Page 6 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 5
(continued from page 5)
… spoke a word that I know well: "What concerns us is not the Jews but Judaism." "Judaism without the Jews": Just so. Take that word to a spiritualists' séance! Among the living, who wish to have life around them and before them, you will have no luck with it. (Long-continued applause.) In my opinion . . . .
President: I notice in this corner of the hall a crush where, I believe, people do not feel comfortable enough. I beg you, in the interest of order, to withdraw a little towards the back; you will hear and stand better there, and there will be no disturbances.
Speaker: Although the fifteen-minute limit does not apply to me, I shall nevertheless apply it to myself. I have to ask for your attention for only three minutes more. It is feared that we might spend the funds we have raised with so much effort, with so much bitter hardship, on provisional colonisation, so that nothing would be left for our real goal. That seems to me entirely out of the question. There is no question of using for this purpose the funds of our Colonial Bank, of the National Fund, or any remittances for Zionist purposes. Not a pfennig of them! (Tumultuous applause.) The only thing that could be justified would be the cost, on the whole insignificant, of sending out a commission of inquiry. But that would also be the maximum of financial sacrifice that could be laid upon the Zionist treasury. (Applause.) What do you risk if you appoint a commission . . . ?
President: Was that not another cry of "Shame"? Voices: No! Order! Order! Speaker: What do you risk if, for the present, you resolve merely to appoint a commission, to which you give the strict instruction to examine the plans to be laid before it by the A.-C., to take cognisance of the explanations belonging to them, and, if need be, to proceed in this examination so thoroughly that an investigation of conditions on the spot also forms an element of the inquiry? This committee will never, never be permitted to take a final decision. If necessary, a new Congress will meet for that purpose. The Jewish people itself will have to make up its mind about it in its electoral meetings. (Great applause.) Meanwhile, however, by electing a committee to examine the question laid before you, you will have fulfilled two duties. You know that I am not a member of the A.-C.; I ask no confidence for myself. But you owe your leader a proof of your confidence. You owe him the means of action which, in his judgment, he asks of you; you owe it to him, when he then begs you to put it into his hands, without thereby, in any way prejudicially, anticipating a later decision.
Then a second reason: We owe this courtesy to England as well. Not all of you appreciate at this moment the significance of the fact that a world-empire enters into negotiations with the Jewish people and makes us an offer that involves almost no reciprocity. They wish only to give. That is so fine that, from my political instinct, it seems to me almost too fine. In the face of such a courtesy, will you not show even a small courtesy in return? Will you reject an offer of this kind without so much as deigning to examine it? My last predecessor on this platform said: "Our good Herzl will put the matter right." Very well. Let us, then, begin by smashing the porcelain to pieces. Our good Herzl will make a whole pot out of it again!
I conclude. Consider what you are doing if you refuse the leader whom you profess to trust the means of answering, even with bare courtesy, a favourable offer that has come to him from the English Government. Consider what responsibility you take upon yourselves if you declare: no place of education for the Jewish people may be created either. Consider what you are bringing about in Russia. You have all read the letter which appeared yesterday in "Die Welt."
The President asks the speaker not to touch on this point. Syrkin is called to order.
Speaker: Very well, let us leave that. In another quarter than Russia, too, we have certainly awakened the earnest conviction that the matter is not settled with the simple declaration: "We will have nothing to do with you in the matter of Palestine." The two days' debate has probably strengthened or created, in the right quarter, the conviction that nothing can turn us aside from our final goal. That has been achieved. Now you may confidently appoint the commission and say: "Whatever the commission decides, whatever a later Congress decides, all that we shall create outside Palestine will always be meant and understood by us only as a preparation for Palestine." (Frenzied applause, waving of handkerchiefs, also some isolated hissing. Renewed stormy applause as the speaker steps onto the platform.)
President: I have thought it desirable to communicate to the Congress something more detailed than I had hitherto believed myself permitted to communicate. But I could not, of course, do so without having asked permission in the competent quarter, and therefore it is only now that I am in a position to make a communication to you, to communicate something supplementary — perhaps the most important matter of fact that has so far come up in this debate.
On this occasion I will also answer certain reproaches, namely that no communication was made to the Congress earlier and that in consequence nothing is known of East Africa and of the territory that might come into question. Even Dr. Nordau had to declare from the tribune that he was not sufficiently informed about the territory! We could make no communications to you earlier because we had nothing definite in hand as yet. We cannot give news like a well-informed newspaper that was able to report on the day before that someone had died. From the date of a document we shall see that it was not possible to announce these communications before the 14th of August. The President gives the floor.
Mr. Greenberg, whose appearance on the platform is greeted with applause, speaks in English (see below, Dr. Nordau).
President: You wish to make a remark about the course of the proceedings. You may do that first and then read the document.
- Dr. Herzl: In order to comply with further wishes that have been expressed, and to give the Congress an opportunity, as to the geographical position of the territory which we merely wish to investigate before we convene a Congress to take a decision, I have, as far as the means available in this short time allowed, a very hasty sketch from the hand of a delegate who fortunately