Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 6 · 29 August 1903
9printed page
scan 9 of 16

No. 6 Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 9

Kremenezki reads a Russian letter from the Zionists in Baku, to the following effect:

"We send the Sixth Congress our most cordial greetings and wish it a further progressive development in the fundamental conditions of Zionism. We enclose herewith a cheque on our bank for 10 pounds for the inscription of the Sixth Congress." On the second page there is, in addition, a Hebrew letter couched in a cordial tone, which expresses the same thing in much the same sense.

At the same time Tschlenow announces that 10 pounds have likewise been donated from the Amur region for the inscription of the Sixth Congress. (Lively applause.)

A collection was organised among the members of the Congress in order that the Congress in Palestine might likewise be inscribed in the Golden Book.

Dr. Brück: Some 19 months ago we set about the creation of the National Fund. You will still remember how difficult the birth was. We disregarded formalities, however, and the National Fund was founded. It was a sturdy boy that was born. In the first 19 months we had assets of 20,000 pounds sterling. These have increased, and attention has been given to legalisation, to the form in which we are to give this child legal protection. It was proposed that a company should be founded. But what is in question is not a company but a fund, a property devoted to a purpose; neither a joint-stock company, nor a co-operative society, nor an association, but a property which exists for a definite purpose, and the administration of this property under the protection of the law. In my judgment this is possible only in the form of a foundation. The foundation corresponds entirely to what we wish to attain, whereas the proposal that we should found a joint-stock company is a mockery of the truth. It will not do for our great movement to begin with an untruth. The question now is whether the form of such a foundation can be adhered to, that is, how legal protection can be obtained. We shall easily find legal protection in any State whatever. The property will always remain intact. Anyone may add to it whatever sum he pleases. I therefore make the formal motion that the Congress instruct the National Fund Commission to draw up a report on the basis of legal foundations, and that on no account should the idea be entertained of founding joint-stock companies for the sake of appearance.

As regards the administration of the foundation, I am in favour of the following:

  1. The delegates of Switzerland, in so far as they possess Swiss rights of domicile, are to be reinforced by the A. C.

Since the A. C. is subject to the Congress, we should thus have, without prejudice to State supervision, a regulated administration over it. Were this Austria, it would have to be altered mutatis mutandis.

  1. The activity of the National Fund cannot be begun until legalisation has taken place.

Its first activity should be the founding of a National House in Basle. The capital would then be well invested, and we should have an everlasting memorial of the Jewish people.

Dr. J. W. Marmorek: I regret that in this debate I am speaking before a hall scarcely half filled (Quite right!), because I have here not merely to give my own view, but to report on some things which took place during the deliberations of the Commission to which I belong. The Commission concerned itself chiefly with 2 projects: first, the motion of Mr. Bentwich, who afterwards abandoned his motion; it was then taken up by me. In the Commission I was defeated with it. The motion which lies before you was adopted. Nevertheless I have held it my duty to inform you also of the motion rejected by the Commission. That motion rests chiefly on the consideration that a legalisation of the National Fund meets with very great difficulties, because it is hard to designate any persons who could with certainty appear as administrators, as owners, and as those entitled to dispose of the great sums of the National Fund. The Greater and the Lesser A. C. and the Congress stand, juristically considered, on so uncertain a footing that it is not possible to name these persons as proprietors before a court. That motion had therefore undertaken to remedy these difficulties radically, and thereby to find another form for securing the property of the National Fund and for securing the continual and constant application of the property to the purpose once laid down. Mr. Bentwich conceived the matter as brought into a relation under private law with the Colonial Bank. Never was the property to be made over to the Colonial Bank or merged with it, nor the Colonial Bank to derive any advantage thereby. The relation was conceived as a "three-hands relation." This construction would have the advantage that we should overcome all those difficulties which arise from the diversity of legislation in the various countries, and that every succeeding Congress would still have a handle by which to give instructions concerning this endowment.

The motion laid before you in print is to this effect: since the only persons who can be definitely designated to a judicial authority are the holders of the founders' shares, we could not lay out the construction otherwise than by building it upon these sole fixed points.

A voice: On a point of order!

President Dr. Nordau: It is an abuse to believe that speaking on a point of order means being allowed to take the floor on every occasion. When the order of business has been fixed for a given moment, one must wait until the debate is exhausted.

Dr. Marmorek continues:

The construction thus attaches itself to this sole fixed point, the holders of the founders' shares. It could not and cannot, of course, be the business of the Commission to place any power whatever in the hands of these holders of the founders' shares. These holders will have nothing else to do than to act as the legal holders of the property, in the court records, in the commercial register. It might indeed be said that the way of a foundation, in which no such persons are needed at all, would have been easier. This is incorrect, because a foundation stands too much under the supremacy of the Government in whose country it has its seat, and slips too much out of the founder's hands.

We have therefore chosen the form of holders of founders' shares. But these shares cannot be brought under the ordinary notion of a share, 1. because they yield no dividend, 2. because the holders of the shares are not to be entitled at their pleasure to have the administrators of the property ap-