Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 47.
"With the exception of a burial society, I belong to no denominational society; I endeavour to instil into my children from their earliest youth love for King and Fatherland, for the dear homeland which was already a secure home to our forefathers despite many oppressions. Out of this unchangeable feeling I should combat Zionism most vehemently were it to show itself in my home — I live in a provincial town. I do not take the Zionist movement seriously; even were it practicable — what could well tempt a reasonable man to exchange the certain for the uncertain? Why, then, do the Zionists not go to Palestine? Surely no one prevents them; on the contrary! He who believes that his fatherland is Palestine, he who does not think German and feel German and will not learn to do so, who ever sees only the slights and never the great love which the German homeland has for the Jew too — let him go out, as soon as possible; the ones who remain behind lose nothing by him. — But how many would go if it came to earnest, how many, I wonder, of those who to-day stand at the head of Zionism, The cultivation of love for the great German Fatherland — doing everything that can bring about assimilation — inwardly through the adoption of a purely German way of thinking, outwardly through the stripping off of everything Oriental that may still cling, in speech, etc., even of the less educated elements; withdrawal from all international societies, even when they serve purposes of culture (Alliance Israélite); and above all the cessation of solidarity among the Jews — whereby the whole community of faith feels itself struck when wrong is done to any co-religionist — without prejudice to energetic personal defence against personal attacks: that is the only justified, true Zionism. There is no doubt that assimilation is making progress, that countless people think as I do, but it must be carried through. This can happen only through an inner mission; the money that flows to the Alliance Israélite for co-religionists abroad — how beneficially it could be employed at home for the raising of German culture among our co-religionists — not only in Posen. The same would be made easier if there were no influx of foreign Jews."
To this the "Schles. Ztg." attached no further remark. But we shall hardly go astray if we assume that the writer of this last letter is a Jew after the heart of this antisemitic paper. Every word of criticism of it is superfluous. But that Dr. Zlocisti proclaimed a "re-Orientialisation" does not appear even from the very objective report of the "Schles. Ztg." That it has merely read into it. It takes the revival of Jewish culture in a modern spirit for that. But that is surely something considerably different, as has indeed already been sufficiently pointed out in the other letter to the "Schles. Ztg."
Interesting is the remark "that the Jewish population possesses very considerable rights and also knows how to make use of them": even if for that reason the "Schles. Zig." no longer sympathises with Zionism, we Zionists will not let ourselves be deprived of a criticism of existing conditions. Nor will we let ourselves be deprived — even though we wish to build ourselves a new home — of working meanwhile, besides, to make the old one more habitable, if only for those who themselves wish to dwell in it later on. Even the Jewish letter-writer of the "Schles. Ztg." from the provinces can change nothing in this. In point of fact the "Schles. Ztg." too took up a different standpoint three years ago. At that time it wrote (30th March 1899), in connection with an article of the "Konserv. Korresp.":
"For Germany a success of the movement, which has grown beyond expectation, would be of advantage. Necessity commands that provision be made for the Jewish masses perishing in misery in the East. If the Jews remember their tribal origin and the obligation arising from it, no one will on that account suppose that they are unpatriotic. If, rather, the countries of Western Europe are freed from the continual influx of poor Jews without means of livelihood, and if the most burning part of the Jewish question is thus practically solved by Zionism, then the movement will earn gratitude, just as even to-day approval cannot be denied to its theoretical aims."
That, after all, sounds somewhat different from the present standpoint. Can Dr. Zlocisti's arguments really be to blame for the change of mind?
I am almost inclined to believe something else. The present view of the "Schles. Ztg." reminds one all too strongly of one that is very well known to us Zionists, one that is very often held up against us by our opponents at our meetings. I cannot here suppress the surmise that the "Schles. Ztg." came to its change of opinion through — assimilationist kinsmen, to whom the whole friendly attitude hitherto maintained towards us by the Conservative paper had long been a vexation; to which must be added that the "Schles. Ztg.'s" reporter who wrote the account is a former Jew and still to-day has many connections with Jews. Hitherto we were even reproached at our meetings: "You see, the antisemitic paper, the "Schles. Ztg.," actually praises you, because you Zionists do the antisemites' business for them."
Moreover, the letter of the Zionist correspondent to the "Schles. Ztg." concluded as follows:
"The German Emperor said recently in Posen: "The Kingdom of Prussia is made up of many voices, which are proud of their former history and individuality. That does not prevent them from being, above all, good Prussians." Should that not hold good of the Jews also, who are proud of their individuality and do not wish to let it perish?"
Why the "Schles. Ztg." left out this passage, I wonder, With its former attitude towards Zionism the "Schles. Ztg.," to the astonishment of all who know it, was for the first time objective on a Jewish question. Can it have regretted that?
Be that as it may: the sympathy of the "Schles. Ztg." could not further us; its antipathy will harm us just as little.
Hugo Schachtel.
Austria-Hungary.
On the Vienna Communal Election.
Last Monday the official electors' meeting of the Jewish Community took place in the Hotel "zur Post." It looked as though the Viennese officials were afraid of the Viennese Jews. For no fewer than a dozen attendants, with drawn official countenances, guarded the entrance to Paradise, and in the hall numerous young officials of the Community saw to the maintenance of disorder, so that there might always be a ground for closing the sitting; for alas! there were also many Opposition speakers at the meeting. The meeting was in fact closed by the Vice-President, Dr. Stern, who took over the chair soon after the beginning owing to the indisposition of the President; but the storm of indignation compelled the withdrawal of the measure.
Imperial Councillor Mr. Klinger welcomed those present and explained that he wished the suggestions and complaints of the electorate might be directed to the Board not always before the polling, but the whole year round. (Does the President not know that there is a Jewish press? That is surely a perpetual wish-list of Jewry; not the most respectfully devoted press, but the press of the people. To be sure, it demands a large-minded policy and not a patchwork policy consisting exclusively of gracious grants of money — one, rather, that has a sense for our future.)
One after another the candidates of the official election committee now come forward, and most of them bring out, word for word, the following winged words: "I have been a member of the Board for 17, 14, 6 years. I cannot set out a programme for you. I ask for your confidence." Would one believe it? The Viennese Jewish electorate applauded its own mockery. In these times, of which a tried non-Zionist authority on the conditions said that they will shortly lead to the ruin of the Vienna Jewish Community, the official candidates do not know what they will do, and reap applause into the bargain for this confession. Only the quite new candidates said a few words about the tax, spoke, for instance, of social relief, but showed themselves most highly satisfied with the existing inadequate institutions.
A nervous unrest arose when our candidate, Architect Mr. Marmorek, took the floor. Every word of criticism led to uproar on the other side; the President protested time after time against alleged provocation. But the speaker, undeterred, set forth the demands of our programme — the demands upon the leadership of the Community in questions of the intellectual and economic elevation of the Jewish people, as leader of an organisation for the whole Empire, as guardian of a Jewish proletariat growing like an avalanche — and at the close reaped the applause of many who were convinced. As he said something about the numerous conversions, the President made an official declaration: there were by no means so many as people said. Only 2834 in 4 years.
There then spoke yet another candidate, enraptured with the present conditions, whereupon Dr. Kahn came to speak as a candidate. He drew a parallel between the official programme and that of the Opposition, and subjects the abuses in the Community to a weighty criticism. The best proof that he had hit the nail on the head was given by the excitement of certain pillars of the existing system, who shouted him down when he expressed the demand that absolutely clean elections should take place, not as two years ago.
Thereby those demagogues were branded who two years ago permitted themselves, in their election appeal, the exclamation, the unheard-of remark, that if our candidates were elected the taxpayers would have to pay for utopian purposes.