No. 10 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
. . . would diminish. And he is fulfilling his promise inexorably . . .
From a letter to the St. Petersburg weekly "Buduschtschnostj" from Philadelphia the following particulars may be gathered concerning the ruthless restriction of Jewish immigration into America:
According to the statements of eye-witnesses, two hundred Jewish immigrants who hoped to find an asylum in America are now turned back daily by the "Administration of Immigration" on Ellis Island. At the same time, the treatment of the Jewish immigrants on Ellis Island is outrageous. The passage of the report dealing with this treatment reads word for word: "In spite of the terrible storms on the Atlantic Ocean, the Jewish immigrants arriving at Ellis Island are kept on open freight vessels, where they suffer dreadfully from the cold of the sea. The new inspectors appointed by Commissioner Williams mock the Jewish immigrants and heap insults upon them. The Jewish immigrants are thereby confused and give answers to the questions of the immigration inspectors which afford the 'Administration of Immigration' a handle for handing the unfortunate immigrants over to the steamship companies for return passage." But there is more! The new Commissioner Williams has also entirely abolished the former arrangement whereby several advocates (lawyers) attended the examination, so that the Jewish immigrants are delivered over to the arbitrary will of the inspectors.
That the turning back of the Jewish immigrants brings heart-rending scenes in its train scarcely needs emphasising. Several papers appearing in New York have much to tell of these scenes. Aged parents were not admitted to their children living in America, nor wives to their husbands.
The newly created conditions on Ellis Island have aroused great agitation among the Jews in America. The Secretary of the Zionist Federation of the United States, Jakob de Haas, called a meeting attended by prominent publicists, writers and advocates. The meeting resolved to stand up for the unfortunate immigrants by every legal means. Among other things, it was resolved to present to the members of the Senate at Washington a memorial on the proceedings at Ellis Island and to petition for redress. The protest meetings against the restriction of Jewish immigration into America, organised soon afterwards in numerous American cities, have met with a reply from the government side which is of great political interest.
The General Commissioner of the Emigrant Department, Mr. Frank P. Sargent, went to Philadelphia on behalf of the government in order to make a statement on the proceedings at Ellis Island to the representatives of American Jewry, at a secret session held in the "Rodeph Shalom" synagogue. He said, among other things: "The necessity now arises of setting bounds to free immigration into the United States, which does terrible harm to the country and to the American workers. The future of the country is inseparably bound up with the ever-growing immigration. The immigration laws will certainly be observed, but the interests of the American population lie nearest to the government's heart." This speech of the General Commissioner Sargent has opened the eyes of many Jewish patriots to the true causes of the restriction of Jewish immigration into America . . .
The government has felt the necessity, as Mr. Sargent said, "of setting bounds to the ever-growing immigration, which harms the land and people of America." These words also throw light on the motives that at the time moved the Washington government to its well-known Note to Roumania . . . Sapienti sat! . . . Gl.
Franz Oppenheimer on Zionism.
We owe it to the collegial kindness of the editors of the Berlin "General-Anzeiger" that we are able to lay before our readers, simultaneously with that paper, Oppenheimer's answer to the questions on Zionism. The Editors.
1. What do you think of Zionism?
So far as I have been able to follow the movement, it presents itself to me as a mixture of very diverse components, of practical endeavours and hopes on the one hand and of theories on the other. It will scarcely be conceivable that a conscious adherent of Zionism should identify himself with all of these constituents, which in part sharply contradict one another. I am, for example, a resolute opponent of the race theory that is authoritative for many Zionists.
That does not in the least prevent me, however, from being a "Zionist" in my own sense, since I agree with its immediate aim and its means.
a) The immediate aim is evidently the transplanting of many suffering human beings, who groan under the threefold scourge of absolutism, capitalism and antisemitism more heavily than any race of men has ever groaned in all history, into politically and socially healthier conditions. As an endeavour of this kind, then, Zionism is no longer a matter for discussion but solely for organisation; it is a duty not only of Jews but of mankind in general.
b) The means which the leaders of the movement intend to employ is the one I too have recommended for the mitigation, nay the solution, of social antagonisms — co-operative colonisation upon a national soil held permanently in common ownership: an organisation which accords exactly with the most ancient national traditions and the later laws of Israel (the Jubilee year). I should have to deny my whole past were I to refuse my collaboration in such a plan, to whose elaboration it is my pride to have contributed a little.
2. Do you hope for a solution of the Jewish question from Zionism?
In my view antisemitism is, as I have said, no racial question, but an economic and social question masked with racial prejudice. The Jewish question is accordingly soluble only together with the "social question" as a whole: it presents, in a single instance, the great problem of how a society is to be so organised that all rightly understood individual interests run parallel with the common interest, instead of breaking against one another.
Since I believe I have furnished stringent proof by all three methods of sociological inquiry (by deduction, by induction and by historical inquiry*) that a society of this kind, realising "socialism," exists wherever the formation and private appropriation of an unearned increment is rendered impossible;
*) Cf. my works: "Grossgrundeigentum und soziale Frage" (Great Landed Property and the Social Question), Berlin 1898; "Die Siedlungsgenossenschaft" (The Settlement Co-operative), Berlin 1898, both published by Vita; and my essay "Käufer-Verkäufer" (Buyer-Seller), Schmollers Jahrbücher 1900, October number.