Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 11
(continued from page 3)
...is simply the pre-existing thing, which then seeks acceptable grounds and justifications.
Competition is the universal phenomenon in the individualist economic order. The Christian is annoyed at his Christian competitor too, and if the latter presses him too hard he tries to stay his arm with laws against unfair competition; but he makes no moral reproach of his competition, and he does not demand that he be economically paralysed or wholly exterminated. The Jewish competitor, however, seems to him a criminal who must be rendered harmless by every means. The fury is directed, in short, not against the competitor but against the Jew, and it is directed against him because it was not first kindled by the competitor but existed already against the Jew. If the Jew earns, he is hated as a competitor; if he lives on his interest, he is hated for his possessions; hated he always is, and the appeal to competition is only an excuse devised after the fact for the sake of palliation. The real grounds of the hatred of the Jews I have set forth in my address "Zionism and its Opponents", published as a pamphlet (pp. 11 ff.), and I need not repeat them here.
When we obtain the Charter, when we settle Palestine, by no means all Jews will return to the land of the fathers. Jewish competition, therefore, will by no means cease. The Jewish question will nevertheless be solved, because no Jew will any longer be compelled to suffer for his Judaism's sake. If conditions are imposed upon the Jew in the Dispersion that unjustly hamper or make impossible his competition with his non-Jewish neighbour and rival, he will then have the choice of escaping these conditions by emigration to the Jewish land. If, on the other hand, he is granted the same legal and social, material and moral, ponderable and imponderable conditions as the non-Jewish rival, he will not complain of the competitive struggle even in the Dispersion, nor feel the existence of a Jewish question. Competition itself Zionism will not remove from the world. The Jew will find competition in Palestine too. But it will be a competition with equal rights, equal weapons, equal rules of combat. It is possible that another economic order, the socialist, may eradicate competition from economic life. But that has nothing to do with Zionism, which is in the first place a national-political movement and identifies itself with no economic theory.
What we want, and why we want it, we have said not "evasively" but plainly and clearly. But what does Achad-Haam want? For an answer to that I have searched his drivel in vain, and I have asked others in vain, who read Hebrew more easily than, unfortunately, I can. To judge by his concluding sentences, it might seem that he chiefly reproaches Zionism with working too fast. "A renaissance of Judaism that should be truly Jewish and not negro-like," (this idiocy is meant to be a witticism) "cannot be accomplished in one breath," (have we ever asserted that? We know the difficulties of the work better than Achad-Haam, who has never stirred a finger for it) "not by means of joint-stock companies and co-operative societies alone," (not by these alone, but with the earnest collaboration of the whole people, which must make use of every suitable instrument, joint-stock companies and co-operative societies included) "a historical ideal requires a historical development, and historical development advances slowly."
This wisdom we do not learn from Achad-Haam. Certainly — not "the historical ideal", as he expresses himself in his smoky, unintelligible fashion, but the realisation of an ideal grown out of history "requires" time, and it comes about through the natural development of circumstances. Zionism, however, is itself a piece of historical development; it is a movement that sprang not from the whim or caprice of one or a few men, but grew organically, with the necessity of nature, out of the conditions of the Jewish people in the Dispersion. Precisely its character as a historical phenomenon, as a phase in the development of the Jewish people's destinies that cannot be suppressed, is the great, the elemental strength of Zionism, and we do not know how Achad-Haam comes to declaim to us, with triumphant airs, as a kind of rejoinder or refutation, his sentence, which, when put into intelligible human speech, is self-evident.
"Historical development advances slowly." Certainly; but in order that it may advance, however slowly, it must at some time begin. The Zionists have resolutely set themselves in motion. How long they will be on the way does not depend on them alone. "If you will it, it is no fairy-tale," says Herzl. If the Jewish people does not will it, it is a fairy-tale. If the Jewish people wills it by halves, wills it feebly, wills it unpractically, the realisations will be more toilsome, more incomplete, more hesitant. The completion of the work begun by Zionism lies in a perhaps distant future. But its beginning we see already to-day, in spite of all the Achad-Haams.
Zionism is not the only development of Jewish history. That history has developed outside Zionism as well: in Russia to the legislation of Alexander III and the events of 1881/82; in Roumania to the latest artisans' law; in Germany from Stöcker by way of Ahlwardt to Bindewald and Count Pückler-Klein-Tschirne; in Austria to Lueger and his system; in France to the Dreyfus affair and Bayados nationalism; in England to the Royal Commission on Alien Immigration. This development was, I find, not at all slow, but quite rapid. Whither it will lead further, must lead, if matters rest with Achad-Haam's drivellings, any fool can guess. Zionism has begun another line of development, and this leads to salvation. Slowly, that may be; but better slowly than not at all. And certainly it is not accelerated by the doings of the Achad-Haams, but still further delayed, still further held back.
Achad-Haam is a secular Protest-Rabbi. To that we have no objection. We can in any case no more forbid him his opposition to Zionism than we can the Protest-Rabbis. But we have the right and the duty to protest against his calling himself a Zionist. He is no Zionist. He is the opposite of a Zionist. It is a mere trick that he speaks of a "political" Zionism in order to make people believe that there is another, a mysterious, never-explained one, his own. "Political" Zionism is a tautology. A Zionism,