No. 28 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…and exhaustive. But even without such completeness it is not hard, on the strength of the evidence already at hand, to understand under what difficult conditions the life of our fellow-Jews in the capital on the Neva laboriously drags itself along . . .
That the Jews in Russia are declining physically in general we learn from the statistical data which the Polish physician Tolwinski has published in the recently issued scientific work "W naszych sprawach." Tolwinski was for fully 12 years physician to the recruiting commission in the district of Lubartow in the Government of Warsaw, and thus had ample opportunity to observe the physical development of the Jews. From his data we learn the following: among the 7417 recruits enlisted there were 1006 Jews, whose average height was 161.3 centimetres; 3.5 centimetres less, in comparison with the average height of the Christians. The girth of the chest, too, is smaller among the Jews than among the Christians: the chest girth among the Poles amounts to 86.3, among the Jews to only 81.1 centimetres . . . . And what Dr. Tolwinski saw in the district of Lubartow may well be established in all other localities of the Vistula region as well . . .
A Proposal to the Congress.
Under this title Mr. S. Wilk of Kowno advocates, in No. 24 of "Die Welt," an innovation whereby every Zionist who once pays 10–15 roubles as shekel into an "iron fund" shall have the lifelong right to vote and to be elected to the Congress.
This proposal calls for sharp and swift rejection before it causes confusion.
The innovation would needs strike dead the ideas that animate the institution of the shekel.
We Zionists created the shekel tax with a view to the one paid at the Biblical numbering of the people. We too wish to count our fighting men every year and to assure ourselves of the increase or decrease of our strength.
The periodical payment of the shekel is a holy and symbolic act, the token of our unwavering readiness for sacrifice. The introduction of a kind of subscription desecrates the act and obscures its meaning. Indeed, the custom already widespread to-day of collecting the shekel in instalments together with the monthly society dues is to be censured. It is, to be sure, more convenient for both parties, but in this way the independent purpose of the shekel no longer reaches the payer's consciousness.
Mr. Wilk, in proposing to create an "iron fund," may have had in mind that it should secure the covering of our future expenses should the self-sacrificing spirit of the Zionists no longer suffice for them. Such doubts ill become us! If the Zionist spirit should ever sink so low that we could not even raise our administrative expenses, then the best-endowed fund will not help us! Do we not see the quarter-milliard francs of the "Ica," in the hands of degenerate administrators, bringing our people a curse instead of a blessing!
Wilk's proposals evidently rest upon an imitation of the National Fund and its Golden Book. Yet the purposes to which the shekel and the National Fund are applied are fundamentally different.
The National Fund is from the outset intended to accumulate as large a capital as possible as quickly as possible, in order one day to place it, in its entirety or at least in mighty portions, at the disposal of the Jewish people for the acquisition of land. The hoarding, which is here usefully promoted by the institution of a Golden Book and a hundred other means, has no meaning in the case of the shekel, which is to cover, and need cover, only the current expenses of each administrative year.
Weightiest of all, however, are the objections which must be raised against Wilk's proposals from the democratic spirit of Zionism and of the shekel institution.
At the moment when the richer Jew can purchase by a larger money payment the — and, what is more, chartered — privilege of a lifelong right to vote for the Congress, the splendid, genuinely Jewish principle that one shekel-payer is of equal worth with another, Rothschild with the last schnorrer, as members of the people, is breached and shattered. Soon the caste of "lifelong" shekel magnates will look down contemptuously upon the shekel proletarians who pay merely their one Krone a year.
And then, where is the guarantee that the Oscher whom a whim drives to-day to a shekel subscription may not, in two or three years, have become an enraged enemy of Zion, who exercises his well-acquired, documented franchise against us, to the injury of the Congress and its great tasks?
Thank God, our Congress is no friend of such lifelong entitlements. This it proved in 1899 and 1900 by its tenacious resistance to the appointment, desired by Dr. Herzl, of lifelong directors for the Colonial Bank.*) In the whole proposal the monetary element of the "practical man" thrusts itself forward in a questionable manner against the ideal element of the Zionist! So, no unripe, ill-considered innovations! Every year on Shekel Day, now as heretofore, let every fighter for Zion profess his adherence to his people and its future by a small money offering. Dr. E. Michael Zweig.
Tribune.
Appeal!
Jewish Fellow-Students!
On 24th September 1902 the Third Congress of the international students' federation "Corda Fratres" takes place in Budapest. Holding strictly to the territorial principle, the previous congresses created, besides the "Sections Nationales," which bear the respective names, three special sections as well: the "Section Polonaise," the "Section Tchèque" and the "Section Spéciale." Into this last, besides little nationalities of the second rank, the Jews too were placed.
Fellow-students! If we still set any store by honour, we must strive to win for ourselves at the next Congress a "Section Juive" of our own. We must there compel the same recognition as has been accorded to others.
The magnificent struggle which our people has waged for its existence for thousands of years in every quarter of the globe gives us the right to claim for ourselves at the World Students' Congress at least the same regard and appreciation as the Poles, Czechs, Armenians and Finns. In order to attain this end we must appear at the Congress in great numbers and act there as one body.
The call therefore goes out to all Jewish fellow-students, men and women, to hold out the definite prospect of their appearance in Budapest in as great numbers as possible, by making known their addresses and sending the membership fee of 3 Kronen to the Working Committee (address: cand. jur. Josef Haas, III., Kollonitzgasse 7).
Fellow-students! Take our words to heart! It is a question not only of winning equal rights, but of vigorous propaganda for our idea among the indifferent, assimilationist Jews of Budapest:
Fellow-students! Come in masses! The Working Committee.
*
P.S. Apart from the single minimal payment of 3 Kronen the journey costs very little, since the Royal Hungarian State Railways have granted free travel to members of the Congress, and other great reductions are also in prospect.
*
Extract from the Statutes and the Regulations.
Fundamental Article.
III. Every student has the right to belong to the "Bund" as soon as he, at a university or any
*) Rests upon an error of the contributor. No such proposal was ever made. Editor's note.