No. 21. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…I, for example, should not agree with the President of our Jewish Board of Guardians on the question which Jews would be undesirable.
The Attitude of the Zionists.
But it will perhaps be said: why should we Zionists raise any objection to the exclusion of further Jewish immigrants, since it would brilliantly demonstrate the justice of our demand, which we had hitherto preached to deaf ears — the necessity of seeking a publicly and legally secured home for our race? Well, there are many reasons why we decline to rejoice at it or to rest content with it. In the first place, those of us who were born and bred in England believe that liberty is England's greatest tradition. We are so often more English than the English of the most ridiculous sort; let us for once be more English than those of the noble sort, and protect England from being untrue to herself. Secondly, we remember as Jews the teaching of Moses: "Ye shall not oppress the stranger, for ye know the heart of the stranger, seeing ye were strangers in the land of Egypt." It is painful to see how new-comers, who can scarcely stammer out English, turn against those still newer. I myself had been invited to join a committee of dukes, lords and members of Parliament for the regulation of immigration. I replied that my own father was an alien immigrant, and that I could not venture to exclude others. A third reason is this: we Zionists protest against everything that weakens the position of our people and restricts its freedom of domicile. Much as we desire to give our people a home, we cannot for all that surrender the right of individual Jews to live where they please, just as persons of other nationality would be free to settle among us.
The Jews in England.
This declaration may dispel the anxiety of the rich Jews of England that we intend to deport them forcibly to Palestine. Their terror reminds me of the old man in Aesop who prayed for Death until at last Death came. But their notion of Zionism is a caricature. We do not in the least expect them to go to Zion of their own accord. We do not believe the old-fashioned Zionists; we expect no miracles. No doubt they are quite right to put their trust in England and to make no provision for a darker future. But I tremble to think what would have befallen us here had England been beaten in the Boer War. As it was, our capitalists were accused of having brought about the mischief, and no one remarked how many of our own sons fought and died for England. And indeed! To this wave of Protectionism, to this cry of "British brothers," there corresponds the heightened national feeling that inevitably accompanies a great war. All our Jewish Jingoism fed the flame that now threatens us.
We came over to England with the Conqueror*), but all the services which the Jews rendered to him and his successors, all the buildings and abbeys, all their contributions to learning and to finance, did not prevent their expulsion two and a quarter centuries later, after a series of terrible popular outbreaks in English Kischenews. Of the 16,000 English Jews who preferred exile to baptism, few came safely across the Channel. One ship's captain set a company of rich merchants down upon a sandbank and advised them to call upon a new Moses who might save them out of the sea. That is the last we know, for nearly four centuries, of the English Jews — pardon, the Jewish Englishmen. Then they begin to creep back, and in the last quarter of the seventeenth century we may take them to be settled once more. And already — again after only two and a quarter centuries — there is a cracking and a rumbling underfoot once more, and a Mene Tekel appears. A sojourn of two and a quarter centuries seems to be all that is allowed us, at least in peace. I do not wish to be one who raises the alarm. I do not say "the term has run out"; I believe England — the mother of liberty and of Parliament — is incapable of sinking so low, even with the help of the President of the Jewish Board of Guardians. It is true enough that popular agitations sometimes force the hand of the Government, and no one who has once been wedged in a bawling crowd can doubt the possibility of anti-Jewish riots even in London; but I believe the heart of England is sound, and that she will not turn away from the outcasts and the fugitives without helping them to find a home. But in France, where before the days of Dreyfus the Jewish Frenchmen deemed themselves safe for ever, where Dreyfus, the greatest Christian in Paris, still cries "Vive la France!" — in France, so I hear from competent French observers, the Jews will be the first victims if there are ever revolutions there again. Let us hope that when a revolution does break out, we shall have the good fortune to offer the fugitives a home in Zion.
The Rothschilds.
On that day, I believe, a Rothschild will no longer be eager to be Ambassador in Paris. As for Baron Edmund v. Rothschild, he would probably not be so loth to settle in those Palestinian colonies which he has so nobly founded: a true father of his country, which will for ever hold his name in blessed remembrance. Nor do I doubt that Lord Rothschild will wish to have at least a villa in Zion, as his kinsman Lord Roseberry has a villa at Naples. Since Lord Rothschild took his seat on the Alien Commission and saw the stream of malice flowing against his people, his eyes have been opened. For the first time in his life he has seen and heard the Jewish question with his own ears and his own eyes, instead of through the ears and eyes of parasites. For him, indeed, the Jewish question was very simple. For Lord Rothschild the Jewish question has always been: "How much will you give?" And this Jewish question he has always answered generously. But a people's salvation cannot be accomplished by schnorring, not even by schnorring of the Almighty. God helps those who help themselves.
Lord Rothschild and Dr. Herzl.
I have the hope that Lord Rothschild will in future help his people to help itself. I spent only an hour at the Alien Commission, but two pictures will remain in my memory for ever: one, the back of the head of a Jewish working man who was protesting against the coming in of still more Jews — the great projecting ears, the criminal bulge of the skull; the other, the back of Lord Rothschild's coat, which lay in a thousand folds. I said to myself: "Here you have either a
*) William the Conqueror, first Norman King of England.