adapting themselves to the prevailing conditions and economic forms." (pp. 13 and 16.) It is altogether a very artificial division which Sombart makes between the different stages of economic development; it is a highly disputable view, and one vehemently contradicted by many historians, that there is no continuity in economic development; and if Sombart's theory as a whole, brilliant and dazzling as it is, is nevertheless unsteady in its foundations, the theory of the disciple has no ground at all. Indeed, granted that this unhistorical and incorrect definition of the old capitalism of the Jews, as opposed to the other peoples, were true — why could they not adapt themselves to the new conditions, they who acclimatise themselves so easily? And why were other peoples who did not suffer so greatly from the Migration of the Nations — the Greeks, for example — able to adapt themselves? It cannot be derived from economic causes, and so one must take refuge in the "capitalist" (and, nota bene, "old-capitalist") spirit of the Jews. But this spirit is, after all, a product of economic conditions. Thus, a formal vicious circle. "The emancipation of the Jews arose from purely economic causes (19). But why, then, did it arise earlier in France than in England, that classic land of capitalism? And further: why was the emancipation bound to arise? Is not modern capitalism, according to the premise, fundamentally different from the "Jewish"? And now: how does one derive Zionism from these principles? The author regards the economic position of the Jews even now as an old-capitalist one, which rests entirely upon ignorance of the actual conditions. The Jews in their mass form a petty bourgeoisie, out of which a proletariat — for the time being still a Lumpenproletariat — is now beginning to form. The Jews in their development follow no economic laws of their own, but the current of development of the lands they dwell in. There can be no talk now of an old and a new capitalism, unless one merely wishes thereby to replace the long-familiar words "bourgeois" and "proletarian" society. And why cannot the Jew adapt himself? And how does Zionism follow from this? Here the author makes a leap and fetches in the national idea. But is it primary or secondary, independent or economically conditioned? Secondary, answers the writer. Well, then, why did Zionism arise and not some other movement; why must the home of the Jews be Palestine? This question the author cannot answer. What is Zionism? "Zionism," he holds, "is the form which the social question has assumed among the Jewish people" (p. 48). This definition, which is no definition at all but merely a tautology, is at any rate no more scientific than the definition of Zionism given in the Basle Programme, or in that of the Democratic Fraction, which the author criticises with dialectical keenness. With this answer, too, we remain unsatisfied. Theoretical Zionism still awaits its Marx.

But this one must keep before one's eyes: Zionism as a movement has nothing to do with "scientific Zionism." Our theoretical questions do not concern the movement as such, for it does not stand or fall with this theory or that; it was created by life and is borne up by life. "Not the doctrine is the main thing, but the deed!"


The Lessons of the Anti-Jewish Riots.

In the seventies of the last century a great part of the Jewish population in Russia looked forward to a hopeful future. All manner of rumours of an impending restriction or complete abolition of the exceptional laws were in the air and gave rise to an optimistic view of the situation. And — as is usually the case with us — the more ground this optimism gained, the more there sank, especially among the intelligentsia, the feeling of Jewish self-knowledge and of their own national consciousness. Things are, unhappily, so ordered that hitherto the improvement of the Jewish position and that of self-respect among the Jews have stood in inverse proportion to one another. The so-called equality of rights was purchased by the Jews of Western Europe at the all too dear price of self-renunciation. And in the East of Europe, too, a development in this direction was at that time making itself very plainly felt. The "patriotism" strengthened by the trustful mood created a