Page 8. — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 6.
(continued from page 7)
…lay not with the members of the commission, but in the fact that such a commission had not been provided for in the budget.
This time we propose to you a commission which is to explore Palestine, which is of absolute importance. We do not know even the climatic conditions in Palestine. We do not know even how much rain falls in the country. In the first purchases of land topographical mistakes were made, such as the purchase of marsh lands. The soil was not known; people did not buy where they ought to have bought. Thus one ought not to have bought sandy soil in Judaea, but to have gone to Galilee, which possesses arable soil.
For all these purposes we must without fail elect a scientific commission which shall explore for us the country which we are to colonise in the future; and if, under our Organisation Statute, we may not colonise, we must at least explore where we wish to colonise next.
We must create an information bureau which shall supply us with reports on the quality and prices of land, as well as on the most important industrial conditions of the country. Our motion, which the German Landsmannschaft has adopted, reads: The election of a Palestine Commission is moved.
The purpose of the Commission is:
-
The scientific exploration of Palestine and of the surrounding countries coming into consideration, in their economic, legal and geographical aspects.
-
The establishment of an experimental station.
-
The establishment of an agricultural and technical bureau for information on land prices, quality, availability for acquisition, and industrial conditions.
-
The establishment of an experimental station for the investigation of infectious diseases.
-
The publication of a journal for the study of Palestine.
These are the motions of the German Landsmannschaft.
Dr. Hantke: The German Landsmannschaft attaches great value to the appointment of this Commission. This Commission is to operate differently from the other Palestine Commissions which we have appointed hitherto. It is to report regularly to the A. C., but is to have an independent character. For this reason the Palestine Commission is to be called in with a consultative voice at the Annual Conferences whenever matters concerning the Palestine Commission are in question.
We conceive the composition of the Palestine Commission thus: three experts are to be elected by the Congress as regular members, and these are to have the right of co-opting three further members, who form, as it were, the executive committee of the Commission and must reside in the same place. It goes without saying that at deliberations of the A. C. and of the Annual Conferences only the three members elected by the Congress have a consultative voice; the co-opted members are not called in.
The Commission can work fruitfully only if funds are at its disposal. We propose to you to grant the Commission 15,000 francs annually for the next two years. It goes without saying that the A. C. requires in this connection a clause stating that the indispensable current expenses of the party must be met in the first place.
These 15,000 francs are of course not sufficient to carry out all the plans which the Palestine Commission must carry out, but they form the foundation which makes any work at all possible for the Commission, and which shows that the Congress and the Zionist party recommend this Commission as a necessity. Money will then also flow to it from the most varied quarters.
But to avoid the impression that we perhaps imagine we can do everything possible and impossible with 15,000 francs, I expressly remark that the agricultural experimental station and the medical research station can do nothing for the present, but that for these the Commission will have to seek to raise the necessary funds.
On the organisation of the Commission I remark as follows:
-
The Commission carries out its tasks independently and is under orders to render reports.
-
The Commission consists of three experts, to whom the right of co-optation belongs.
-
At deliberations and decisions concerning the Palestine Commission in the A. C. and at Annual Conferences, the three elected members of the Commission are to be called in with a consultative voice.
-
The Commission receives for 2 years a budget of at least 15,000 francs annually.
I beg you to adopt these motions, which signify practical work toward the attainment of the Charter in Palestine, as unanimously as possible (long-continued applause).
Rosenthal (Jargon) moves that the debate be taken above all on the far more important item "National Fund," since otherwise, in view of the advanced hour, it would in the end have to be rushed through.
President Dr. Herzl: I learn this moment that the Directorate of the Bank has just withdrawn for a meeting. Therefore it would in any case not be possible to speak about the Bank now. I shall therefore use this time, if there is no objection, for the National Fund.
Dr. Loewe: Dr. Pasmanik's motion lies before you, to combine the discussion on the National Fund with the motion of the German Landsmannschaft. I beg the President to take this into consideration.
President Dr. Herzl: I do not believe that this is possible, for the motion of the German Landsmannschaft relates to something quite different. No money can be taken from the National Fund for such purposes. It has its designated objects, from which there can be no departure.
Dr. Loewe: Then I request that a vote be taken on the Palestine Commission and that the discussion on the Palestine Commission take precedence. (Applause.)
Advocate Rosenbaum: The motion of the German Landsmannschaft is clear. A debate upon it would be a waste of time. I therefore move a vote without debate.
President Dr. Herzl: I remark that the A. C. accepts the motion of the German Landsmannschaft.
Dr. Loewe: Then I move a vote without discussion.
President Dr. Herzl takes the vote.
The closure of the debate is carried.
We now enter upon the debate on the National Fund. I believe that this debate is best introduced by an acknowledgment that H. Rawikowitsch and Sons have subscribed Fr. 417.— for the inscription of this firm and its staff in the Golden Book.
