Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 30 · 25 July 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 30.

(continued from page 1)

…has succeeded, or is at least on the way to success! Because of several villages a single one has not gone to smash.

And such an assertion is put forward by the President of the Anglo Jewish Association—at a time when the misère in Roumania threatens to become simply appalling. To speak only of Roumania. In the whole East of Europe, but also at all the other new and old points of settlement, Jewry is one single sigh, one single groan. And Mr. Claude Montefiore points to the few families of Moisesville in Argentina.

We Zionists are a discontented society. These few families are too few for us.

Afterword to the Meeting of the German

Rabbinical Association.

On the 7th and 8th of this month the general meeting of the German Rabbinical Association sat at Frankfort-on-Main. As we reported in No. 25, Dr. Gronemann of Hanover had intended to bring Zionism up for discussion at this conference, by moving that the Rabbinical Association revise its peculiar ban against Zionism, issued now five years ago. By what secret powers Dr. Gronemann was induced not to bring in the motion aimed at this, or to withdraw the motion already brought in and to stay away from the meeting, is not known to us. Yet this general meeting of the Rabbinical Association is likely to have been the last among whose subjects of deliberation no place was granted to our aspirations. We are entitled to this surmise not only by an incident which revealed to us the good will of a considerable part of those attending the meeting to gain clarity as to the nature of Zionism, but also by observations of a general kind.

Like the sphere of activity of the modern Jewish community in general, so too the field of work of the contemporary rabbis widens from day to day; indeed, through the sharpening of the distress of our people as a whole, it is gradually undergoing a complete displacement. This, too, came to light in a clear and characteristic manner at the rabbinical conference that occupies us here. Whereas at earlier meetings of German rabbis, besides professional questions, it was chiefly matters of the "cure of souls" and of ritual that came up for discussion, and the intervals were filled by self-satisfied cultivators of pulpit eloquence who, instead of their accustomed "devout listeners," for a change bored their honoured colleagues with new variations on the worn-out theme of the Mission, the deliberations of the German Rabbinical Association this time extended to deeply serious socio-political problems of Jewish life in our time. A report was delivered on combating the Jewish traffic in girls, another on "The Rabbi's Share in the Solution of Social Tasks." Beside these, to be sure, there was also an unctuous address on "The Significance of Judaism in the Present," in which the much-overworked "world mission" was once more tormented to a pitiable degree. This, however, alters little in the fact that within the field of vision of the German rabbinate—be it only at the very edge—the great living problems of Judaism are beginning to emerge.

And therefore we venture to predict that the latest general meeting of the German Rabbinical Association will have been the last at which our Zionist aspirations have not found the consideration due to them. In the speech with which Rechtsanwalt Dr. Plotke welcomed the meeting on behalf of the Frankfort Jewish community, he said, with reference to the item of the agenda which aims at combating the traffic in girls, that this was an evil "which has spread in the most deplorable manner in the lands where our co-religionists, herded together, can neither live nor die. There it is needful to trace the causes and to find the remedies, for the welfare of Judaism and for the salvation of mankind." Well then, the causes of the evil Dr. Plotke has characterised briefly and aptly; but the remedy, and indeed the one and radical remedy, follows of itself: Give the herded-together Jewish masses a home where they can live in a manner worthy of human beings! Then, together with the traffic in human beings, we shall have rooted out countless other accursed abuses. By circulars, elections of committees and "friendly warnings," however, the deep-eaten social cancers of a national organism cannot be done away with. The more discerning rabbis will at last tell themselves this, and will recognise the truth that lies in the demands of Zionism.

As yet, it is true, most German rabbis feel before Zionism a shyness and a dread which would decidedly be bound to seem amusing, were not the shyness of the light and the dread of the truth quite so shameful. A single rabbi, Dr. Eschelbacher of Berlin, found the courage to point out at the meeting the beneficent effects of the Zionist idea. He reported on the subject "What is to be done for the religious and moral education of youth that has left school?" and in the course of his remarks came to speak of the Jewish students' associations, of which he said that on the whole they stand upon a Zionist basis, at the same time appreciatively emphasising that they display a healthy Jewish self-respect and lovingly cultivate the spiritual treasures of Judaism.

These remarks aroused at the presidential table and among most of those attending the meeting a state of mind which, according to the newspaper reports before us, we must positively describe as panic. We here give verbatim the exceedingly characteristic report of the Mainz Israelit on this part of the proceedings:

"The excursion into Zionist territory—the speaker, by the way, stressed at the end that he himself was not a Zionist—gave some, the chairman among them, occasion to propose that no discussion of the address be entered upon, but that the assent of the meeting be declared merely to the thesis, and to this alone. The chairman, who conducts the proceedings as a skilful diplomat and anxiously seeks to avoid closer debate on every overly divisive question, remarked that the speaker had indeed not had the intention of throwing Zionism into the debate, but that the opportunity had tempted him to do so. For almost half an hour the exchange lasted on the question: Discussion, or no discussion and merely adoption of the thesis? The course of the proceedings grew ever livelier. The Bureau unanimously declared the proposal 'No discussion' adopted. But since vehement objection was raised against this estimate, a count was taken. The result was the elimination of the Zionist apple of discord by 36 votes to 22. At the same time the thesis is thereby adopted."

One sees that there were among the rabbis, after all, 22 stout-hearted men who did not shrink from a serious discussion of Zionism, nay, the need