Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 43 · 24 October 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 43

(continued from page 3)

. . . man who sold the bear's skin before the beast was killed held me back. In vain did I tell myself that a tried marksman with a sure eye and a steady hand, with that courage which dares to stake life itself, with exact knowledge of the qualities and habits of bears and of the dangers of the forest — a marksman who has long been following the tracks of the beast and knows precisely where it lurks — that such a huntsman might perhaps be excused if, while on the chase, he dwelt for a moment upon the use he meant to make of the dead bear's skin. In vain: the fear of seeming a visionary was stronger than reasonable reflection.

Great, therefore, was my joyful surprise when I read the words of Herr Rosenbaum, advocate, at Minsk: "The land purchased with the capital of the National Fund is inalienable and remains for all time the property of the whole Jewish people. It may be leased for a shorter or longer period, but may never become private property."

The speaker has here hit the mark; as a Zionist I feel myself indebted to him, and regret from my heart that his proposal was not unanimously adopted. Herr R., however, will have rendered our cause a great service when this shall have taken place at a general Zionist Congress, and I hope that he will soon find occasion to set forth his ideas to the delegates of the Jewish world in such a manner that the principle of the inalienability of every parcel of Erez Israel may find its place in the future Charter.

And such an exposition presents no excessive difficulties.

The right of private property, the foundation of society, comprises the full yield of the labour of the individual members of society. But to extend this right so far that it includes within itself the necessary condition of all labour is an abuse which, like all abuses, has avenged itself. Mother Earth is a gift of the Creator to the whole of mankind, entrusted in His name to the various societies, and may therefore not be monopolised by the individual. It is an encroachment which has spread over Europe together with Roman law, with the partial exception of the Slavonic lands, notably Russia; and the Russian intelligentsia appears, perhaps not without reason, to see in the "Mir" the road to the hegemony of Russia.

History speaks to us here only too plainly. For at all times and everywhere it has been shown that the principle of private property, applied to land, has within a short time split the population into two parts: into rich and proletarians. It was the latifundia, the great landed estates, that levelled the way for the barbarians and put an end to the Roman dominion of the world. It is the great landed estates that depopulated Ireland and compelled the descendants of those 250,000 yeomen, who as late as the middle of the XVIIIth century were the pride of England, to seek their bread as day-labourers. And so everywhere in the civilised world; everywhere a comparatively small minority, relying upon this abuse, has been able to disinherit the great mass of the people.

Now I know well that land is no longer the sole wealth of a people, that, on the contrary, floating capital plays the most important part in the economy of nations in our time; I know, too, that it is capital which, through mortgage bonds and priorities, has become the real owner of the fields and forests. But this alters nothing in the matter, since it must be a matter of indifference to the small husbandman whether his field belongs to the nearest nobleman or to the mortgage bank of the distant capital.

Without that preventive measure, things would go in the new Erez Israel as they went in the old. The agrarian legislation of Moses did not, after all, succeed in averting the baneful consequences of the abuse of a principle in itself natural; to this the denunciations of the Prophets against the rich bear witness, as do our Holy Scriptures in general. For that legislation was, after all, but a half-measure; the private right of property in land was stronger than all laws, and soon split Israel, too, into poor and rich.

And all that the humane legislation of the XVIIIth and XIXth centuries has been able to devise, with the intention of preserving to the small cultivator his little plot, has likewise remained a mere substitute; and therefore the time is no longer far off when the "nationalisation" of the soil will have superseded the right of private property, and the late Henry George will be honoured as the hero that he is.

But even apart from the splendid course of the Zionist fraternisation at Minsk, the immediate fact, the mere meeting of this assembly, is at once a promise and a pointer. For a representation of this kind of Russian subjects on Russian soil with the sanction of the Russian authorities is something entirely new and unique for as long as Jews have lived in Russia. And the fact that it was precisely Jews with whom the experiment was made, and that the attempt had a happy course and issue, contains the promise that the voice of the Jews will be tolerated and heard also on matters touching the position of the Jews in the country itself. And this legalisation of Jewish initiative is, on the other hand, a pointer to the fact that the Russian authorities in return — do ut des — henceforth expect that the young Jewish intelligentsia and the Jewish workers will turn their minds to the Jewish future, away from the Russian present and the internal Russian movements, which have already cost tears enough without bettering the position of the Jews, but rather in many respects worsening it. That intelligentsia and our working brethren will, as Sokolow says, not take it upon themselves to censure wrongs done to foreign peoples — peoples who have done and are doing wrong to our people — but will always remember that charity begins at home and that a people is ever nearest to itself. The Russian authorities have held out their hand to our people; it behoves us to grasp this hand gratefully, in the well-founded hope that that strong hand will protect us in our endeavours and in the task that awaits us: to make ready the building of our own house upon our own soil.

The Russian aristocracy is not the Jew's worst enemy, and besides — leave the stone where it is! said the peasant; he saw his child pushing at the tower!

Copenhagen.

Josef Michaelsen.