Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 52 · 26 December 1902
27printed page
scan 27 of 28

— 27 —

(continued from page 26)

...nections between the pauperisation of the Jewish masses and the position and repute of the Community underrate, and therefore do not feel the share of responsibility borne by the Community board for the ruin of so many capable, honest livelihoods. This is not, perhaps, to lay down the principle that the Community has the duty of setting on their feet all threatened or feeble livelihoods; that would exceed its moral and material resources infinitely. But what is possible, and certainly does not overstep the framework of the existing statute, is the systematic development of its charitable activities, as well as the support of all endeavours which aim at preventing or checking the economic decline among the Jews.

To this end, first and foremost, an institution must at last be called into being which has often been proposed, discussed, and even attempted, but which up to now has never yet been taken in hand with success: a certain centralisation of poor relief! Almsgiving, which as it has been practised hitherto brings in its train many hardships and injustices towards the shamefaced and the modest, ought to be brought, on definite principles, into a system whose aim would be — except where immediate distress absolutely demands charitable gifts — to employ the available means for lasting assistance, for institutions which benefit not only single individuals already in utter misery, but also the endangered mass. The anarchy of professional schnorrerdom, at the expense of so many deserving applicants who are turned away, is to be effectively opposed, and this is possible only through the establishment of a Central Register. An understanding among the individual philanthropic societies — which by no means implies any surrender of their independence — on the initiative and under the direction of the Community could soon lead here to the desired goal, all the more since this union would also represent an effective gathering of forces for the creation of the larger welfare institutions provided for by the statute.

The creation of this Central Register would also be most warmly to be welcomed from the standpoint of founding a Jewish Central Statistical Office, which likewise belongs among the tasks of the Community. Jewish statistics are to-day among the most important prerequisites of social relief on a larger scale; they are a necessity for the Jewish bodies which represent the Jews or wish to work on their behalf. Serious beginnings in this direction already exist. In Berlin there is a Central Bureau for Jewish Statistics, which has commissions working in all countries. But what is accessible to such a commission only at the greatest sacrifice stands readily at the disposal of the Communities: the factual material, the workers, the money, and the authoritative influence which, in statistical inquiries not touching upon tax monies, is effective and necessary. The field of work of the Communities in this domain is considerable, and the prospective scientific and practical results are not to be underrated.

Not only will the conditions of schools and of worship become clear; the formula "we are very badly off" will also admit of being further resolved into figures and data. The wretched conditions of housing and labour among the poorest of our people, to which greater attention should already be given now, are to become known to those competent and concerned in such a way as will make it possible to apply the available means most intensively and most profitably — an aim which, moreover, is the ideal of all welfare statistics.

Even a superficial statistics of unemployment would, for example, show the causal connexion between the demands made upon the charitable institutions and the economic crisis; it would be possible to calculate approximately how much the Communities and the private and public charitable committees could save every year if they extended more encouragement and interest to Jewish employment agencies, where and as these approach them. The moral and material advantages which the systematic support of the unemployed — that is, insurance against loss of situation for commercial employees and workmen — would bring in its train would leap to the eye.

When, therefore, the demand is raised that more Jewish spirit be allowed to penetrate into the Community chamber, this means — in keeping with the private spirit of our wonderful Mosaic legislation —: worship and charity must not be treated as a paragraph of the statutes; they must not be torn out of the whole life of the Jew as separate functions, because with us there are no boundaries between the life of practical welfare, of social justice, and of religious activity. Through all our laws runs the grand strain of the most modern insight of civilisation: that State and Society must unite — from ethical and from egoistic motives — to diminish the conditions of impoverishment, to prevent misery, to create possibilities of work and of health, that is, of existence.

The flagging interest in the work of the Community is easily explained from the Jewish psyche. The Jew wishes to have a share in the life of the whole; he wishes to have tasks assigned to him, wishes to produce, to help bring about what is good and useful. Forms and the spirit of forms have never satisfied him, have never been able to hold him, even when vanity or ease was for a time willing to make such intellectual sacrifices.

As the struggle of every day and petty want have often dragged down eminent minds, so the many and responsible administrative and formal tasks of the Community also press down the great, free Jewish spirit within it; petty and narrow-chested appear to us men who would press Judaism into formulas, who cannot themselves rise so far above formulas and points that their field of action may become a living and fruitful one, that their activity may find points of contact with, and the interest of, those concerned.

It is not a question here of enumerating all those social duties and tasks which fall to the Communities. These lines do not wish to point to special demands, such as loan and credit societies, training schools for nurses, people's kitchens and warming-rooms, etc.; but they are meant to say clearly and urgently that the Jews do not suffer merely from single evils, but have to struggle against a whole complex of resistances grounded in economic life, in the constellation of society, and in the conditions of race and language; that there is no Jewish social question which is not also inwardly bound up with the traditional laws; and that the Jews, finally, have the right to raise the earnest demand that a body which is meant to represent a gathering of the best intellectual and material forces of Jewry should not turn away indifferently from great Jewish welfare tasks, on pretexts which the Jewish spirit ought to abhor. A well-known and distinguished professor of religion once said: "A defective and bad curriculum cannot prevent me from teaching what is good. If I had nothing but the titles of Jellinek's sermons for a curriculum, I should know how to teach Judaism and the lofty Jewish spirit with it."