Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 28
(continued from page 1)
…that the attempt to exclude the poor oppressed Jews can succeed. It will then be proved that England is a territory thoroughly suited to immigration.
I cannot regard the question which lies before the Commission as a comparatively unimportant one, such as, for instance, the question in which district of the city people are to live, or whether any overcrowding takes place.
As to that question, I have little to say so far as it concerns the East of London. All that I know rests upon acquaintance with the evidence given before the Commission, and this evidence has convinced me that the above-named questions of local domicile or local overcrowding are for the most part accidents, that the driving forces are identical with those which elsewhere work against our people, and which I have called "the forces springing from envy in labour, from inherited prejudice, and from supposed self-defence."
These forces are at work here, and however much one may conceal it from oneself, the cry for restriction of alien immigration arises from the presence of a perceptible number of Jews and from the wish that this number should not be perceptibly increased. You have had witnesses here who have set forth to you the causes why Jews from Eastern Europe are induced to come hither and to America.
Permit me to assert that it is by no means chiefly material comforts that draw them hither. For the most part it is moral things, namely the ardent desire to come into conditions which are in harmony with human aspirations, the desire to enjoy that freedom of life and of mind which the Jew in Eastern Europe under present conditions does not know at all.
On the question whether immigration in itself is good for this country or not, it is not for me to judge. At best I am a partial witness. It may be that — because these immigrants possess certain virtues in a marked degree, such as industry, temperance and thrift — they are for that very reason possibly less welcome than if they possessed unadulterated vices. So far as Eastern Europe is concerned, which is decisive for the whole of Jewry because it contains so great a part of the entire Jewish people, the situation grows worse from day to day.
I need only point to Roumania, as a striking example of the method by which Jews are compelled to leave their homes. Even after they have served in the army they remain aliens in the land of their birth. The Commission will please understand that the Jews, more than all other peoples — but certainly not less — are patriotic, and this circumstance heightens the tragedy of their lot.
In mediaeval German the word "Elend" meant both misery and exile, and from time immemorial these terms have been synonymous for Jewry.
Nevertheless, you must not suppose that the Jew tears himself away from the land of his birth the moment his situation there becomes unfavourable, and that you here in England have answered the question once and for all; on the contrary, I must congratulate this country on having instituted an inquiry at a time which, according to my conviction, will come to be regarded almost as the initial stage.
The perceptible number of Jews which I mentioned just now will probably increase, and that in consequence of immigration under present circumstances; for I note that even Mr. Arnold White does not propose to attempt to exclude the immigrants who are the victims of persecution.
I cannot say that I am astonished at the despair which, at the very beginning of the Jewish question, has taken hold of the Jewish community in England.
In the numerous speeches which I and others of like mind with me have delivered in England, I have warned the English Jews against remaining unprepared in the face of a state of things which they hoped would never arise.
What does surprise me is the depth of the despair, the extent of the unpreparedness, which hits upon nothing but the senseless proposal of local distribution as a remedy for the evil which, with giant strides, is gathering over and around the English Jews, precisely as has already been the case elsewhere.
It may in truth be asserted that this proposal is conceived in that antiquated spirit which is called "Jewish charity." Jewish charity still rests upon the principles which sufficed for conditions in the Middle Ages. The altered conditions of modern times, however, have grown beyond it.
In olden times Jewish charity had the purpose of standing helpfully by those who travelled from place to place and had been reduced to beggary by persecution, and the guiding motive may for the most part have been the circumstance that no one knew how quickly the almsgiver of to-day might become the beggar of to-morrow.
All Jews were, if not yet actually, then prospectively, brothers in misfortune. But in those times the distance which the wandering Jew had to cover was a journey on foot of perhaps only a few miles, and consequently the help he required needed only to suffice for that short distance. To-day, however, the means of communication have outgrown this charitable system, so that the London benefactors, for example, must pay for the passing-on of Jews emigrating from Russia to America; and the old system has reached such a degree of confusion that it can no longer confine itself to helping people, but the money which was intended to free the Jews from their wretched situation has been used to plunge them back into it.
This was chiefly the case with the Roumanian refugees who came to England, and whose only reception consisted in the remedy: "Back to the fatherland by police convoy," a fatherland into which they return as aliens!!
That is what I meant when I said that the system of Jewish charity is bankrupt. Its real purpose is to convey Jews from a bad situation into better conditions; but when it is compelled to bring them from better conditions into a worse situation, that is a testimony that the method has proved a fiasco.
Then comes the proposal of assimilation. Those who put it forward as a solution of the Jewish question do not mean by it a merely apish assimilation, equivalent to a slavish and often vulgar imitation. They probably mean assimilation by way of intermarriage, so that the little stream of our race shall merge and lose itself in the broad stream of the peoples among whom it lives. As regards intermarriage, there are two points of view, the question
