No. 47. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
...agree with. How can one let an electoral campaign in Roumania be played out under the eyes of Europe? And the good old brawls and the traditional Jew-baiting and all the political speeches — what becomes of these? Yes, that is unpleasant; and so it also came about that a Liberal adherent of Mr. Stourdza, placed in the dreadful position of either having to keep silent or of inventing something new against the Jews, found himself compelled to sacrifice the diplomatic interests of his chief and, amid the stormy cheers of an enraptured audience, to make the Jews (the "Alliance israélite," the Jewish millionaires, etc.) responsible for the already well-known articles of Take Jonescu. This Mr. Culoglu did, and Mr. Stourdza, not a little disturbed thereby in his hypocritical neutrality, could not even protest against his party colleague: — c'est l'usage du pays! Or was he to leave the fine effect of this word to the Opposition and so prepare the defeat of his own party? That will not do, the less so as Mr. Culoglu thereby worked in two directions. He proved, firstly, to the P. T. public how fast-dyed the antisemitism of the Liberal party has remained even now; and secondly he compromises Mr. Take Jonescu and with him the whole Conservative party, which has sold itself to the "Finance juive"! But it would have been better, after all, if Mr. Stourdza and his party men had not been obliged to put any constraint upon themselves at all, that is, if Europe would no longer concern itself with Roumania. How fine were the times when the Boyars, "free," to their hearts' content and without troubling themselves about so-called principles of civilisation, were masters in their own house, made laws, played politics and terrorised! Longing for this "free" time, Mr. Stourdza devised his new political manoeuvre, which is to restore to the country the desired darkness. It is a question of nothing less than the naturalisation of the Jews! Yes, of the naturalisation of the Roumanian Jews — but not of all the Roumanian Jews, and not now. And I must also remark at once that it is not Mr. Stourdza who takes upon himself the obligation to naturalise a part of the Jews, but certain anonymous editors on newspapers friendly to Mr. Stourdza. The matter stands thus: Mr. Stourdza cannot promise it, because the Conservatives would stir up the people against him; on the other hand, the Jews will hope and keep silent. Mr. Stourdza has thus in fact promised nothing which he will also perform at the proper moment, and now has peace on the part of the Jews, who will await the fulfilment of the promise. And because Mr. Stourdza is a genuine Roumanian politician, his plan aims not only at winning the Jews over to himself but also at dividing them, by promising the rights only to a part of the Jews. There are, namely, so it is said, to be naturalised the "titled," the educated among the Jews, and the rich who own a factory or some other large undertaking in Roumania. Thus Mr. Stourdza hopes to procure himself peace at a stroke. The rich will hope and keep silent. The others, the dumb and ignorant mass of the poor and "untitled," will keep silent and die. To make the matter more credible, certain better-known Roumanian politicians are commissioned — men whose word and opinion carry weight, but who are "Wild Men," that is, belong regularly to no regular party but render services to all governments, and whose word therefore binds Mr. Stourdza no more than the anonymous articles in the party press — to occupy themselves likewise with the Jewish question and to arrive at the same conclusion. Thus Mr. G. Panu, formerly chief of the Radicals and now a "Wild Man" in the service of Mr. Stourdza, recently occupied himself with the Jewish question in his weekly "Saptamina," and arrived, as had been agreed, at this same partial naturalisation in the near future. Until then, he advised, the "titled" should be calm and keep silent. It seems, however, that this time the lie can deceive no one.
N.
Germany.
Breslau. (The Consistency of the "Schlesische Zeitung.") On the 8th of November the "Schlesische Zeitung," after an objective report of a meeting of the Breslau Zionist Society (speaker: Dr. Th. Zlocisti), published the following remarks of the editors:
The lecture was received with lively applause and met with no contradiction whatever. The meeting had been opened by the chairman with some communications, taken from the last report of activity of the Zionist Actions Committee, on the further progress of the Zionist movement. The male audience at the meetings here, in which numerous ladies have also always taken part, consists predominantly of younger people belonging to the most various callings. The riper ages are but sparsely represented. The Jewish citizenry of Breslau that really stands in practical life seems, therefore, to devote scarcely any interest to the movement. But should the Zionist agitation, which disposes of oratorical forces deserving of recognition, remain effective in the long run, then it may in the not too distant future produce profound differences: both within the Jewish population itself, whose members inclining more to the German than to the Jewish character are hated and mocked by the Zionists as "Assimilation Jews," and also between the Zionists and the Germans in general, who will perhaps not always be inclined to regard such a re-Orientalisation, such an ever more obtrusive emphasis on Jewish national consciousness, as compatible with the possession of the rights of German citizenship.
On the 16th of November the paper publishes the following article:
The report published in No. 787 of this paper on the recruiting lecture of Dr. Zlocisti, delivered at a meeting of the Breslau Zionist Society, has given occasion to several letters addressed to us, which we cannot reproduce here in full, since this — however interesting this symptomatic movement within Judaism may be — would after all lead us too far, in view of its comparatively slight practical importance. Nevertheless the letters contain some remarks which shall be dealt with here in a few words.
The one letter, emanating from the Zionist association here, first of all reproaches the "Schles. Ztg." with fickleness in its treatment of Zionism. It had formerly regarded Zionism objectively, wished it a favourable progress, and with the "Kons. Korr." described it as deserving approval practically and theoretically. Now all of a sudden a re-Orientalisation is perceived in Zionism, and the emphasis on Jewish national consciousness is regarded as incompatible with the possession of the rights of German citizenship. The writer forgets that the re-Orientalisation is not our invention, but was proclaimed by the speaker of the evening (Dr. Zlocisti), and that a sharpness hitherto unobserved had likewise been given to the emphasis on Jewish nationality. To this the concluding remarks in No. 787 of this paper referred. It is therefore wholly out of place when the writer of the letter further writes:
"The "Schles. Ztg." quite forgets that the German Jews have, or are meant to have, only very paper rights of citizenship. But above all it forgets that Zionism is chiefly a great work of relief, that Zionism exists in the first line for the Jews of Eastern Europe, and that the German Jews come into question here only in the second rank. Certainly, should it succeed in creating a home for the restless wanderers, a union of these in a commonwealth of some kind, then German Jews too, especially German-Jewish university men, even those who to-day still stand hostile to Zionism, will go to those brethren of theirs and act and labour for them, and find there the recognition that is denied to their activity in this country. Is that to be unpatriotic, whereas emigration to America, etc., is not? Or does the "Schles. Ztg." perhaps fear the loss of these men for culture? Then it surely does not know that the German Jews were bearers of German culture from the earliest Middle Ages — very involuntary ones, to be sure, namely when they were cruelly driven out of Germany. So too Zionism to-day by no means aims at a re-Orientalisation; rather it wishes to carry West European culture to the East. And then: to-day Jews can create values of culture only in a limited measure, since they are everywhere hindered therein by antisemitic hostility, since all the public means necessary for it are not placed at their disposal — unless they have themselves baptised."
In these sentences the positive economic aim of Zionism is mingled with tendencies such as are at home in the "Society for Defence against Antisemitism," in a manner that will scarcely win new sympathies for the cause of Zionism. That the Jews in Germany have, "or are meant to have, only very paper rights of citizenship" is an assertion that will not fail to arouse some astonishment, for hitherto it has been assumed not only on the Christian but also on the Jewish side that the Jewish population possesses very considerable rights and also knows how to make use of them. Quite different from the letter mentioned above sounds another expression of opinion, which has reached us from a Jewish reader in the provinces, in which it says, among other things: