Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 34
(continued from page 1)
…the Conservatives and the Orthodox. Between the first two there is the same difference as between a sewing-needle and a pin. Grasp the one, and you are pricked at both ends; touch the other, and you are scratched on one side only. The Reform movement has conjured up the spirit of Jewish nationalism. It is the cult of a number of ladies, devoted worshippers of mass-like Kaddish prayers, who are in a position to bring their Christian friends into their un-Jewish temples. It is beyond my power of judgment to decide whether Reform will hold out beyond the second generation. Opinions differ, but it is certain that 75 per cent. of the grandchildren of the present-day Reformers in America will be unable, in matters of Judaism, to tell their right hand from their left.
As for Conservatism, it is an attempt to moderate Reform, and is therefore despised by both extremes. Yet it is not without a certain saving grace; but how much it will save is still an open question.
Orthodoxy is the most interesting problem. There are various shades of Orthodoxy, which may be discerned as one walks from the upper to the lower end of the East Side of New York. Whatever good qualities Orthodoxy possesses are frittered away by the want of organisation. Moreover, Orthodoxy — through enormous blunders, quite different from any that the Jews commit in Europe — has no hold upon the young generation; and unless some restraining influence makes itself felt in the near future, Orthodoxy, it seems to me, will advance like a tortoise, while Reform follows after it at a hare's pace.
New York reminds me of an octopus; its tentacles clasp everything that comes within its reach, and this embrace has a remarkable influence upon the people. The Jewish population of this city is estimated at over half a million, and a whole quarter of the town is given over to them; and yet this quarter does not wear the aspect of Sabbath or festival peace. The Jew who left Russia in full piety is often to be found, after the lapse of but a single month, at the other extreme. The younger generation, the sons of the Orthodox, scarcely know the Jewish calendar. What the girls know of the two thousand years of faith, suffering and martyrdom I dare not ask. Ignorance has undoubtedly brought religious degeneration in its train, and the natural consequences of a hard struggle for existence, the cramped and wretched dwellings, lead me to believe that demoralisation of another kind has not been wanting either.
Moreover, the community is divided into two camps: the "uptown" element, which for the most part has probably never learned anything about Judaism and Jews, and which would like to educate the "downtowners," of whom the older masters, if not always, are practisers of Judaism and have no desire to accept instruction.
The American air provokes effervescence, and there are people here who believe they have done much when they have talked much about something. Add to this the circumstance that their speeches run to the grandiose, and it produces the impression of what the Americans call "bluff."
One plan for regeneration within American Jewry is that which brought Prof. Schechter here to preside over the Theological Seminary. This was arranged by well-meaning people who have no personal knowledge of the needs of the poor. Theology is no antidote to the poison that prevails here. But the gain will be rabbis who possess more than a veneer of Judaism.
Another hopeful influence making itself felt here is that of the "B'nei Brith," which, together with the local "Jewish World," is working to Judaise the younger generation. This Judaising is truly necessary for the whole of those classes which receive a modern education in which "Jewishness" is entirely lacking.
As a Zionist I find that what is lacking here above all is the Jewish national spirit. I have strayed so far from the basis of the activity I mean to begin this year in order to turn the most earnest attention to the cultural programme, for before Zionism can attain any considerable importance here, the education of the people towards it must have been carried through. This Jewry is very greatly secularised; and hand in hand with this has gone the abandonment of the old standard of Judaism, of the feeling of community and kinship.
Zionism is here too often regarded as a charitable rather than a national endeavour. And while from afar I thought that the former must be the solution for America, I have to-day come to the conviction that Zionism as a national idea is an urgent necessity precisely for the Jews in America. So long as the Jews in Eastern Europe remain in their present sad condition, there is no need to fear that they will forget the Jewish traditions; but he who comes over here would have to stand firm against the overwhelming character of his surroundings.
In the chaotic conditions that prevail in American Judaism, every rabbi who strives after reputation seeks to hit upon some new absurdity which he proclaims as his ideal of Judaism. Thus it has come about that one rabbi "receives" "confirmands" "into the House of Israel (!)," as though he were a priest; another writes in a book that the Jews have no national characteristics whatever; and of a third the newspapers print, under headlines a foot high, interviews meant to justify the transfer of the Sabbath to Sunday. The highest achievement of this kind was the discovery that oysters are — vegetables, and that the eating of these bivalves is permitted to Jews!
The Zionists have not yet fully grasped their mission in this country. One of the finest days of my life was that which I spent in a public park in Philadelphia in the company of Jewish boys and girls, singing uplifting and stirring Jewish songs. That was one of the few purposeful efforts to hold the young generation within the bounds of the old hearth.
If Judaism in America is to be saved from dissolution and destruction, the national doctrine, Zionism, alone can accomplish it; and if the ranks and hosts of New York, which have hitherto not rendered adequate work for our national cause, would give up the parading and picking-over of their manifold grievances, they would find before them the greatest field for Zionist activity that stands at our disposal anywhere. For the American Jews — renegade as they appear to me from many a point of view — have one wonderful quality: even the richest among them are ready to learn something and take good advice well; they are, further, charitable, and, further, they suffer — in the free Republic! — from social ostracism. The
