No. 37. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.
Minsk, 5 September, afternoon.
The discussion of the reports of the district chiefs continued the whole of to-day. Particularly sharp criticism was made by the delegates Dr. Bragin (Simferopol) and Scheinkin (Balta), who demand a reconstruction of the Russian organisation from the ground up. In the end the National Conference expressed its confidence in the district chiefs.
*
Minsk, 7 September.
The Sabbath passed in an uplifting manner. Zionist addresses were delivered in many synagogues. Many who had hitherto stood aloof declared their adherence to the movement. After the close of the Sabbath Ussischkin spoke, amid great applause, on the general organisation of the Russian Zionists.
To-day, Sunday, continuation of the discussion on the National Fund and the Colonial Bank.
The special correspondent of the St. Petersburg "Nowosti," in his article from Minsk, draws the following interesting picture of the opening, on Thursday last, of the first All-Russian Zionist Conference at Minsk: "The opening of the Conference in the great hall of the 'Hotel Paris' took place at 11 o'clock in the forenoon. But already by 7 o'clock in the morning all the streets leading to the Conference's place of meeting were occupied by dense masses of people. The delegates as they drove past were stormily greeted by the crowd in the street, as well as by the spectators gathered on the balconies of the houses. At the entrance to the hall students formed a chain, admitting none but those who showed a card of admission. When the plenipotentiaries of the Conference, Messrs. Bruck, Belkowsky, Goldberg, Rabbinowitsch, Ussischkin, Tschlenow and Jasinowski appeared, long-sustained cheers rang out. Bruck read a telegram of greeting from Dr. Herzl, which mightily heightened the enthusiasm of the assembly. At that moment the hall presented a rare sight. All, men and women, old and young, orthodox and enlightened, rose from their seats and cried: 'Hedad, Hedad!' Dr. Bruck said in his opening address that the Conference pursued the purpose of discovering ways and means of bringing about the regeneration of the Jewish people. The successes of the Zionist movement are gigantic; they express themselves chiefly in the heightening of the national self-consciousness of the Jews. Favourable political conditions, created thanks to the brilliant and untiring activity of Dr. Herzl, opened the hope of a good future. These words were received with never-ending applause and clapping of hands. Dr. Bruck closed his address with the declaration that the Jews would in the end attain the goal of their striving, because in culture, vitality and loyalty they can measure themselves against all other peoples. The Russian paper appearing in Minsk, the 'Minskij Listok,' devotes an article to the Zionist Conference in which, among other things, the following is said: "The Zionists, to whom the laws of history are known, have, in fulfilment of their task, the foundation of a Jewish State, directed their whole attention to raising the intellectual and cultural level of the Jews. And indeed, only the enlightenment of the Jewish masses can bring about the regeneration of the people. And if the Minsk Conference should succeed in bringing this question to a favourable solution, the delegates may leave Minsk in the consciousness of having done a truly good work for their fellow-countrymen." Gt.
The Activity and Balance-Sheet of the "Ica."
The balance-sheet of the "Ica" which we reproduced from the "Jewish Express" of London contains an unintelligible item: in paragraph 2, "Annual Subventions," a "Lace School in Jerusalem" is named among the subsidised institutions. No such school, however, exists. It should read instead "Lämmel School in Jerusalem." And this confusion has the following history: in the manuscript before the "Jew. Expr." the word "Lämmelschule" must have been indistinctly written, and it was set by the compositor in the Jargon text as "Laces-Schule." Laces is the English word for Spitzen. The Lämmel School is a foundation established in Jerusalem at the beginning of the last century by a Vienna communal president.
*
The organ of the "Ica," the "Jewish Chronicle," writes that it is authorised to state that the figures of the published balance-sheet are incorrect. Further, it has been declared more than once that the "Ica" does not intend to publish its balance-sheet.
That is very short and to the point, and — very convenient. But the foundation of Baron Hirsch is a public institution devoted to the entire Jewish people. So long as there was no public opinion in Jewry, nobody troubled himself about the doings of the trustees of these millions. But the newly reviving Jewry has already formed a public opinion of its own, and this will raise ever more energetically the demand that it be given an account of the administration of this national foundation. Only a subsidised press, or one hungering for subsidies, can fall from the outset into panegyrics and raptures without exact knowledge of the achievements and successes and without knowledge of the means expended. But what has been accomplished with the 11·5 millions (for this sum is undisputed) is shown by — the annual report of the "Ica" just issued. Be it remarked in passing, this is not word for word the same report that was sent to the trustees (who, as the organ of the "Ica" wrote at the time, would not take the trouble to come to Paris for the general meeting), but a report edited for the public by a sub-committee. Well, this report finds itself obliged to record — failures in the great majority of the undertakings.
While the "voluntarily ministerial," such as the Berlin "Jüdische Presse" of Dr. Hildesheimer, can scarcely contain themselves for rapture, the "Jewish Chronicle" writes in its number of 5 September:
"The report of the 'Ica' is not a uniformly satisfactory document. It is a record of varying fortune, in which the elements have played no inconsiderable sad part. In Argentina the drought exercised an unhappy influence upon the standing crops and bears a great share of the blame for the failure of the colonies Moisesville and Entre Rios. And in Palestine the same misfortune befell the colonists, while the phylloxera wrought havoc among the vines. All these occurrences, however, are dispensations of God, and all the wisdom of the world could not have avoided them. They mean a delay in the development of the colonies towards independence and prosperity, and serve to provoke criticism of the activity of the 'Ica.' But they are unavoidable incidents with which every great undertaking of this kind must reckon; and — as we have said before — anyone who expects sudden and wonderful changes in the situation of Jewry through the 'Ica' or any other body must suffer disappointment. Not five millions, nor ten millions, nor even fifty millions will solve the Jewish Question. It is no matter of silver or gold, but of sound and patient statesmanship. It (the solution of the Jewish Question) depends upon the wisdom of others and not upon the cheque-book of the Jews."
*
So far the "Jew. Chr." We are entirely of its opinion that money alone will not solve the Jewish Question — and Dr. Herzl stated it precisely before the Alien Immigration Commission: a great idea and a flag are needed for it. And since the "Ica" lacks these, its activity will always remain mere carters' labour. We shall continue the instructive report of the "Ica" in our next number.
Zionism in South America.
One of the most remarkable phenomena in the history of the development of the Zionist movement is the fact that Zionism flourishes even where so-called antisemitism and other factors unfavourable to the Jews display no active operation. This fact has hitherto been too little emphasised, and yet it is in the highest degree fitted to illustrate clearly the great power of attraction of Zionism.
We are led to this remark by the accounts of a Russian traveller, who in the periodical "Juschnoje Obosrenje" ("Southern Review"), appearing in Odessa, very interesting travel sketches from Argentina