Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 47 · 21 November 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 47.

(continued from page 3)

…el themselves, and to claim a normal national position for themselves. This hard and toilsome work of re-awakening the national individuality was made easier for the Jews by the attitude of the nations, which cast them out from among themselves as a foreign element and, without much courtesy or consideration, pointed to the real or supposed contrasts, or at least differences, between themselves and the Jews.

The principle of nationality, in its exaggeration, has led to excesses. It has strayed into Chauvinism, and degraded itself to idiotic hatred of foreigners and grotesque self-worship. From these caricatures Jewish nationalism is safe. Jewish nationalism does not suffer from megalomania. On the contrary, it feels that it must first by toil make the name of Jew a name of honour. It modestly acknowledges the merits of the nations, and wishes merely to strive zealously to equal them, so far as its natural capacities reach. It knows what terrible devastation centuries of slavery have wrought upon its original pride and upright character, and endeavours to repair it by persistent self-discipline.

Antisemitism has taught many modern Jews to find the way back to their people. It has had the effect of a severer test, which the weak could not withstand, but from which the stronger have emerged with greater confidence in themselves. It is not correct to call Zionism a "creation of defiance" or "an act of despair against Antisemitism." It is true that educated Jews were brought solely and exclusively by Antisemitism to link their fate with Judaism, and would perhaps relapse if their Christian fellow-countrymen were to receive them kindly again. But with most Zionists Antisemitism has had only the one effect, that they were brought to reflect upon their position towards the other nations, and their reflections have led them to results which have left traces in their minds and hearts that would endure permanently even if Antisemitism were to vanish from the world entirely.

Be it well understood: this Zionism here analysed is that of the educated and free Jews; the uneducated mass, which clings to the old traditions, is Zionist without much reflection — through its feeling, through its instinct, through its distress and its longing. This Jewish mass suffers too much from the hardships of life, from the hatred of the nations, from legal restrictions and from social exclusion. It feels that it cannot hope for a lasting improvement of its condition so long as it is compelled to live powerless in the midst of a hostile majority. It wishes to be a nation, to rejuvenate itself by union with Mother Earth, and for once to become mistress of its own destiny. This Zionist mass is in part not yet free from mystical tendencies. It must be admitted that its Zionism is in part still filled with Messianic stirrings and religious feelings. It has a clear idea of the longing for the restoration of the Jewish nation, but not of the means necessary thereto. Yet they have recognised the necessity of their own exertions, and there is therefore a great difference between their energetic readiness to organise and to make sacrifices, and the pious inactivity of the religious Messianists, which demands nothing but prayers.

III.

At such historic moments it fortunately always comes to pass that the man appears whose mission it is to give clear expression to the ideas which many others dimly feel, and to utter aloud the word which the others have long been waiting to hear. This man was Dr. Theodor Herzl. In the autumn of 1896 he published a pamphlet under the title "Der Judenstaat" ("The Jewish State"), which with a precision hitherto wanting proclaimed the fact that the Jews are a people which may claim for itself all the rights of a people, and may cherish the wish to dwell in a land of its own, where it could lead a free and complete political existence.

"The Jewish State" has become the starting-point of political Zionism — the starting-point, not the programme. Herzl's book is still the subjective work of a solitary thinker who speaks in his own name. The real programme had to become a collective work, which, though founded upon Herzl's book and influenced by Herzl's vision of the future, is freed from all its fantastic ideas and built solely upon the ground of reality.

Herzl's book was greeted by thousands of Jews, especially the young, as an act of redemption. It was not to remain mere printed paper, but to be translated into practical deed. Societies were founded everywhere which no longer aimed at a gentle, gradual settlement in Palestine, but had as their object the preparations for a mass immigration into the Holy Land, following upon a previous treaty with the Turkish Government which was to be sanctioned by the Great Powers.

Dr. Herzl recognised that the first task he had to fulfil must be the organisation of a demonstration which should bring to the world, and to the Jewish people itself, knowledge of the fact of its national existence. He convened a Zionist Congress, which, in spite of the furious attacks and unscrupulous acts of violence of its opponents (the Jewish ones), assembled at the end of August 1897 and consisted of 204 elected representatives of the Zionist Jews of both hemispheres.

(To be concluded.)


Race Feeling and Nationalism.¹)

By Dr. Friedrich Gernandt.

In spite of all the efforts of the world-reformers and political sentimentalists, the peoples and States will not "fraternise." The internationalism of the labour movement preached by Marx has gone badly to pieces. Apart from theoretical discussions, moral compliments and small money subsidies, the cry "Proletarians of all countries, unite!" has died away fairly without effect. The English working class, with the exception of the impotent protests of the small Marxist Socialist group, never in the least thought of preventing the Boer War, which according to Social-Democratic theory should have been one of the most important civilising tasks of the proletariat. On the contrary, the English workmen joined in the nationalist and imperialist jubilation; and wherever several nationalities dwell side by side or intermingled within one State, there the adherents of Social Democracy begin to confront one another just as the bourgeois parties do.

Just as fruitlessly have the Hague Arbitration Conference and the international peace movement, set on foot still earlier by parliamentarians and writers, run into the sand.

On the other hand, we see in almost every country a nationalist movement awakening and growing powerful. World-reformers and Utopians see in it only megalomania and popular incitement. But whoever looks somewhat more deeply into the natural laws of the life of nations recognises in it the re-awakening of a natural race instinct, which rises up mightily against the arbitrary jumbling together of the nations by past wars and by the present economic supremacy of Capitalism, as well as against the dominion of the world-fraternising ideas of Christianity and Socialism.


¹) From the excellent "Politisch-anthropologische Revue", monthly for the social and intellectual life of the nations, 1st year, No. 8. Editors: Ludwig Woltmann and Hans K. E. Buhmann; Thüringische Verlagsanstalt, Eisenach and Leipzig.