No. 37. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…this temple, where you confided your sorrows to the Eternal, where you today acknowledge in Italy a mother and in all Italians brothers, swear today upon these divine books which we revere that you will love Italy with all your heart, with all your soul, with all the forces of your life, that you will be devoted to her with a great, unchanging love, at all times, in every distress." And the Italian Jews faithfully fulfilled his exhortation. Not only have they made themselves into complete Italians, but, as Lombroso ⁴) says, in the Venetian territory they have become wholly Venetians, so that they would fit into a comedy of Goldoni, and in Tuscany they imitate Stenterello ⁵). Faithfully devoted to their fatherland, with its interests alone before their eyes, they pride themselves on its culture, sing and study with zeal and love the heroes of Italy, its poets and thinkers, and speak with enthusiasm of Rome, of the Campidoglio or the Quirinal, as of their national (!) monuments. And in that same Rome where the Arch of Titus stands, in the same Rome where the most wretched of all ghettos has been preserved as a pillory of history, the on. Luzzatti, Barzilai, etc., deliver fiery speeches for "their" nation, for the greatness and world significance of Rome.⁶) "Ils sont plus italiens que les italiens memes"… The Jew has thrown himself into every field of Italy's collective life; he takes part in every branch and every enterprise; he steers the helm of the ship of state, directs public opinion, teaches and educates the young, and labours untiringly ad majorem gloriam Italiae. In the comparatively short span since the emancipation of the Jews they have furnished such meritorious sons, who are an ornament to their fatherland, as Lombroso, Loria, Luzzatti (Luigi, properly Salomon), Massarani, D'Ancona, and so forth. Now when a people, a stock alien to the land ⁷), thus fuses itself, incorporates itself into the people of the land, the natural expectation would be that the prevailing mass of the population would swallow it up entirely and make it unrecognisable. Such was the case with all immigrants in most civilised countries. Thus the French who migrated into Prussia under Frederick the Great vanished completely among the Germans, and the Germans in Russia or America, etc., among their host peoples. But the physiognomy of the Jewish race is far too peculiar, far too prominent, for anything of the kind to be feared in its case.
Henry George, the celebrated American political economist, says in his excellent book "Social Problems," with reference to America: "When things go too well in a country, when capital is heaped upon capital and the population increases with giant strides, then behind its back stands the fate of Polycrates, the envious one." And these words, even if not wholly true where America is concerned, are applicable to our case, the life and doings of the Italian Jews. While before the Russian and Roumanian Jews the problem rears itself up in a menacing, fearful attitude: "How and where to live?", before the Italian Jews another problem arises, but with no less urgency: "To be or not to be?". Freed from all the fetters that bound him to traditional Judaism, saturated with Italian thought and aspiration, nothing remains for the modern Italian Jew, nothing that would hold him back from complete assimilation, and the modern Italian Jew has no longer any "raison d'etre" for his Judaism, and Italian Jewry is gradually losing its best forces. In vain do the
⁴) C. Lombroso: L'antisemitismo e le scienze moderne, Turin 1894.
⁵) A character from a Florentine comedy of the seventeenth century.
⁶) Cf., for example, the speech of the on. Luzzatti at the Victor Hugo celebration in Rome.
⁷) Although the Italian Jews would like to pass themselves off as Latins of pure blood, as Guidetti seeks to maintain in his book "Pro Judaeis."
rabbis of Italy strive to rekindle the flame of faith. The time of religious questions, however, is past; the place of faith is now taken by other ideals, purely human ones. The old faith gives way before the new. Nor has there been any lack of attempts to reconcile Judaism with science, to modernise it; thus S. D. Luzzatti came forward with his "Giudaismo Illustrato," and E. Benamozegh with his philosophy of religion, but their attempts have borne little fruit; their voice remained a cry in the wilderness. But the Jewish Proteus, who each time assumes new forms, sometimes bizarre, sometimes grand, but always viable and suited to the age — he, the phoenix that rises rejuvenated from its own ashes — now awakens under another guise, in a new, modern form: the ethnic. Such is ever the lot of the Jews: when once the storm of religious strife has abated, when the Jews, after the brief rest granted them, fancy themselves wholly in a safe harbour, then the peoples who harbour them scent a new danger, and they begin to proclaim aloud to the Jews who cling to them the bitter truth that they are a peculiar stock, of peculiar mental endowment, of peculiar inclinations and ideals. When the religious question ceases, the economic one begins, and the ethnic one springs forth. In one of his articles (in the "Nuova Rassegna," 1893) the celebrated sociologist and chief leader of Italian socialism, Ferri, writes the following weighty words: "Although sporadic, latent antisemitism is at home everywhere in Europe, true, furious antisemitism flares up only in those countries where two parties of wholly opposite tendency are in conflict: thus in Germany, where socialism is advancing, in Russia, where there is nihilism, and Austria, where there is nationalism. In those countries, on the other hand, where socialism makes no conquering strides forward, antisemitism too has not spread, as for example in England, Italy and Spain." These words of the brilliant Italian scholar seem at first to be a paradox: What? Socialism, which would turn brotherhood and justice from a mere phrase into flesh and blood, is to lead to antisemitism! But if one looks closely into the matter, Ferri's dictum is very true and profoundly well founded. Life, history, is the fulfilment of the necessity imposed by circumstances, by the struggle for existence; it knows no consideration, no sentimentality. A nation, a class, a social order is supported, fostered and defended, or hated, persecuted and disinherited, not merely out of sympathy or antipathy, not merely on religious, that is to say psychological, grounds, but rather from motives which stand in the most intimate relation to the economic and political life of the given people, are rooted deep in the bosom of the people's history, and are in the closest connexion with the strongest — that is, above all the material — needs of the people. But the position of the Jews in the countries of Western Europe is so constituted, has been so shaped by their historical life, that in the economic struggle they can find no sympathy precisely with the awakening class of the proletariat and its spokesmen. Let us illustrate this by the example of the very country that occupies us at the present hour — Italy. The 38 000 Jews who are in Italy, and who live almost exclusively in Upper and Central Italy, are distributed, according to the reckoning of Servi ⁸), as follows: agriculturists 0.7 per cent., artisans 4 per cent., landowners 5,6 per cent., religious service 9,3 per cent., liberal professions 27,6 per cent., officials 120 per cent. (yet there are only 100 per cent. in all), servants 16 per cent., military, etc., 13 per cent., trade and industry 177 per cent.
(To be concluded.)
⁸) Cf. also Lombroso l. c. cap. IX passim.